Baxter's Restaurant
4919 1st Coast Hwy, Fernandina Beach
(904) 277-4503
Customers' Favorites
Twin Lobster Tail
French Onion Soup
Blue Cheese Steak
Chicken Marsala
Fresh Grouper
Fish and Chips
Surf and Turf
Fried Shrimp
Key Lime Pie
Rack of Lamb
Menu
Photos
+42 photos
+41 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
I had the 14 oz ribeye steak… full of flavor, tender, and juicy. The vegetable medley was the same.. seasoned to perfection! Then I topped it off with some cheesecake. Phenomenal food!
This place has an old vintage charm atmosphere. At the bar you almost expect to see Dean Martin sitting there. The staff is on top of things. The food is great. My wife had steak diane and I had the eggplant. Both were wonderful. We also had fried green tomatoes and shrimp as an appetizer... very good. Love this place!
The food was fantastic. The service from Susan was fantastic. The atmosphere...it could use a refresh for sure.
I'm not sure what these other reviews are talking about with regards to the steaks being chewy. I had a medium NY Strip and it was perfect. My wife had a filet and man if was melt in your mouth.
I'm not sure what these other reviews are talking about with regards to the steaks being chewy. I had a medium NY Strip and it was perfect. My wife had a filet and man if was melt in your mouth.
You May Also Like
Bar Zin - 4924 1st Coast Hwy
![]()
Bar, American, Wine Bar, New American
Cucina South - 4828 1st Coast Hwy #1
![]()
Seafood, Italian
Lagniappe - 4810 1st Coast Hwy
![]()
French, Southern, Cajun/Creole, Pet Friendly