Mattheessen’s Candy Kitchen
419 D Duval St, Key West
(305) 923-5418
Recent Reviews
Sort by
419 D Duval St, Key West
(305) 923-5418
The ice cream was fabulous and so were the enormous cookies. We purchased some fudge which my boyfriend loved. Great service and nice people.
I’m usually not one to rave about cookies but omg. They were to die for. Their peanut butter cookie was phenomenal. We also enjoyed their chocolate chip nut & sprinkle cookies. Theyre huge and so flavorful. Highly recommend trying one!!!
The best Keylime pie in all of Key West! I went on a Keylime pie walking tour, and this was my favorite of the three. They use cookies in the crust!
My wife gave the cookie a 4 star. I wanted a custom cookie and was willing to pay for it but was told they couldn’t put the topping I wanted on the cookie.
This is our must stop place for their amazing key lime pie and delicious cookies! Do not miss out on their yummy treats when you’re in Key West!
Best cookies and friendly staff. Our favorite. Highly recommended!
I stumbled upon this little gem. Loved the key lime pie but the macaroons were on point. I only bought one and didn’t try it until I was back on the cruise ship. Then immediately wished I would’ve bought 12 more. Looking to order more for my birthday in February.
Awesome homemade ice cream. We got Brownie boom.
Good when you need a fix
Great cookies.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great key lime ice cream
The cookies are enormous. They’re $7 each, but really big and delicious. One cookie is enough to share with 2/3 people
Had the key lime pie. Of the 5 pies we tried, this was ranked 3rd. The flavor was not very punchy. It was not as bland as some of the others, but it was still rather bland.
Price wise, it was average.
The cookies are huge and great
we always stop when we're in key west for giant cookies and ice cream. the Cuban coffee ice cream is amazing
Loading...