Mattheessen’s Candy Kitchen
419 D Duval St, Key West
(305) 923-5418
Recent Reviews
Sort by
419 D Duval St, Key West
(305) 923-5418
Great Ice cream and key lime pie!
Well if ya got a sweet tooth do yourself a solid and stop in!! The smells comingbfrom inside is what pulled us in!! The ice cream was divine!!
Friendly staff. Cookies are made fresh each day! Must check it out!
Great ice cream, pies and cookies!!! Service is exceptional!!
The BEST Key Lime pie I've ever had! Thick like cheesecake and the crust was perfect. Drove 30 mins just for this pie!
Mattheessen’s has their own spin on Key West key lime pie, with a fairly thick hand made graham cracker crust, and whipped cream by request. I like a thicker crust, so I enjoyed the flavor fusion of crunch with the creamy smooth tart lime flavor. This place is made for tourists, much like Kermit’s, though has more general dessert options including giant cookies, fudge, and ice cream. Sure to find something sweet for everyone’s taste in the family!
Food was great and lali provided the best service. I may have missed spelled her name.
Best. Cookies. Everrrr!!! By far the best cookies in all of Key West!
Love this place for giant size cookies!! Several varieties, sometimes an occasional brownie. They also serve hard ice cream. Different thing you can get. Cookies are delicious! 2 locations on Duval street in Key West.
Delicious dessert / ice cream but rather expensice
Restaurantji Recommends
Tasty 10pm treat
Great treats and wonderful staff.
Great key lime pie, huge delicious cookies and exceptional service.
Those cookies were honestly some of the best I've ever had, and their size is perfect for sharing if you're up for it! Oh, and you have to try the key lime pie—it's so delicious that I ended up taking some home. Just a heads-up: you should keep it in a cold bag to ensure it stays fresh.
My go to place for icecream and giant cookies in KW.
Loading...