Hillary's Chicago Pizza

1974 US1, St. Augustine
(904) 209-5960

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Sausage Thin Crust Pizza and Italian Beef Sandwich
BYO Cheese Sharing Deep Dish Pizza
mfw - Deep Dish Pizza Sharing Size
Spinach Ricotta Mushroom - Sharing
Cheese or BYO Family Deep Dish
Chicago Style Deep Dish Pizza
Thin Crust BYO Cheese Pizza
Tavern Style Sausage Pizza
Hot Italian Beef Sandwich
Pretzel and Beer Cheese

Menu

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+14 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+13 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Hilary’s Pizzas has the best deep dish pizza in St. Augustine! The crust is buttery and crisp, the sauce is rich, and the cheese pulls are unreal. Every bite is loaded with flavor and quality ingredients. If you’re craving authentic deep dish, this place is a must. Friendly staff, cozy vibes, and seriously satisfying pizza!
July 2025
Went couple weeks ago. Gluten-free options here but not dedicated
My dad and I are both from Chicago and he said the regular Chicago pizza was amazing!!!!!
Like most people from Chicago we're not after the deep dish he got thin crust.
I had a gluten-free option and it was also amazing even if I could tell it wasn't the crust I craved 😂
I asked for a salad as well, mid meal, she forgot never brought it, but I was okay with that and...
July 2025
Excellent Chicago style thin cracker crust & deep dish pizza! Being married to a midwesterner, he was so happy to find a little taste of home here in St. Augustine! Pizza is fresh and delicious.
Great drink specials and cute family friendly atmosphere. Highly recommend Hillary’s Chicago Pizza!
July 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

904 Nutrition - 1972 US-1
Juice, Juice Bar & Smoothies
Caribbean & Soule Restaurant - 1968 US 1 South
Jamaican, Caribbean
Tsaôcaa St Augustine: Fried chicken, Smoothie - 1948 US-1
Bubble Tea, Juice Bar & Smoothies

Hillary's Chicago Pizza

1974 US1, St. Augustine, FL 32086
(904) 209-5960