The Fat Apple
CLOSED$ •
About The Fat Apple
The Fat Apple Reviews
164 ratings
Called in an order, very friendly and polite and insightful on the ingredients. Was told it was be done in about 15 minutes (I was already walking in to pay as I called the order in because I live close by and was out), the lady who helped me was quick and very friendly. The inside was clean and rustic vibes but a calmness to it. The pizza and garlic knots were done in about 6-7 minutes, and I ended up paying about 25-30$ total which is less than any chain, and it’s a nice thin...read full review
Best pizza in the area. Family owned and you can feel that when you walk in.
I just had a couple of pizza slices. They're okay but not Chicago thin/tavern style. Sorry my legacy!
The Fat Apple is a local restaurant that serves homemade-style pizza with a unique New York/New Jersey flair. Customers enjoy the authentic taste and appreciate the family-owned business, though some find the pizza portion sizes to be a bit uneven. Overall, the restaurant provides a pleasant dining experience, with a variety of menu options including sandwiches, salads, and wings. Many visitors consider it their ultimate favorite place for pizza, with some returning after years to enjoy the Cecilian pizza or a white pie. The pizza is praised for its excellent quality, toasted undercarriage, and minimal oil on top. The garlic knots are also highly recommended. While the dine-in service can be slow, the quick preparation of the food makes up for it. The Fat Apple is a great choice for those craving authentic NY pizza, and it’s a reliable spot to enjoy a delicious meal during vacation or whenever in the area.