Jeremiah's Italian Ice

4355 W Lake Mary Blvd, Lake Mary
(407) 302-9882

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Scoop Froggy Frog with Twist Soft Serve Ice Cream
Cake Batter with Chocolate Ice Cream
Chocolate Soft Serve Ice Cream
Sugar Free Cherry Italian Ice
Chocolate & Vanilla Swirl
Cotton Candy Gelati
Strawberry Gelati
Cookies & Cream
Soft Ice Cream
Cookie Butter

Menu

Frog Squad Favorites
Coconut Key Lime Pie
Served with Coconut Key lime ice, vanilla ice cream, and biscoff cookie butter crumbles flavors.
Berry Bomb Gelati
Blueberry Italian ice, vanilla ice cream and strawberry hippity hops flavors.
Sour Blast
Sour Apple Italian ice, vanilla ice cream and watermelon hippity hops flavors.
Strawberry Shortcake
Cake batter ice, strawberry ice, vanilla soft ice cream and cookie butter crumbles.
Frosted Animal Cracker
Cookie butter Italian ice, cotton Candy Italian ice, vanilla soft ice cream and rainbow sprinkles.
S'More
Cookie butter Italian ice, chocolate Italian ice, swirl soft ice cream and cookie butter crumbles.
Grasshopper
Scoop froggy frog Italian ice, cookies and cream Italian ice, swirl soft ice cream and Oreo cookie crumbles.
Peanut Butter Cup
P-nutty Italian ice, chocolate soft ice cream and Hershey's mini chocolate chips.
Oreo Mud Pie
Cookies and cream Italian ice, swirl soft ice cream and Oreo cookie crumbles.
Birthday Cake
Cake batter Italian ice, vanilla soft ice cream and rainbow sprinkles.
Orange Mango Tango
Orange smash Italian ice, mango Italian ice, vanilla soft ice cream and rainbow sprinkles.
PB&J
P-nutty Italian ice, strawberry Italian ice, vanilla ice cream and cookie butter crumbles.

Gelati

Medium Gelati
Large Gelati
Quart Gelati

Italian Ice

Medium Italian Ice
Large Italian Ice
Quart Italian Ice

Ice Cream

Medium Ice Cream
Large Ice Cream
Quart Ice Cream

Extras

Bottled Water
Waffle Cone on the Side
Cooler Bag
Hippity Hops Packet

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: nextdoor
Photo credit: facebook
+83 photos
Photo credit: ubereats
+82 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

At my most recent visit to Jeremiah’s, I was feeling indecisive. I was met with Keenyah’s smile and warm nature. I tried a few samples and still didn’t feel like anything sounded good. I finally asked her what her favorite order is. I went with her suggestion and it was PERFECT. It’s been two days and I’m still wishing I had some of it left.

I wanted to write this review to specifically praise Keenyah. I get...
July 2026
Kierre gave me and my family visiting from California the best service! He brought us water cups just because and buttons, bracelets, and merch. Super nice and all around 😎 cool guy. Thank you!!!!
June 2026
Ignore the other people that reviewed this place. It's your typical high school workers working. They're super kind and go above and beyond. Obviously they can't have an ice cream out every 20 second so people need to be patient
July 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Don Julio Mexican Kitchen - Lake Mary - 4275 W Lake Mary Blvd
Mexican, Bar, Vegetarian
Gator's Dockside Lake Mary - 4349 W Lake Mary Blvd
American, Vegetarian
Huey Magoo's Chicken Tenders - 4235 W Lake Mary Blvd
Chicken Shop, Chicken

Jeremiah's Italian Ice

4355 W Lake Mary Blvd, Lake Mary, FL 32746
(407) 302-9882