The Original Brooklyn Water Bagel Co.
3801 W Lake Mary Blvd #139, Lake Mary
(407) 878-7863
Customers' Favorites
Toasted Bagel with Cream Cheese
Egg and Cheese Bagel
Pastrami Egg & Cheese
Iced Coffee Cubsta
Everything Bagel
Corned Beef Hash
The Williamsburg
Breakfast Bagel
The Jersey Boy
Plain Bagel
Featured items
Egg and Cheese Bagel
The Brooklyn
Fresh eggs, bacon, sausage, ham, and American cheese
The Williamsburg
Smoked salmon, cream cheese, sliced tomato, and red onion.
Large Cubsta 32oz
Indicate number of sweeteners and creamers in special instructions
Jumbo Chocolate Chip Muffin
Pastrami Egg & Cheese
Pastrami Egg and Cheese
Large Hot Coffee
Indicate number of sweeteners and creamers in special instructions.
Matzo Ball Soup Cup
A Cup of Matzo Ball Soup with one matzo ball.
Bulk Bagels
6 Bagels
For multiple selections of same flavor, please indicate in special instructions.
13 Bagels
For multiple selections of same flavor, please indicate in special instructions.
Brooklyn Office Bagel Pack
13 Bagels and two 1/2 lb tubs of your choice of cream cheese.
Bagels
Plain Bagel
Everything Bagel
Asiago Bagel
Cinnamon Raisin Bagel
Sesame Bagel
Onion Bagel
Salt Bagel
Garlic Bagel
Poppy Seed Bagel
Whole Wheat Bagel
Whole Wheat Everything Bagel
Black Russian Bagel
Black Russian Seeded Bagel
Bagel Sandwiches
Egg and Cheese Bagel
The Brooklyn
Fresh eggs, bacon, sausage, ham, and American cheese
Pastrami Egg & Cheese
Pastrami Egg and Cheese
The Williamsburg
Smoked salmon, cream cheese, sliced tomato, and red onion.
Corned Beef Hash Egg & Cheese
Corned Beef with a Hashbrown, Eggs and American Cheese on a Toasted Plain Bagel.
The Greenpoint
Egg whites, spinach, mushroom, and swiss on a scooped bagel.
DBL Bacon Egg and Cheese
Double the bacon on your egg and cheese sandwich.
Salami Egg and Cheese
Salami, Egg and Cheese
LOX
Sliced Nova, Eggs, Onion and a schmear of Cream Cheese
The Jersey Boy
Taylor Ham™, Eggs and Cheese on a Toasted Plain Bagel
Deli Sandwiches
Bagel Dog
Choice of Premium Beef Hot Dog or Chicken Sausage, Wrapped in Bagel Dough, Topped with Everything Bagel Seeds. Spicy Mustard & Sauerkraut on the Side.
Club Melt
Warm Ham, Turkey & Bacon with Melted Swiss Cheese, Tomato, Onion & Butter on a Bagel or Bread of your Choice.
Tuna Salad Sandwich
Tuna Salad with Lettuce, Tomato & Red Onion on a Bagel or Bread of Your Choice.
S'mores
Little Italy
Salami, Capicola & Ham with Provolone Cheese, Shredded Lettuce, Tomato. Red Onion, Banana Peppers & Vinaigrette on a Bagel or Bread of your Choice.
The Reuben
Corned Beef, Swiss Cheese, and Sauerkraut, with your choice of mustard or 1000 Island dressing on a toasted bagel or rye bread.
Tuna Melt
Housemade White Albacore Tuna Salad with Tomato and American Cheese served on Rye Bread.
Turkey Avocado Bacon Wrap
Served on your choice of plain or whole wheat wrap with Lettuce, Tomato and Mayo
Sliced Ham Sandwich
Sliced Ham with Lettuce, Tomato & Red Onion, Swiss Cheese on a Bagel or Bread of Your Choice.
Half-Pound Pastrami
Spicy Grilled Chicken
Grilled Chicken, Pepperjack Cheese, Bacon, Pickle Slices, Lettuce, Tomato & Spicy Mayo on a Bagel or Bread of your Choice.
The Pastrami Reuben
Pastrami, Swiss Cheese, and Sauerkraut, with your choice of mustard or 1000 Island dressing on a toasted bagel or rye bread.
Half-Pound Corned Beef
Half Pound of Warm Corned Beef with Mustard on a Bagel or Rye Bread
Chicken Salad Sandwich
Chicken Salad with Lettuce, Tomato & Red Onion on a Bagel or Bread of Your Choice.
Roasted Turkey Sandwich
Roasted Turkey with Lettuce, Tomato, Swiss Cheese on a Bagel or Bread of Your Choice.
Egg Salad Sandwich
Egg Salad with Lettuce, Tomato & Red Onion on a Bagel or Bread of Your Choice.
Lunch Platters
Bagel with Choice of any Three House-Made Salads or Cream Cheese, served on a Bed of Lettuce & Tomato.
Whitefish Salad Sandwich
Whitefish Salad with Lettuce, Tomato & Red Onion on a Bagel or Bread of Your Choice.
Half and Half Deli
Half Pounder one side Carnegie Pastrami one Corned Beef
Soups and Combos
Matzo Ball Soup Cup
A Cup of Matzo Ball Soup with one matzo ball.
Matzo Ball Soup Quart
A quart of Cold Matzo Ball Soup with four matzo balls.
1/2 Corned Beef & Matzo Ball Soup
1/2 Corned Beef and a Cup of Matzo Ball Soup.
1/2 Pastrami & Matzo Ball Soup
1/2 Pastrami Sandwich and a Cup of Matzo Ball Soup.
1/2 Sliced Ham & Matzo Ball Soup
1/2 Slice Ham Sandwich and a Cup of Matzo Ball Soup.
1/2 Roasted Turkey & Matzo Ball Soup
Large Spreads and Salads
Plain Cream Cheese 8oz
Scallion Cream Cheese 8oz
Veggie Cream Cheese 8oz
Egg Salad 8oz
Chicken Salad 8oz
Tuna Salad 8oz
Nova Cream Cheese 8oz
Tub Whipped Butter
Whitefish Salad 8oz
Coffee
Large Cubsta 32oz
Indicate number of sweeteners and creamers in special instructions
Cubsta Cubed 24oz
4 regular 24oz cubstas. Indicate number of sweeteners and creamers in special instructions
Regular Hot Coffee
Indicate number of sweeteners and creamers in special instructions
Large Hot Coffee
Indicate number of sweeteners and creamers in special instructions.
Coffee B-Individuals
Now our coffee is available in single serve capsules for Keurig K-cup Brewers, Available in our two most popular blends! Enjoy a quick cup of your favorite coffee anytime!
Coffee 12oz BAG
Our locally crafted ground coffee available in our three most popular blends. Enjoy your favorite coffee at home anytime!
Regular Cubsta 24oz
Indicate number of sweeteners and creamers in special instructions
Box of Cubsta Iced Coffee
Servers up to 6
Box of Hot Coffee
Servers up to 8
Cubsta Cubed 32oz
4 large 32oz cubstas. Indicate number of sweeteners and creamers in special instructions.
Beverages
32oz Fountain
Natalie's Orange Juice
Apple Juice
24oz Fountain
32oz Tractor Beverage
Tractor Beverages are our non-carbonated beverage options.
24oz Tractor Beverage
Tractor Beverages are our non-carbonated beverage options.
Natalie's Strawberry Lemonade
Chocolate Milk
Bottle Water
Whole Milk 24oz
Natalie's Lemonade
Sides
Hash Brown
Potato Knish
Soft, pillowy dough, filled to the brim with seasoned mash potatoes and baked to perfection.
Potato Chips
Pickle Half
Desserts
Jumbo Chocolate Chip Muffin
S'mores
Jumbo Chocolate Chip Cookie
Jumbo Blueberry Muffin
Jumbo Apple Cinnamon Muffin
Jumbo Black and White Cookie
Family Meals
Brooklyn Brunch
6 Bagels, 8oz plain cream cheese, Scrambled Eggs for 4 with cheese, 8 slices of bacon, 2 sausage patties, 6 hash browns, 2 pints of Natalie's OJ
Box of Cubsta Iced Coffee
Servers up to 6
Box of Hot Coffee
Servers up to 8
Office Packs
Cubsta Cubed 24oz
4 regular 24oz cubstas. Indicate number of sweeteners and creamers in special instructions
Brooklyn Office Bagel Pack
13 Bagels and two 1/2 lb tubs of your choice of cream cheese.
Brooklyn Brunch
6 Bagels, 8oz plain cream cheese, Scrambled Eggs for 4 with cheese, 8 slices of bacon, 2 sausage patties, 6 hash browns, 2 pints of Natalie's OJ
Box of Cubsta Iced Coffee
Servers up to 6
Cubsta Cubed 32oz
4 large 32oz cubstas. Indicate number of sweeteners and creamers in special instructions.
Box of Hot Coffee
Servers up to 8
Photos
+48 photos
+47 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
As of late the quality of their bagels have declined to sad. Even their creame cheese is sad.. the past three orders at least one and mostly 2 of a 6 pack are hard as rocks and burnt. I stopped ordering onion bagels because to burnt to eat... the plan bagels are usually spot on but who ever took over the store in Lake Mary doesn't care about quality or making good food. Shame.
November 2025
As a NJ native, this is the closest I’ve had to the bagels and hard rolls I ate growing up. Service was great. Breakfast sandwich was huge and could barely finish half! Will be back in the near future since it’s practically in walking distance of our house.
October 2025
Love the concept and vibe of this place. Coffee is really good and they have coffee ice cubes.
They were giving out free cinnamon rolls as a promotion for a new product. My brother got one and they were giving some out to almost every costumer. Unfortunately they skipped us.
We ordered and they accidentally got our order wrong. I felt bad trying to fix the order because line was so long. It wasn’t a huge deal, breakfast sandwich was good. My cream cheese...
They were giving out free cinnamon rolls as a promotion for a new product. My brother got one and they were giving some out to almost every costumer. Unfortunately they skipped us.
We ordered and they accidentally got our order wrong. I felt bad trying to fix the order because line was so long. It wasn’t a huge deal, breakfast sandwich was good. My cream cheese...
March 2025
You May Also Like
BurgerFi - 3801 W Lake Mary Blvd #141
![]()
Hamburger, Burgers, Hot Dogs, American, Vegan
China King - 3801 W Lake Mary Blvd #133
![]()
Chinese, Vegetarian