17 Best Italian Restaurants in Key West

Bruschetta Francesca Italian • $$
112 Fitzpatrick St, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Taglier Misto Saluni E Formaggi
Spaghetti Pomodoro E Basilico
Paccheri Funghi E Salsiccia
Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo
Complimentary Bruschetta
Togliere Misto Salumi
Fettuccine Bolognese
Eggplant Parmigiana
Bruschetta Classica
Carpaccio Di Manzo

“Due to the weather, I found myself spending another night in Key West. I came across this quaint restaurant near my hotel. Francesca the owner is so sweet and friendly. Mario behind the bar was just great. He really knows the drinks and the food. I had the cream of zucchini soup. It was delicious large portion and great flavor. Two ladies at the bar shared their antipasto tray with me. Enjoyed both the tray and the ladies who shared it. I will definitely make this my first stop the next time I’m in Key West.“

4.7 Superb402 Reviews
Abbondanza Italian Restaurant Italian • $$
1208 Simonton St, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Linguine Al Pesto Con Gamberetti
Fettuccine Alfredo Alla Fungi
Bruschetta Al Peperonata
Spaghetti with Meatballs
Mozzarella in Carozza
Linguini with Clams
Spaghetti E Polpette
Vongole Pietrasanta
Spaghetti Calabrese
Eggplant Parmigiana

“Excellent food, above average friendly service and a warm cozy atmosphere! Spaghetti & meatballs and eggplant parm were both plentiful & delicious! Cool little bar, not a bad seat in the place! Looking forward to coming back again next year.“

4.6 Superb134 Reviews
La Trattoria Oceanside Italian • $$
3593 S Roosevelt Blvd, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Ossobuco When Available
Tortellini Alla Romana
Gnocchi Al Gorgonzola
Lasagna Alla Bolognese
Bread Dipping Sauce
Ravioli Trattoria
Bistecca Al Pepe
Mushroom Starter
Chocolate Mousse
Creme Brûlée

“Oh my goodness, what a wonderful experience we had when dining with you on November 30th! The food was incredible and service was outstanding! If you like martinis, they have many to choose from. We celebrated my husband’s birthday with a beautiful sunset view. (Thank you to the staff for making it extra special!)Seriously, a perfect dining experience! When in Key West, definitely dine here!“

4.4 Superb237 Reviews
Mangia Mangia Italian • $$
900 Southard St, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Spinach Fettuccini Alfredo with Jumbo Lump Backfin Blue Crabmeat
Mostaciolli with Broccoli Rabe Rappini
Chicken Parmesan with Alfredo Sauce
Pesto with Pinenuts & Walnuts
Spaghettini Alla Carbonara
Complementary Bread App
Spaghetti with Marinara
Beef Carpaccio Di Bue
Bollito Misto Di Mare
Linguine Con Vongole

“A true gem! Food was delicious, staff was courteous and atmosphere was outstanding. Highly recommended!!“

4.3 Superb180 Reviews
Antonia's Restaurant Italian • $$$
615 Duval St, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Fettuccine with Prosciutto Di Parma
Chianti Braised Lamb Osso Buco
Seafood Linguine Alla Vodka
Amaretto Coconut Cream Pie
Fettuccine Bolognese
Goat Cheese Souffle
Lasagne Bolognese
Imported Burrata
Chicken Milanese
Potato Gnocchi

“We had an incredible dinning experience. From the moment we enter the restaurant we were greeted by Ali the hosted and treated like family. Dwayne our server was excellent. Very friendly. We were never rushed. The food and atmosphere was perfect. We picked the perfect restaurant to celebrate my wife's birthday. Overall an awesome dining experience.“

4.2 Good228 Reviews
La Trattoria Restaurant Italian • $$
524 Duval St, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Spaghetti Alla Bolognese
Tortellini Alla Romana
Vitello Alla Parmigiana
Lasagna Alla Bolognese
Gnocchi Al Gorgonzola
Fettuccine Alfredo
Ravioli Trattoria
Chicken Marsala
Seafood Ravioli
Penne Venezia

“We ate dinner here in December 2023…we had bruschetta, soup, salads and my entree was the steak with peppercorn cream sauce….ive never tasted anything more delicious in my life! If I could give this restaurant a million stars I would! All of the food was absolutely delicious and the atmosphere was spot on for couples night out!! We are looking forward to coming back!“

4.2 Good250 Reviews
Roostica Italian • $$
5620 MacDonald Ave, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Hell's Kitchen Diavola Pizza
The Sicilian Deep Dish Pizza
Antipasto the Chopping Block
Homemade Baked Lasagna
Spaghetti & Meatballs
The Fig & Pig Pizza
Chicken Parmesan
Bobby's Meatball
Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Alfredo

“Amazing Gluten Free Pizza! Thankful for a Celiac Safe lunch. A must try wood-fired pizza ( and the chocolate tart was also really good).“

4.1 Good205 Reviews
Onlywood Grill Italian • $$
725 Caroline St, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Salsiccia E Friarelli Pizza with Sausages Broccoli Rabe and Homemade Mozzarella
Bruschetta Onlywood
Fried Mozzarella
Margherita Pizza
Mushroom Risotto
Pepperoni Pizza
Tomahawk Steak
Chicken Wings
Lobster Bisque
Creme Brulee

“Best pizza. Owner handed the pizza to us like she cared so much for us So much love in this place and the food.“

3.8 Good124 Reviews
New York Pasta Garden Italian • $$
1075 Duval St, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp & Scallop Carino
Eggplant Parmigiana
Fettuccine Alfredo
Caramel Cheesecake
French Onion Soup
Artichoke Hearts
Fried Artichokes
Pasta Bella Mare
Grouper Ala Lola
Chicken Alfredo

“Absolutely the best line fletch the server was awesome“

3.8 Good151 Reviews
Clemente's Wood-Fired Trolley Pizzeria Pizza • $
516 Fleming St, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Blueberry Ricotta Cake
Meatball and Ricotta
Roasted Veggie Pizza
Baby's House Salad
Cannoli of the Day
Meat Lovers Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
12 Cheese Pizza
Margarita Pizza
Key Lime Cannoli

“everything we tried was delicious from the apps to salad to pies. We will definitely be back!! Stuffed.“

4.6 Superb245 Reviews
Onlywood Pizzeria Trattoria Pizza • $$
613-1/2 Duval St, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Burratina Prosciutto Di Parma E Rucola
Small Pizza Margherita Special
Bucatini Alla Carbonara
Bucatini Cacio E Pepe
Fettuccine Alfredo
Prosciutto Pizza
Margherita Pizza
Wood Fired Pizza
Margarita Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza

“Absolutely wonderful food! Pizza, calzone, and carbonara were delicious! Calamari and caprese appetizers were fabulous too and atmosphere and service was top-notch! Highly recommend the location on Duval, down the alley!!“

4.5 Superb235 Reviews
Bel Mare Restaurant Fine Dining • $$$
700 Front St, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Caprese with Burrata Salad
Oysters on the Half Shell
Scallops & Pork Belly
Chocolate Temptation
Wild Mushroom Risotto
Shrimp Orecchiette
Key Lime Desert
Pistachio Gelato
Lobster Scampi
Veal Bolognese

“My husband and I have been coming here for years. It’s exceptional. We never have any problems with dietary restrictions and the service is 10/10“

4.5 Superb175 Reviews
Duetto Pizza and Gelato Pizza • $
540 Greene St #1, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Con Carne-Meat Lovers Pizza
Valentino Tricolore Pizza
New York Style Pizza
Focaccia Sandwich
Pizza Margherita
Hawaiian Pizza
Slice of Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Pint of Gelato
Caprese Pizza

“Lasagna pizza.....say no more. 😎“

4.5 Superb174 Reviews
Lola's Bistro Key West Bistros
728 Simonton St, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Amuse-Bouche Complimentary Appetier from Chef
Branzino in Lemon Caper Sauce
Strawberry Lemon Cream Cake
Shrimp Lobster Ravioli
Beef Short Rib Raviolis
Mediterranean Sea Bass
Chocolate Ganache Cake
Lemon Raspberry Cake
Gnocchi Appetizer
Chocolate Souffle

“OUTSTANDING!! OUTSTANDING!! OUTSTANDING!! Only way to describe my recent experience at Chef Richie’s Lola’s Bistro. Incredible dinner with amazing sauces. Everything was great from start to finish. Will definitely eat here again. Two seatings 6:00 & 8:00. It’s BYOB. Best meal I’ve had in a long time. This place is a home run. Make sure to call ahead for reservations.“

4.5 Superb155 Reviews
Salute! On The Beach American • $$
1000 Atlantic Blvd, Key West

Customers` Favorites

Sautéed Yellowtail Snapper with Lemon Cream Sauce and Spinach
Grouper Cakes with Shrimp and Chipotle Aioli
Calamari Sautéed with Marinara Sauce
Mussels Steamed in White Wine
Yellowtail Snapper Sandwich
Steamed Mussels in Bianco
Blue Heaven Key Lime Pie
Peel and Eat Shrimp
Grouper Special
Cheeseburger

“Great food and drinks-Enjoy.“

4.4 Superb216 Reviews
Pasha’s Garden Mediterranean • $$
1075 Duval St STE C2, Key West

“Food was great. Service was great. Even got free app. Why not 5 stars? We were a party of 3 and the bill had an auto gratuity added. Waiter didn't say anything at the time. And the credit card slip to sign didn't say there was a gratuity also added. So I felt like most people would double tip. Waiter should have said he was doing auto gratuity and the credit card slip to sigh should also say “add additional tip” not “add tip”.“

3.8 Good51 Reviews
Big John's Pizzeria Pizza • $
1103 Key Plaza, Key West

Customers` Favorites

New York Style Pepperoni and Mushroom
Pizza and Garlic Knots
Fettuccine Alfredo
Eggplant Parmesan
Mozzarella Sticks
All the Way Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Buffalo Chicken
Meat Stromboli
Antipasto Salad

“A great pizza place we just happened upon when grabbing something from the grocery store. We are lovers of pizza and had tried other places, but this one was definitely the best! Awesome crust, great variety of pizza types and even gluten free for my husband. I tried the Greek, my husband the white pizza with chicken. So glad we came across here!“

3.8 Good113 Reviews

Italian Restaurants Nearby

You May Also Like