Mediterranean Restaurants in Marco Island

“My wife and I recently celebrated our anniversary at Tesoro, and it was an experience that exceeded every expectation. We chose the restaurant based on the enthusiastic recommendation of a VIP client who praised the food, service, and view—Tesoro delivered on all fronts and then some. From the moment we arrived, the warmth was palpable. The hostess was incredibly hospitable and inviting, offering sincere congratulations on our anniversary and setting a celebratory tone for the evening. We were seated in Sherri's section, and she was the absolute star of the night. Sherri embodies the pinnacle of hospitality and professionalism; her attentiveness, knowledge, and genuine desire to go above and beyond made us feel like honored guests. She was a key part of what made the evening so special. The culinary journey was exceptional. We began with the meatballs and polenta—super fresh and so tender they truly melted in our mouths. For our mains, my wife's Truffle Fettuccine was rich and deeply flavorful, while my Chicken Marsala was a perfect, classic execution. Both were excellent choices. The cocktails were works of art in their presentation, beautifully crafted and enjoyable. The grand finale was the Pistachio Pain De Gêne, which arrived adorned with a "Happy Anniversary" note in chocolate —a thoughtful, personal touch that capped the meal perfectly. It was as delicious as it was meaningful. And then, there's the view. Breathtaking doesn't do it justice. We were treated to a spectacular, picturesque sunset over the water, providing a stunning, romantic backdrop that elevated the entire experience. Tesoro is more than a restaurant; it's a destination for creating core memories. For exceptional cuisine, flawless and heartfelt service, and one of the most beautiful settings in Southwest Florida, look no further. We will absolutely be returning. Thank you, Tesoro, and especially Sherri, for a truly memorable anniversary celebration.“

“Solid food, nice service, nothing mind blowing, but deserves a solid 4. We appreciated the various vegetarian options as entrees, and found both of our dishes to be pretty good, just some of the flavor was lack luster and the vegetables were overcooked (my broccoli rabe).“