“Great views from the dock, you can buy fish food to feed the catfish. The kids menu was fantastic as it includes dishes such as salmon and shrimp for $10 for the kids who eat more than just Mac and cheese. The food was good, large portions. The staff were very friendly and attentive. Plenty of parking and a gift shop on premise. Check this place out if you are nearby!“
“Excellent overall! Three in our party- we ordered crab cakes, grouper and shrimp for appetizers. For the grouper and shrimp, both breaded, the breading was crisp and tasty. The sauces were excellent, not overpowering and complimented rather than detracted from the base offering. For the main dish, the bourbon salmon was served beyond just warm but not overdone. The bourbon glacé was the consistency of chocolate syrup, thick enough to stay on the fish without running off but not gluey or gummy. It was excellent. The fried shrimp batter was just peppery enough to add depth to what is often a relatively bland dish and the shrimp was cooked, but not overcooked so it was tender and moist. Finally, we had Parmesan crusted cod, pan seared. The fish was lightly breaded such that the Parmesan came through and the coating was crisp but not burnt. As with the other dishes, the fish was flavorful, moist and not overdone. Our server was attentive without being overbearing and kept the meal moving but not rushed. We never felt ignored or hurried. Perfect pace to enjoy a meal. We travelled about an hour to go to the Magic Oyster and I'd do it again.“
“I have been here so many times and it's not real bad. Not my favorite, the food is mediocre, I think too many things on the menu. This particular experience was the worst one yet. I got the salad salad with grilled chicken. They couldn't toss the chicken in hot sauce like they can the fried ones. ?♀️ When the salad came, the chicken was sooooo dry. Smh. My co-worker order the grilled Mahi sandwich, and said that was VERY dry as well. It's a real shame since it was my co-workers first time there; not sure she will go back.“
“We checked into the Old Colorado Inn on Friday evening and decided to have a light meal at the Sneaki Tiki located there. I had the blackened fish tacos and my friend had the coconut crusted shrimp. We shared a side salad. We also had a side of French Fries. All the food including dessert were excellent. However we were somewhat disappointed with the French Fries. They were not at all crisp. The server was very personable and efficient. So our taste buds were satisfied but our ears were irritated by the terrible performer who sang so pitchy that we had a hard time recognizing the tunes. In three words he seemed loud and drunk.“
Bar & Grill • $
“I had Jeff's 'Quesadilla with Shrimp' but Can also get it with Chicken. Comes with Sour Cream, Guacamole, & Salsa Cups. Maybe it was the Awesome sound of Live Music of the Kevin McCloughlin Band, But I think that's the Best Quesadilla I've ever had! It's listed as an appetizer, but it was plenty filling for me. Pairs well with beer or wine.?“
Bar & Grill • $
“Usually our pickup order is perfect, but the last time one of our 3 Impossible Burgers had zero toppings. Just bread and a patty. After adding our own toppings from the fridge it was perfect so just a minor inconvenience and the fries were still perfect.Vegetarian options: They serve the Impossible Burger and it seems like they patty them up in house. Delicious with whatever toppings requested... They usually get the toppings right and the fries are always excellent“
“We went with friends from the area who told us it was their favorite place to go for fish. My wife ordered the Fish & Chips fried. I ordered the Fish & Chips Jamaican Jerk. It was as good as "advertised". It was so good, we went back 2 weeks later when we were Stuart for the Art Festival. Every bit as good this visit. And our waitress was personable and very attentive. Overall, it was a great find!“