New American Restaurants in Marco Island, FL

“Amazing breakfast place! We ate here every day of our vacation. YUMMMMMMM!!!“

“We had an amazing open menu dinner right on the beach, and it was easily one of the highlights of our trip. The setting was absolutely perfect—feet in the sand, ocean breeze, and a beautiful sunset as the backdrop. You really can’t beat that kind of atmosphere.

The menu was broad and everything we ordered was spot on. The seafood was super fresh—especially the grouper and shrimp, both cooked just right and full of flavor. We also had a filet that was perfectly seared and super tender. Sides were flavorful, and the portions were generous without being over the top.

Drinks were a hit too—tropical cocktails that actually tasted balanced (not just sugary), and a solid wine list to go with the meal. Dessert didn’t disappoint either—key lime pie and chocolate cake that were both worth saving room for.

Service was great: attentive, friendly, and relaxed, which matched the whole beachside vibe. It felt special but still comfortable. If you’re looking for a memorable dinner experience at Marco Island, dining on the beach through Hammock Bay Grill is 100% worth it“

“We had a nice time here, though our appetizer of blistered shishito peppers was neither blistered or shishito peppers. We got small red and yellow peppers basically raw with goat cheese sauce. Server did remove it from the check. The rest of our meal was very good Salmon with purple rice and quinoa bowl. Both were very good and nicely prepared Music at the pool was loud but good“

“Food was amazing, clean place and people friendly“

“Sea bass out of this world entertainment on a Wednesday out standing“