Arrived Key West, checked in an headed out. Hit the wharf and found this place a few blocks beyond. On our walk we saw Kl- pie being sold for as much as $9.45 a slice. Here, $5.45. We bought a slice It was good but I expected it to be more limey. While sharing the slice I saw a sign reading they had a more "tart" variety. We may go back.
Janee L.
I had such high expectations for this place! I use to watch the profit and have been waiting to try it for years! Was very disappointed. Key lime pie was a bad consistency, crust was soggy, and every bite tasted different. Some bites I could taste some key lime and then other bites it tasted like cream cheese. I guess it wasn't mixed well. Overall the shop is nice. And the lady who took our order was okay. Just expected more.
Charles M.
Delicious pies--so much so that my wife asked to have some shipped to us (near Chicago) for her birthday. And great, great customer service. (It's a long story with a joyous ending!)
Julie M.
I decided on a whimsy to try every pie locals recommended. I was told if you like it a little more tart, come to the Key West Pie Company. You can choose from a mini pie slice, a cup with more topping or fluff, a chocolate covered slice on a stick or a mini pie. We chose the mini pie and the chocolate covered slice. The mini tart was the perfect blend of creamy, sweet and tart. The chocolate covered slice was frozen, and so easy to eat on the go. The chocolate didn't break off or crumble, it was the most perfect frozen pie creation I have ever sampled. I can't choose a favorite. Thank heavens we split it so I could eat half of both and not feel guilty. Loved the variety, and prices were very fair. For tartness and flavor, Key Lime Pie Co has my vote!! If you love meringue on a pie, Blue Heaven has the best key lime with meringue pie. Four Marlins had the best "cheesecake" style pie with a beautiful view of ocean. Kermit's has gifts galore that are key lime related and a solid pie as well. Yes, I ate five pieces of pie in one day. Well...if you include the frozen pie on a stick, technically that is six. Best tasting I have had in a long while.
Beth W.
This is a great way to enjoy Key West's signature dessert of Key Lime Pie in a quick way when you have limited time during a day in port with a cruise. Great flavor, and packaged in a way that is portable and you can eat as you wander the streets!
Ty D.
This place is AMAZING! The only key lime pie I've had that was better is my mommas but for commercially produced pie it's great. I was a little bummed they didn't have any mini pies in the other flavors they advertised but I guess going to a key lime pie company and not getting the original would be a crime.
Melissa Ramirez Guzman
Best place ever.Every time we come to key west we make a stop here. Homemade key lime pie and the service is amazing. Even the baby wants to eat.Thanks Guys you
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
David E.
Overall not a bad place, the pie was very tasty but just know that if you don't want a frozen slice of pie you'll need to get the mini pie the slice comes from the frozen whole pie.
Samuel T.
Best key lime pie I've ever had in my life. This is the place to go for pie in Key West. Don't miss the chance to eat the best.
Karen C.
We've tried all of the different key lime pies in Key West and the extra tart from here is our favorite. Too many others just don't have enough flavor and are too sweet. Intense and delicious
I was in Key West for a full week and was waiting for their "pie in a cup." I was told from day one that they were sold out. Multiple workers were annoyed when we asked about them even though many of them told us they would make more the next day. Went back multiple days to see if they had made more, last day of vacation made a stop to see if we could have one on the way to airport, still weren't open by 11 on a Saturday.
Kit G.
Had one of their frozen pies at Publix, so thought I would look for the bakery downtown. I found an outlet, maybe they baked in the back. Pies were good, but they sold the same frozen, frozen pie at their location. Was a bit of a disappointment as I thought I was going to the bakery. Still the pie is good. Not sure any different than getting it at the supermarket. Now I ordered a cuban coffee, con leche. It was horrible. No tastable coffee. Maybe they forgot to put it in? Anyhow I dumped it out. Thus my rating for the coffee and the pie.
Cassandra T.
This is the best key lime pie I have ever had. I got the mini pie and it was everything!
Scott D.
When you get to have an original you should try it. The nice thing for me is I haven't ever had key lime pie before, so to me it's perfect. Our pie was provided for us, so I don't have any comments about the store. We did stop by the store as we were out and about in key west.
Josh H.
I come here every time I'm in Key West. I've tried other places and they just don't measure up to this place. It's served frozen and it's just the perfect thing on a hot day. Love it so much. Check em out.
Arrived Key West, checked in an headed out. Hit the wharf and found this place a few blocks beyond. On our walk we saw Kl- pie being sold for as much as $9.45 a slice. Here, $5.45. We bought a slice It was good but I expected it to be more limey. While sharing the slice I saw a sign reading they had a more "tart" variety. We may go back.
I had such high expectations for this place! I use to watch the profit and have been waiting to try it for years! Was very disappointed. Key lime pie was a bad consistency, crust was soggy, and every bite tasted different. Some bites I could taste some key lime and then other bites it tasted like cream cheese. I guess it wasn't mixed well. Overall the shop is nice. And the lady who took our order was okay. Just expected more.
Delicious pies--so much so that my wife asked to have some shipped to us (near Chicago) for her birthday. And great, great customer service. (It's a long story with a joyous ending!)
I decided on a whimsy to try every pie locals recommended. I was told if you like it a little more tart, come to the Key West Pie Company. You can choose from a mini pie slice, a cup with more topping or fluff, a chocolate covered slice on a stick or a mini pie. We chose the mini pie and the chocolate covered slice. The mini tart was the perfect blend of creamy, sweet and tart. The chocolate covered slice was frozen, and so easy to eat on the go. The chocolate didn't break off or crumble, it was the most perfect frozen pie creation I have ever sampled. I can't choose a favorite. Thank heavens we split it so I could eat half of both and not feel guilty. Loved the variety, and prices were very fair. For tartness and flavor, Key Lime Pie Co has my vote!! If you love meringue on a pie, Blue Heaven has the best key lime with meringue pie. Four Marlins had the best "cheesecake" style pie with a beautiful view of ocean. Kermit's has gifts galore that are key lime related and a solid pie as well. Yes, I ate five pieces of pie in one day. Well...if you include the frozen pie on a stick, technically that is six. Best tasting I have had in a long while.
This is a great way to enjoy Key West's signature dessert of Key Lime Pie in a quick way when you have limited time during a day in port with a cruise. Great flavor, and packaged in a way that is portable and you can eat as you wander the streets!
This place is AMAZING! The only key lime pie I've had that was better is my mommas but for commercially produced pie it's great. I was a little bummed they didn't have any mini pies in the other flavors they advertised but I guess going to a key lime pie company and not getting the original would be a crime.
Best place ever.Every time we come to key west we make a stop here. Homemade key lime pie and the service is amazing. Even the baby wants to eat.Thanks Guys you
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Overall not a bad place, the pie was very tasty but just know that if you don't want a frozen slice of pie you'll need to get the mini pie the slice comes from the frozen whole pie.
Best key lime pie I've ever had in my life. This is the place to go for pie in Key West. Don't miss the chance to eat the best.
We've tried all of the different key lime pies in Key West and the extra tart from here is our favorite. Too many others just don't have enough flavor and are too sweet. Intense and delicious
Restaurantji Recommends
I was in Key West for a full week and was waiting for their "pie in a cup." I was told from day one that they were sold out. Multiple workers were annoyed when we asked about them even though many of them told us they would make more the next day. Went back multiple days to see if they had made more, last day of vacation made a stop to see if we could have one on the way to airport, still weren't open by 11 on a Saturday.
Had one of their frozen pies at Publix, so thought I would look for the bakery downtown. I found an outlet, maybe they baked in the back. Pies were good, but they sold the same frozen, frozen pie at their location. Was a bit of a disappointment as I thought I was going to the bakery. Still the pie is good. Not sure any different than getting it at the supermarket. Now I ordered a cuban coffee, con leche. It was horrible. No tastable coffee. Maybe they forgot to put it in? Anyhow I dumped it out. Thus my rating for the coffee and the pie.
This is the best key lime pie I have ever had. I got the mini pie and it was everything!
When you get to have an original you should try it. The nice thing for me is I haven't ever had key lime pie before, so to me it's perfect. Our pie was provided for us, so I don't have any comments about the store. We did stop by the store as we were out and about in key west.
I come here every time I'm in Key West. I've tried other places and they just don't measure up to this place. It's served frozen and it's just the perfect thing on a hot day. Love it so much. Check em out.