We came to Italian Food Company after feeling like we wanted to eat dinner that wasn't seafood, did some randomly Googling and discovered this place. Martica was our server. She was fun, funny, kind and informative. We ordered the Montanara appetizer, as well as the chicken pesto genovese and meat lasagna. For dessert we tried 3 different options: pistachio cake, tiramisu and triple chocolate mousse. Every single thing we ordered was top notch tasty. It was so good that we came back the next night and ordered Bruschetta topped with prosciutto, burrata and chopped tomatoes, as well as spaghetti with meatballs, chicken genovese and meat lasagna. AND two more desserts: lemon pie and pistachio cake. Leann was our server the second night. She was fun, attentive and amazing. We are so happy to have discovered such a great place to eat, with the best service! We will definitely eat here the next time we are in town!
Gabby E.
Came here with my toddler for some bites. Ordered the bruschetta and meatballs. They came in a matter of 3-4 minutes, which I found odd... The meatballs tasted raw and the bruschetta wasn't all that. The worse part is that my waitress didn't come check on me til the end and when I addressed what I felt she tried to argue with me. She was appalled by my comment of the meatballs & told me "you must not like the taste because we've never heard this before here" "they are pre-cooked". Never did I get the benefit of the doubt from her & when I finished paying she just walked away. Won't be coming here again. Don't waste your money with this crappy service. I left hungry & with my stomach hurting.
Stephanie B.
Great spot in Key Largo with good food, good service and live outdoor music! I recommend making reservations as seating is limited. Love the keys vibe with an Italian restaurant!
Thomas H.
Overall, a great meal and service. We arrived just before 5pm and had plenty of seating choices. Our waitress took our drink and appetizer order right away. We asked for garlic bread ( not on the menu) and it was nicely toasted and not too strong. Our fettuccine alfredo was perfectly al-dente with creamy sauce that was not too garlicky. We were checked on often and had a great time. Some music had very "adult lyrics" and seemed out of place though. Got our desserts to-go, as we had plenty of food, but could not pass on the plentiful selection.
Gigi B.
I went with my daughter to have a pizza with prosciutto and arugula. That was delicious. Seriously then we also had a penny à la vodka. I wish that you didn't put any pancetta, but it was good. Also had the meatball appetizer they were excellent and chocolate mousse cake that was just OK, the service was very attentive and the girl was really nice and welcoming as well as the hostess cute little joint to go have a casual
TomnBeebs C.
What a lovely Italian restaurant. Music, colorful lights hanging from the trees, delicious Bruschetta and delicious pizza! A definite "must" to relax and enjoy authentic dining. Our waitress, Dilma was very attentive and we had excellent service.
Maggie M.
The pizza and vodka pasta were awesome!! The service was great and they also do a great birthday scene!
John O.
Looking for a great spot to eat in KL. This...is it. Not exaggerating here, this is some of the best Italian food we've ever had. Not super fancy, but a nice cozy spot with a great vibe. Great service and food. You have to get a pizza (we also had lasagna). Literally the best Neapolitan pizza I've ever had, and I've had it in Florence! Soooo good. Mange!!
Christine R.
Service was excellent and the food was great. I had the gluten free Ortolana Vegetable pizza and my husband had the Bolognese. We also split a house salad. Definitely one of the best gluten free crusts I've had. Ambience is great and they have definitely done everything they can to make it a nice "backyard feel" and to minimize the traffic noise at this Key Larfo location.
David F.
Great food! Our first visit as vacationers. You can tell this is a family owned establishment. We ordered pizzas and a sandwich and had way too much food! The pizza is tremendous especially the one with the bacon and hot tomato jam. When they say 6 pieces of pizza (L), it's enough for 4-6 people as the pieces are huge!! You can surely tell the San Marzano sauce is fresh and nothing from Dominos here :-) Delicious!!!
What a nice little surprise. Food was exceptionally good and I loved the vibe. Small home-cooked and authentic Italian restaurant in the Florida Keys felt really random and very wholesome. Would absolutely go back.
Chloe Sastqoue
tana was amazing 100% recommend loved it!
John Tollfree
Attentive knowledgable staff, Leanne our server was top dollar! Authentic Italian dishes were great.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers, Neapolitan Pizza
Jackson Forrester
Food was greatKid-friendliness: Awesome
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmigiana
Julia Parker
A special thank you to our server, Lee Ann, who made our experience even better.
We came to Italian Food Company after feeling like we wanted to eat dinner that wasn't seafood, did some randomly Googling and discovered this place. Martica was our server. She was fun, funny, kind and informative. We ordered the Montanara appetizer, as well as the chicken pesto genovese and meat lasagna. For dessert we tried 3 different options: pistachio cake, tiramisu and triple chocolate mousse. Every single thing we ordered was top notch tasty. It was so good that we came back the next night and ordered Bruschetta topped with prosciutto, burrata and chopped tomatoes, as well as spaghetti with meatballs, chicken genovese and meat lasagna. AND two more desserts: lemon pie and pistachio cake. Leann was our server the second night. She was fun, attentive and amazing. We are so happy to have discovered such a great place to eat, with the best service! We will definitely eat here the next time we are in town!
Came here with my toddler for some bites. Ordered the bruschetta and meatballs. They came in a matter of 3-4 minutes, which I found odd... The meatballs tasted raw and the bruschetta wasn't all that. The worse part is that my waitress didn't come check on me til the end and when I addressed what I felt she tried to argue with me. She was appalled by my comment of the meatballs & told me "you must not like the taste because we've never heard this before here" "they are pre-cooked". Never did I get the benefit of the doubt from her & when I finished paying she just walked away. Won't be coming here again. Don't waste your money with this crappy service. I left hungry & with my stomach hurting.
Great spot in Key Largo with good food, good service and live outdoor music! I recommend making reservations as seating is limited. Love the keys vibe with an Italian restaurant!
Overall, a great meal and service. We arrived just before 5pm and had plenty of seating choices. Our waitress took our drink and appetizer order right away. We asked for garlic bread ( not on the menu) and it was nicely toasted and not too strong. Our fettuccine alfredo was perfectly al-dente with creamy sauce that was not too garlicky. We were checked on often and had a great time. Some music had very "adult lyrics" and seemed out of place though. Got our desserts to-go, as we had plenty of food, but could not pass on the plentiful selection.
I went with my daughter to have a pizza with prosciutto and arugula. That was delicious. Seriously then we also had a penny à la vodka. I wish that you didn't put any pancetta, but it was good. Also had the meatball appetizer they were excellent and chocolate mousse cake that was just OK, the service was very attentive and the girl was really nice and welcoming as well as the hostess cute little joint to go have a casual
What a lovely Italian restaurant. Music, colorful lights hanging from the trees, delicious Bruschetta and delicious pizza! A definite "must" to relax and enjoy authentic dining. Our waitress, Dilma was very attentive and we had excellent service.
The pizza and vodka pasta were awesome!! The service was great and they also do a great birthday scene!
Looking for a great spot to eat in KL. This...is it. Not exaggerating here, this is some of the best Italian food we've ever had. Not super fancy, but a nice cozy spot with a great vibe. Great service and food. You have to get a pizza (we also had lasagna). Literally the best Neapolitan pizza I've ever had, and I've had it in Florence! Soooo good. Mange!!
Service was excellent and the food was great. I had the gluten free Ortolana Vegetable pizza and my husband had the Bolognese. We also split a house salad. Definitely one of the best gluten free crusts I've had. Ambience is great and they have definitely done everything they can to make it a nice "backyard feel" and to minimize the traffic noise at this Key Larfo location.
Great food! Our first visit as vacationers. You can tell this is a family owned establishment. We ordered pizzas and a sandwich and had way too much food! The pizza is tremendous especially the one with the bacon and hot tomato jam. When they say 6 pieces of pizza (L), it's enough for 4-6 people as the pieces are huge!! You can surely tell the San Marzano sauce is fresh and nothing from Dominos here :-) Delicious!!!
Restaurantji Recommends
What a nice little surprise. Food was exceptionally good and I loved the vibe. Small home-cooked and authentic Italian restaurant in the Florida Keys felt really random and very wholesome. Would absolutely go back.
tana was amazing 100% recommend loved it!
Attentive knowledgable staff, Leanne our server was top dollar! Authentic Italian dishes were great.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Lovers, Neapolitan Pizza
Food was greatKid-friendliness: Awesome
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmigiana
A special thank you to our server, Lee Ann, who made our experience even better.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5