Mattheessen's
$ • Dessert, Ice Cream, Pet Friendly
Hours:
614 Greene St, Key West
(305) 923-5418
About Mattheessen's
Customers' Favorites
Key Lime Ice Cream & Key Lime Pie Slice
1 2 lbs Chocolate Chip Cookies
Key Lime Pie on a Stick
Key West Key Lime Pie
Raspberry Sorbet
Mattheessen's Reviews
Ratings
Menu
Add a Menu
Hours
| Monday | 9AM - 11PM |
| Tuesday | 9AM - 11PM |
| Wednesday | 9AM - 11PM |
| Thursday | 9AM - 11PM |
| Friday | 9AM - 11PM |
| Saturday | 9AM - 11PM |
| Sunday | 9AM - 10:30PM |
People in Key West Also Viewed
The Breakfast Club, too
Breakfast, Pet Friendly, Vegan
Kermit's Key Lime Pie Shop - Elizabeth Street
Bakery, Specialty Food, Pet Friendly
Fisherman's Cafe
American, Seafood, Pet Friendly
Mattheessen's is a popular destination known for its oversized cookies baked to perfection, with a crunchy outside and a cakey inside. The cookies, as big as a fist, come in a variety of flavors, including classic chocolate chip and white chocolate macadamia nut. Customers often enjoy them moist and melty even after a couple of days, making them a favorite treat. The shop also offers delicious ice cream, with standout flavors like coffee, and a range of milkshake options for those looking for something cool. The late hours and multiple locations make Mattheessen's a convenient spot to satisfy sweet cravings.
In addition to their renowned cookies, Mattheessen's is praised for its exceptional key lime pie. Customers describe the graham cracker crust as "perfection" and the filling as a "masterpiece," with a rich lime flavor that is not overpowering. Many consider Mattheessen's key lime pie to be one of the best they have ever tasted.