Tony's N.Y. Pizza

Name: Tony's N.Y. Pizza
Address: 145 S Barfield Dr, Marco Island, Florida, 34145, US
Telephone: (239) 970-0027
Price range: $
Rating: 4.2

$ • Pizza, Italian, Chicken Wings

Hours:
145 S Barfield Dr, Marco Island
(239) 970-0027

Menu Order Online

About Tony's N.Y. Pizza

Tony's N.Y. Pizza is a popular spot for pizza lovers, known for its delicious pizza and other menu items like calzones. Customers can choose between pizza by the slice or a whole pie. The restaurant is praised for its fresh, scratch-made food, making it a guilt-free choice for regulars.

The pizzeria offers a variety of options, including a well-done pizza and a unique Grandma's style for those who prefer a thicker crust and extra sauce. The staff is extremely friendly and attentive, adding to the welcoming atmosphere. Customers can enjoy the comfortable indoor seating, and the restaurant is conveniently located in a small strip shopping center.

While some customers have noted inconsistencies in the dough's consistency, particularly with the Sicilian pie, the overall taste has been consistently praised. However, the price difference between a Sicilian slice and a whole Sicilian pie has been a point of contention for some, especially when comparing it to New York prices.

Despite minor issues, Tony's N.Y. Pizza has built a loyal customer base due to its delicious food and convenient take-out service. Some customers even consider it to be among the top 3 pizza spots on the island. The restaurant offers an authentic New York-style pizza experience, and customers have praised the outstanding pizza, including the Madison Square Garden, as well as the exceptional meatball slice and the delicious eggplant parmesan sub.