5 Best Caterers in Key West

“Hats off to Abby and her team at Destination Catering for their service at our son's large wedding welcome reception on the beach. Everything was fabulous! Abby was professional and accommodating. Beautiful presentation. Delicious food. Joyful environment. And all of her team were equally gracious and attentive. Abby even brought items from her home to assist me in decorating the tables to create the right vibe for the event. They were very easy to work with and all of the guests loved the food. I highly recommend booking them for your next catered event.“

“Amazing meal for our 9 person group at our house. We had filet, stuffed yellowtail, etc. the appetizers were to die for and the bread was the best I ever had. Highly recommend.“

“From our very first call to the final toast, Great Events Catering exceeded every expectation for my daughter’s Key West wedding. Melissa was incredibly responsive, helpful, and generous with vendor recommendations from the start.

The tasting experience was truly elevated—and memorable enough that we talked about it for months leading up to the wedding. On the big day, the food was just as exceptional. Guests couldn’t stop raving during cocktail hour (the empanadas and crab cakes were instant favorites!), and dinner was absolutely superb. Even the dinnerware felt elegant and thoughtfully chosen.

What impressed us just as much was the service—glasses were never empty, and the staff was attentive without ever being intrusive.

From beginning to end, it was a flawless, first-class experience. We are so grateful!“

“Catered Affairs was the best decision I made for my wedding. The food and drinks were the best ever. Every single item and drink was absolutely great. Everyone raved about how amazing it was. Working with the team was wonderful. Quick to respond, organized, and accurate. I couldn’t have imagined a better catering company! If you’re having an event, book them!“

“The two things that people mentioned over and over again about the caterer at our wedding was that the meals were awesome and the bartenders were very friendly! From the first phone call with Chef Lea, I knew I was in good hands. He was very accommodating and quick to respond to emails. As a wedding DJ in Key West, I've had his meals before, but this was the first time I have ever hired him to cater an event. I really appreciated how he handled the planning stage with my wife and I. He listened to our vision, while adding in his own professional expertise, which made the dinner stations about as perfect as anyone could ever ask for. We had two bartenders who everyone felt were part of the family and enjoyed having conversations with. It's moments like these that really help create a nice atmosphere at a wedding reception and Key West Catering really knocked it out of the park 👏 PS: Get the Jamacian hot pot. That was the dish that people kept saying was their favorite and I would have to agree!“