Holey Moley Bagel Shop

Name: Holey Moley Bagel Shop
Address: 8616 Baymeadows Rd, Jacksonville, Florida, 32256, US
Telephone: (904) 503-7496
Price range: $
Rating: 3.9

$ • Bagels, American

Hours:
8616 Baymeadows Rd, Jacksonville
(904) 503-7496

Menu Order Online

About Holey Moley Bagel Shop

Holey Moley Bagel Shop is a popular spot to enjoy a New York deli vibe with a wide variety of bagel flavors and specialty sandwiches. Customers praise the bagels as some of the best, comparing them favorably to those in New York City, with the blueberry and Giulia bagels especially bursting with flavor. The shop offers fresh bagels sourced weekly from the Bronx, and the service is known for being fast and friendly, making it a quick and enjoyable breakfast or lunch stop. The menu includes delicious chop cheese sandwiches and the steak egg and cheese sandwich, which many customers recommend. The shop also features a great iced coffee selection, with portions that are large for the price.

The atmosphere is simple and plain, reminiscent of traditional New York delis, which some appreciate. The staff, including the owner, are friendly and welcoming, and the shop provides a reliable and refreshing experience each visit. Customers have noted that the bagels are warm and chewy, with thick cream cheese, making the prices worth it. However, some have experienced issues with the toasting of bagels, which can affect flavor, and others have mentioned the interior sometimes looking in disrepair or the beverage case being out of order. It is recommended to arrive early since they close at 1 pm. Overall, Holey Moley Bagel Shop offers a straightforward, satisfying experience that many look forward to repeating.