New American Restaurants near Sanibel, FL

Sandollar Restaurant American • $$
1231 Middle Gulf Dr, Sanibel

“this place now calls itself the BRGR restaurant as it has renewed itself after recovery from the hurricane Ian as part of the Sanibel Island Resort. They place is beautiful and a new favorite of mine. Had a Black and Bleu burger (relates to the name of the restaurant) with cole slaw and it was excellent! Very high quality, done just right, tasted wonderful and included bacon in the burger. Tried fries from one of our party and they were exceptional, great taste and crunch. Our server was friendly and took great care of our party. we parked our bikes at the rack behind the restaurant in the area where the parking lot leads back to palms and passes their pool (with bar) toward the path to the beach where they have lounge chairs that they furnish to guests on the beach that has recently had its sand replenished by the island. A great visit, we'll be back.“

3.6 Good10 Reviews
Point 57 Kitchen & Cocktails American • $$
3522 Del Prado Blvd S, Cape Coral - 10.7 miles

Customers` Favorites

Old Bay Shrimp Scampi Pasta
Filet Mignon and Shrimp
Southern Fried Chicken
Banana Bread Pudding
Blackened Mahi Mahi
Crab Cake Benedict
Stuffed Mushrooms
Cape Royal Burger
kb's Key Lime Pie
Beef Stroganoff

“Point 57 Kitchen & Cocktails is a trendy and upscale restaurant offering a unique dining experience with creative dishes and handcrafted cocktails. The menu features a fusion of flavors, blending classic American cuisine with international influences. With its stylish ambiance and attentive service, it's an ideal spot for special occasions or casual gatherings. While prices may be higher compared to other restaurants, the quality of food and drinks justifies the cost. Overall, Point 57 delivers a memorable culinary journey with its innovative dishes and carefully crafted cocktails.“

4.4 Superb337 Reviews
Lighthouse Restaurant & Bar Steak House • $$$
14301 Port Comfort Rd, Fort Myers - 3.49 miles

Customers` Favorites

Oysters on the Half Shell
Flourless Chocolate Cake
Lighthouse Seafood Bowl
Lighthouse Key Lime Pie
Traditional Bruschetta
Chocolate Lava Cake
Island Conch Ceviche
Firecracker Shrimp
Grouper Sandwich
Lobster Bisque

“Was recomend this restaurant by someone on the flight in, told me the bacon wrapped shrimp appetizer was wonderful, so we came for appetizers and desert. Service was great, food was outstanding, views were beautiful. wish I could have stayed for the sunset, request patio seating“

4.4 Superb174 Reviews
High Tide Social House Pizza • $$
6095 Silver King Blvd, Cape Coral - 6.35 miles

Customers` Favorites

Grouper Sandwich and French Fries
Pressed Chicken and Chorizo
Prime Rib Sandwich
Whole Fried Snapper
OH My Gorg Burger
Nature Walk Salad
Soho House Salad
Grouper Planks
Pressed Cubano
Happy as a Clam

“Love this place. Grouper sandwich is fantastic... love the crispy batter and generous fish portion! We've been here several times and everything has been delicious. We love the atmosphere here, and the service is great. If you haven't been to this gem of a restaurant, what are you waiting for?!“

4.4 Superb125 Reviews
Whiskey Creek Station American • $$
11481 McGregor Blvd, Fort Myers - 11.57 miles

Customers` Favorites

Corn Beef and Cabbage
Grouper Sandwich
Yucatan Shrimp
Shepherd's Pie
Fish & Chips
Onion Soup
Pastrami
Calamari
Fajitas
Burger

“I had lunch here twice in the last week. You would totally pass this place up by looking at the outside, Hurricane Ian did some damage to their awning and they have a tarp over it. But DON'T pass by, they have amazing food. First lunch I got the special which was 3 tacos, beef, chicken and grouper. Excellent. Second time the table got the grouper bites as an appetizer however for one person it would be a meal, soooo good. I got a hamburger as my meal. Excellent flavor. As I said don't pass this place by for lunch or dinner. Prices are extremely reasonable.“

4.4 Superb81 Reviews
Matanzas on the Bay Seafood • $$
416 Crescent St, Fort Myers Beach - 4.28 miles

Customers` Favorites

Smoked Fish Dip
Coconut Shrimp
Shrimp Burger
Key Lime Pie
Crab Cakes
Meat Lovers
Couscous
Pizza

“On our trip to Fort Myers with Family my husband and I ate here twice, once just the two of us and then with our entire family group. Both were great stops with outside seating, great views of the bay to watch the pelicans, boats and wildlife. If you like coconut shrimp they have the best coconut shrimp I’ve ever had (I had them twice). Service was good on both occasions. If you want tap beer you’ll need to sit on the upper bar section.“

4.3 Superb97 Reviews
Cabanas Beach Bar & Grille American • $$
2000 Estero Blvd, Fort Myers Beach - 4.66 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cuban Sandwich and Onion Rings
1 2 lb Burger and Onion Rings
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Chicken Caesar Salad
Grouper Sandwich
Grouper Ruban
Coconut Shrimp
Chicken Wings
House Salad
House Slaw

“If we could give this place 10 stars just for the customer service, we would! The food and drinks were good, but Dianne really made the whole experience! She was especially great with all the kids at our table, brought us water bottles for the beach as we were leaving, and was all around incredibly attentive and had a wonderful attitude and was so sweet! Excellent service! We will be back just because of this!“

4.5 Superb43 Reviews
The Cove American •
17260 Harbour Pointe Dr, Fort Myers - 2.88 miles

“Wow! Exceptional staff and 5 star service. Special thanks to Nick, Kader and Carl for working with our daughter to make our 50th anniversary incredibly special. Room comfy & spacious, Food and drinks delicious. We will definitely return.“

4.6 Superb22 Reviews
Palm Grill American • $
14441 Woodsong Ln, Fort Myers - 4.48 miles

“Our 20 person group had lunch in their small banquet room. Service is always great and the lunch menu has a nice variety for selection. Desserts were also great. Prices and quality highly competitive. Other than a "dry campus", very enjoyable.“

4.9 Superb7 Reviews
Island Café American •
14990 Shell Point Blvd, Fort Myers - 5.05 miles

“This was a great surprise. We didn’t realize it was a senior community but open to the public. My husband wanted breakfast and I wanted a good burger. We were both pleased as our food was cooked to perfection. We were warmly greeted and the place was spotless. Everyone was so nice and friendly as it was obvious we weren’t old enough to live there. They offer a great variety of options including ice cream.“

4.4 Superb8 Reviews
Buster's Sports Tavern Sports Bar • $
16681 McGregor Blvd, Fort Myers - 5.04 miles

Customers` Favorites

Saturday & Sunday - 1 Pound Sirloin Steak Dinner
AYCE Grilled Breaded or Blackened Shrimp
Thursday - All You Can Eat Fried Chicken
All You Can Eat Fried Chicken Dinner
Hand Breaded Onion Rings
Lobster & Shrimp Pizza
Fisherman's Platter
Tavern Steak Dinner
Mozzarella Sticks
French Onion Soup

“Buster’s was amazing! Alec was so friendly and efficient as our waiter. He made us feel welcome and comfortable. The food was incredible! So incredible that I annoyed my husband the entire meal with expressing how delicious everything was. We got mozzarella sticks for the appetizer and they were the biggest I have ever seen. So good with the marinara. My cuban sandwich was made to perfection. The meats were tender and juicy, the roll was soft and even the mustard delighted my tastebuds. The side of coleslaw was so good, too! Usually I don’t like the coleslaw sides that restaurants make because it’s a side and an afterthought. Buster’s had to be homemade and created with care. The crinkle fries were cooked perfectly. The portions were huge. I was disappointed I couldn’t finish everything, but I have leftovers. I wish we would have tried this gem sooner! Highly recommend and can’t wait to go back!“

4 Good131 Reviews
Cork Soakers Deck & Wine Bar Bar & Grill • $$
837 SE 47th Terrace, Cape Coral - 8.93 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ralph's 'Killer' Shrimp N Grits
Grilled Cheese & Tomato Soup
Truffle Whipped Eggs Diablo
Prime Rib Sandwich
Chicken Sandwich
Shrimp & Grits
Side Devil Egg
Surf & Turf
Surf Turf

“I have been coming here for 4 years. The staff and managers are incredible. I feel at home. Jassen and Kylie are fun, engaging, and really make sure we are taken care of! That is why we will keep coming! Every. Single. Week. I am shocked by some of these lower reviews. Some of you should check “

4 Good126 Reviews
Snappers Comedy Club New American • $$
8595 College Pkwy #270, Fort Myers - 10.72 miles

“Snappers is not only a great comedy club but they have amazing food at reasonable prices. They added booths which are wonderful! We eat out quite often and our server Tierra was best server we've ever had. She immediately made us feel welcome with her warm smile and professionalism. She was attentive and hustled to make sure we had everything we needed. We were amazed when she told us she had only been working there 3 weeks! She was such a pro!!! The comedians were hilarious. Rob Little kept everyone laughing. Oh and when we go back there we will definitely ask for Tierra's section!“

3.9 Good76 Reviews
Nevermind Awesome Bar and The Hop Gastropubs • $$
927 Cape Coral Pkwy E, Cape Coral - 8.97 miles

Customers` Favorites

Parmesan Truffle Wings
Truffled Fries
Volcano
Burger

“Love the new management! Food and service was great. They're still getting their sea-legs, but off to a great start! I've heard people describe NeverMind as a dive bar, but it's really got food that's too good for that description. More like an upscale dive-want-to-be bar ?.“

3.9 Good76 Reviews
Rumrunners Seafood • $$
5848 Cape Harbour Dr, Cape Coral - 6.63 miles

Customers` Favorites

Caribbean Bronzed Salmon or Divers Scallops
Rumrunners Coconut Shrimp
Gulf Coast Seafood Pasta
Crunchy Grouper Sandwich
Maine Lobster Ravioli
Sweet Potato Fries
French Onion Soup
Conch Fritters
Seafood Paella
Seafood Pot Pie

“Exceeded my expectations, knew there would be a great atmosphere but food, service and drinks were equally as good. Birthday dessert was beautifully presented and tasted amazing! We took a bite before I snapped the photo. See if you can find the missing piece?“

3.9 Good249 Reviews
Fathoms Restaurant & Bar American • $$
5785 Cape Harbour Dr # 106, Cape Coral - 6.7 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fathoms Steak Frites
Bourbon Street Mac
Tropical Ahi Tuna
Seared Beef Tips
Flatbread Pizza
Margarita Pizza
Fish and Chips
Mahi Sandwich
Goat Cheese
Egg Rolls

“Perfect place if you want to enjoy a relaxing dinner by the sea ?? Their food is the best, you can't ask for something better! They have amazing views as well so if you are looking for a place to have a great dinner combined, then this is the right place.“

3.8 Good97 Reviews
McGregor Grill Bar & Grill • $
15675 McGregor Blvd, Fort Myers - 6.31 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bacon Cheeseburger Without the Bun
Reuben with Fries and Slaw
Spinach and Artichoke Dip
The Monte Cristo Sandwich
Grilled Chicken Salad
Italian Combo Sandwich
Hamburger Recommended
Turkey Club Sandwich
Chicken Ceasar Salad
Philly Cheese Steak

“I really like McGregor Grill! There is a wide variety of very good food, and the interior is cozy and pretty clean. The tables are a bit sticky, and the service is slow only because there are few employees. But if they hire a couple waiters it would be perfect. Try the beef tips quesadilla!“

3.7 Good92 Reviews
Loading...
map Map