36 Best Pizza Restaurants near Port Saint John

“Had a coworker recommend this place, and in so glad he did! Finally found a place that serves a Midwest style pizza. Sorry no pic as I ate it all before posting this review. Crust is flavorful and crispy without being dry, sauce , cheese, pepperoni and spices were delicious and made for a very well balanced pie. Thanks Leo! I'll be back“

“One of our PSJ favorites. I work close so I love stopping for the pizza slices, but everything here is good. The BEST wings, quesadillas, and subs. His meatball sub is incredible you can taste the love in this food. Love the support for our veterans in this establishment.“

“This Papa John’s location RARELY does me wrong. I live just barely outside the delivery zone of this location but the quality difference between “my” store and this one is astronomical. So when I want Papa John’s I intentionally order carryout from this location because it’s consistently well-made and ready quickly. Whatever they’re doing, please keep doing it!“

“Decided to try Kelsey's after a long while, and after the recently-new mgmt and spotty reviews. We were warmly greeted at the door, looked at the menu - noticing neither offerings nor prices had changed (good) and sat down. Service was very attentive and the portions were as large as we remembered. The only difference we noticed is the marinara sauce: sweeter and more bland - important to us and cost a star for food in this review. The meat sauce was better, though it too could have used a little more complexity. Otherwise, the mini Greek salad was huge as always, and the spaghetti and meatballs dinner was tasty and large with a substantial take-home portion. They also still have the $5 hurricane drinks, though I didn't buy one this time. Before tip our bill was under $20 - rare these days for eating out anywhere.“

“Excellent pizza! Our new favorite!“

“This place is amazing! Friendly staff, fresh food, and an amazing owner. Jordan is such a great guy and it shows with how much he cares about this location! Great food all the time. There needs to be more small business owners like HIM!“

“Rocky told me Pizza Co. is the best pizza on the Island. I totally AGREE.“

“Tried Pozzy Bro Pizza for the first time today. So happy we found our new pizza place! Everyone was so friendly and welcoming. Slices were giant and delicious.“

“Great pizza but the staff is very unprofessional and rude“

“Their food is absolutely amazing!“

“just enjoyed an AWESOME meat lovers. A great pie & a great owner“

“What a wonderful surprise in Downtown Titusville...

I've been hearing about this place for quite a while and finally had an opportunity to try it tonight - it was certainly worth the wait. The place, in it's essence, is basically a pizza joint. But it's no ordinary pizza joint as it's modern, sleek, and has a hip-vibe I have never gotten from any other pizza joint I've been to, to date.

You order at the counter right inside the entrance and are warmly greeted and happily guided as it was our first time there. The menu is chock full of the mainstays you expect with a few surprises (for us it was mostly on the dessert side of things.)

We ordered the Goat Pizza and each had a different dessert - the pizza was deep-dish (which I loved) and all the desserts we had, from a mint cheesecake, an almond flavored tiramisu-looking cake, to their galaxy cake - we shared and we all loved it.

Service was super friendly, super attentive, and it was truly sincere - you just can't fake it.

I normally don't talk about bathrooms at places I eat at, and I won't go into it in detail, but it was 'entertaining' to see the pics they had up on the wall in their bathroom.

Anyway, a fabulous place - an incredible surprise - and I'm looking forward to our next trip back...“

“Great fried ravioli with marinara“

“We loved Oceanside Pizza. Everyone in our group enjoyed their meal, and the vibe was perfect — relaxed, welcoming, and exactly what you want when grabbing whatever you feel like to eat. Great food, great atmosphere, and a spot we’ll definitely be back to. Highly recommend!
- Alyssa and Shannon; Selling Together Team with Blue Marlin“

“We love Pozzy Bros! They listen when you say you want it a little well done! Their pizza has a nice crust and great flavor. Salads could use more tomatoes, but are nice.“

“The best food with a view!!!“

“So good. NY Style at its best. My wife is from Brooklyn and loves it.“

“Can't eat inside but the car worked fine. Stopped here after going to KSC. We split a large meatball sub (not really a sub, more like a small pizza folded in half.) So good! Great flavor, good amount of cheese, (I'm from Wisconsin so I'm basically an expert on cheese.) Wish we had this chain up here. Best thing I ate all weekend.“

“love there pizza and you cant get unlimited toppings“

“Keys atmosphere fish from right off the shore excellent staff and wonderful food“

“Marco’s Pizza is delicious and they use fresh dough, They also have Salads,Calzones,Subs,Desserts. They also have thin crust and cauliflower crust for gluten free menu Team Marco’s are good in Hospitality and customer service .“

“I get a pizza too often for lunch but they are the best here so its hard not too. Jordan is always there with a smile when I walk in which is nice to see in that industry. Pizza is always ready and delicious. The place always looks brand new inside. So thanks Dominoes for this awesome location with good employees running it.“

“the best pizza in town!!!“

“Great experience at Kelsey’s, pizza was quick and great! But most importantly EVERY employee was kind, nice and taking care of everyone in there! It was great!“

“Food was ok, pizza undercooked as if they were in a hurry, wing were fried well but the garlic parmesan sauce was greasy/buttery not garlic or parmesan. The service waz awful. We as customers seemed to be an inconvenience to them. It's gone downhill for the past while.“

“fast and friendly :) curbside available“

“This is my neighborhood Domino's. I suggest using the app which provides great deals. It also allows you to keep track of any delivery you might have pending with Domino's. The New York style pizza is very good as is the Chicken Parm sandwich. My daughter loves the Parmesan bread bites. I usually pick up my order and the staff is always friendly and professional. I had my first delivery yesterday and I received my food in the time given. The driver, Samuel was very pleasant and professional.“

“I frequent this place quite often. Every experience there has been wonderful. I could continue to gush like a kid with a crush but I won’t. Although, I will say that delivery 🚚 driver, Jenée Joy Krzyston, she definitely deserves a raise if she still works there. Side note 📝: She is even hotter than your pizza 🍕. Thanks for all the meals you have prepared for my family. We appreciate all that you do.“

“Last night was New Year’s Eve and it happened to fall on Wednesday night and if you know anything about Pizza Hut that’s Wing Wednesday. So on top of being open until midnight on New Year’s Eve these workers also had to deal with it being one of the BEST nights of the week to order wings. I called the store earlier in the night to verify what time the store was open until and I received great customer service. The woman on the phone said “she looked forward to taking my order later”. The fact that I still felt encouraged by a worker to place an order on what was to be one of the busiest nights of the year says a lot about the standard of customer service upheld by this restaurant. When I arrived around 11pm the store was slammed to be expected. However, the wings that I received from this location during this rush were probably the best I ever had up to this point and I order them frequently on Wednesday’s. The young male manager who prepared and processed my order of Spicy Garlic Wings did a PHENOMENAL job. The sauce is what makes these types of wings and without even having to ask for extra sauce I received the perfect wing to sauce ratio that I was looking for. I feel that my overall customer experience went above and beyond especially given the context of the situation. Great job and special shoutout to the team of workers who worked the New Years Eve shift last night. You guys really knocked it out of the park 😊👌“

“Food, wine and desserts were out of this world for the 4 of us. Chef Alfredo went out of his way to check on his patrons dining at the restaurant this evening. I can go on and on, but I'll save it for later because I plan on frequenting Paradiso from now on. What a very pleasant surprise experiencing this restaurant that I had thought just opened in the past year.“

“So the babies and I just got Domino’s because we were hungry and I have a migraine so I didn’t want to get up. The delivery girl, Lexi, was seriously the sweetest and most bubbly person ever. She’s been gone for a while now and my kids are still talking about that “cute girl with the colorful hair that gave us pizza” So, Lexi, thank you for being a sweetheart! The babies and I adored that small encounter with you! Merry Christmas!🥰“

“Mimmo’s has high quality ingredients and a delicious pizza. The grandma pizza is a MUST! It keeps us coming back for more.“

“New to the area and went today for the first time for lunch. Greeted immediately by the owner, ordered by the slice and could add any toppings. Pizza was absolutely delicious, hot, lots of toppings, prices were great!! 5+ stars highly recommend to all to try!!“

“We ate at The Kings Duck for dinner last night (11/19/25) and had Fish and Chips and a Mushroom Cheeseburger both with fries. The fries were some of crispiest, and tastiest we have ever had! Also, the Mushroom Swiss Burger cooked medium rare was perfectly cooked, which is hard to get done correctly. The Fish was also very good!!! I would recommend The Kings Duck for really good food!“

“Pizzas were great. Full of toppings. Crust was perfect. They were not greasy. Honestly, the best Pizza Hut I ordered from. Pizzas arrived on time. Big Kudos to the person who made our pizzas. Thank you. Keep the good work. 100% satisfied customer. Expectations exceeded.“