One of my favorite stops in the Keys. Reel Catch never disappoints, and Mei is a delightful server!
Dominick Austin
Very confusing billing issue.
Amanda Foster Brown
We loved our stay at Amara Cay over spring break! Will certainly be back. Fish Like a Local was an incredible experience at Amara Cay and Three Waters for our whole family! We have been to the keys several times participating in multiple fishing experiences on charters and off bridges and Patrick was by far the best guide we have ever had! He is so friendly, fun, informative and patient! We were fortunate enough to fish with him our first day and it was a hit. We made it a point to be sure we fished with him again prior to the end of our trip and will be sure to check him out the next time we are in the keys. Highly recommend!
Todd
Friendliest staff- so helpful and polite. Food was excellent!! Beautiful setting. We had a lovely time. If I had to give one suggestion it would be bigger tables. It was a challenge getting food and drinks on the table with four of us.
eileen
our waitress Mae was unbelievable. so professional and kind. the food we had was also amazing. would definitely recommend
John
The service was very attentive and the waiter was helpful in selecting our dishes. Everyone in our group was pleased with their selection.
Cindy
Server was very kind & attentive. Food was so-so, not really worth the price in my opinion (we had prime rib special, snapper and seafood cioppino). Chef seems to enjoy using tomatoes in many of the dishes (chicken piccata, snapper, seafood cioppino) which is unusual. Ambiance was lovely (we sat outside) but sadly the musical entertainment wasn't great; choice of songs was nice but delivery not-so-much. With all of the great restaurant offerings in Islamorada I don't think we'll return to ReelCatch.
Uta Maharaj
We’ve tried most of the local hot spots and nothing came close to the amazing food we enjoyed here! Everything was 10/10
Tuba Aksoy
Food, service and view were all five stars!
Scott Neuens
Had an amazing Valentines day dinner. We are always happy coming here.
Produits de mauvaises qualités, préparés de manière très basique, très mauvais rapport qualité/prix qui plus est, à fuir
Susan
Had never been here before. Tried it on a quiet Monday night and was pleasantly surprised. Was skeptical when we walked in because at 6:30 bar and dining room were empty but it was a whole different vibe outside. Service was very attentive and timely. Food was delicious. Very nice surprise!
Joy E
Absolutely the best most wonderful bartender service ever when I dropped my phone in water ! The breakfast here was AMAZING. I would do without the rooster who stole half my eggs but the avocado toast was the best I’ve ever had. Fed me 2 meals. It was perfection. The view is stunning. They also allow dogs which I love. Dinner was great too. Highly recommend and will absolutely be back!
Jessie Besic
Breakfast was ok. Pastries were store bought. Our waiter appeared to also be responsible for outdoor cleanup.
Will Dorsey Eden
The food was outstanding, and only exceeded by the service. Our waitress Yvena proactively helped us find the best options and made sure we had an exceptional experience.
One of my favorite stops in the Keys. Reel Catch never disappoints, and Mei is a delightful server!
Very confusing billing issue.
We loved our stay at Amara Cay over spring break! Will certainly be back. Fish Like a Local was an incredible experience at Amara Cay and Three Waters for our whole family! We have been to the keys several times participating in multiple fishing experiences on charters and off bridges and Patrick was by far the best guide we have ever had! He is so friendly, fun, informative and patient! We were fortunate enough to fish with him our first day and it was a hit. We made it a point to be sure we fished with him again prior to the end of our trip and will be sure to check him out the next time we are in the keys. Highly recommend!
Friendliest staff- so helpful and polite. Food was excellent!! Beautiful setting. We had a lovely time. If I had to give one suggestion it would be bigger tables. It was a challenge getting food and drinks on the table with four of us.
our waitress Mae was unbelievable. so professional and kind. the food we had was also amazing. would definitely recommend
The service was very attentive and the waiter was helpful in selecting our dishes. Everyone in our group was pleased with their selection.
Server was very kind & attentive. Food was so-so, not really worth the price in my opinion (we had prime rib special, snapper and seafood cioppino). Chef seems to enjoy using tomatoes in many of the dishes (chicken piccata, snapper, seafood cioppino) which is unusual. Ambiance was lovely (we sat outside) but sadly the musical entertainment wasn't great; choice of songs was nice but delivery not-so-much. With all of the great restaurant offerings in Islamorada I don't think we'll return to ReelCatch.
We’ve tried most of the local hot spots and nothing came close to the amazing food we enjoyed here! Everything was 10/10
Food, service and view were all five stars!
Had an amazing Valentines day dinner. We are always happy coming here.
Restaurantji Recommends
Produits de mauvaises qualités, préparés de manière très basique, très mauvais rapport qualité/prix qui plus est, à fuir
Had never been here before. Tried it on a quiet Monday night and was pleasantly surprised. Was skeptical when we walked in because at 6:30 bar and dining room were empty but it was a whole different vibe outside. Service was very attentive and timely. Food was delicious. Very nice surprise!
Absolutely the best most wonderful bartender service ever when I dropped my phone in water ! The breakfast here was AMAZING. I would do without the rooster who stole half my eggs but the avocado toast was the best I’ve ever had. Fed me 2 meals. It was perfection. The view is stunning. They also allow dogs which I love. Dinner was great too. Highly recommend and will absolutely be back!
Breakfast was ok. Pastries were store bought. Our waiter appeared to also be responsible for outdoor cleanup.
The food was outstanding, and only exceeded by the service. Our waitress Yvena proactively helped us find the best options and made sure we had an exceptional experience.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...