Sugar Shack PSJ
319 Reid Ave, Port St Joe
(256) 572-9868
Customers' Favorites
Bourbon Butter Pecan
Milkshakes the Twix
Ice Cream Sandwich
Chocolate Coffee
Ice Cream Cakes
Nachos Sundaes
Banana Split
Cheesecake
Shark
Menu
Photos
+14 photos
+13 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Best ice cream around. You guys never disappoint!! Love all the different flavors you offer especially the homemade ones. Everyone is always friendly and smiling even on busy days. The crowds show just how good the ice cream 🍦 is. 🤘🏻☀️
Update: Owner called the next day to apologize. Much respect.
I was 20 minutes away. Called to see if they have dairy free options. The owner answered "hello" and didn't say the name of the shop. I asked is this "sugar shack?" And He replied it was. Thought that was kind of unprofessional.
I then asked about the dairy free options, to which he said they have acacia bowls. He even asked someone off the phone if they...
I was 20 minutes away. Called to see if they have dairy free options. The owner answered "hello" and didn't say the name of the shop. I asked is this "sugar shack?" And He replied it was. Thought that was kind of unprofessional.
I then asked about the dairy free options, to which he said they have acacia bowls. He even asked someone off the phone if they...
The burnout butter pecan (21+!) is good but tasted like it was melted and placed back in the freezer - if that makes sense lol. The lovely ladies working were so sweet. My boyfriend got the blueberry cheese and it was really good!
You May Also Like
Pepper's Mexican Grill & Cantina - 309 Reid Ave
![]()
Mexican, Pet Friendly, Vegetarian
Herbalife - St. Joe Nutrition - 316 Reid Ave
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee, Coffee & Tea, Tea Rooms
Sweet Bunz - 306 Reid Ave
![]()
Donuts, Bakery, Coffee Shops, Coffee