37 Best Pizza Restaurants near Port Saint John

“One of our PSJ favorites. I work close so I love stopping for the pizza slices, but everything here is good. The BEST wings, quesadillas, and subs. His meatball sub is incredible you can taste the love in this food. Love the support for our veterans in this establishment.“

“This Papa John’s location RARELY does me wrong. I live just barely outside the delivery zone of this location but the quality difference between “my” store and this one is astronomical. So when I want Papa John’s I intentionally order carryout from this location because it’s consistently well-made and ready quickly. Whatever they’re doing, please keep doing it!“

“Matt was absolutely amazing. He made our experience very blessed and exciting to the 10th power!!! We as a family needed this at this very moment!! Please know, we are not easy and he made our experience very easy to enjoy !!! Thank you Matt 🌺“

“Excellent pizza! Our new favorite!“

“This place is amazing! Friendly staff, fresh food, and an amazing owner. Jordan is such a great guy and it shows with how much he cares about this location! Great food all the time. There needs to be more small business owners like HIM!“

“Rocky told me Pizza Co. is the best pizza on the Island. I totally AGREE.“

“I had a surprise birthday party for my husband here. Approximately 50 people and plenty of indoor and outdoor seating PLUS room for the buffet style set up of food/pizza/drinks/cale/presents! The owner amd team are very easy to accommodate our needs and we enjoyed the most amazing pizzas, baked ziti, garlic knots and fresh salad! Can't wait for our next event to celebrate with their food!“

“Great pizza but the staff is very unprofessional and rude“

“Tried Pozzy Bro Pizza for the first time today. So happy we found our new pizza place! Everyone was so friendly and welcoming. Slices were giant and delicious.“

“Keys atmosphere fish from right off the shore excellent staff and wonderful food“

“I love their pizza, especially with extra cheese. Dough is thick and fresh. Their banana pudding cheesecake is delicious. But PLEASE get a phone number. I understand you guys prefer customers coming in to make it more personable, but I’ve wanted to buy your pizza so many more times where I’m too far to place the order in person and would love to just call ahead and then drive to you. My bf also wanted to place an order for the company he worked for during his lunch break, but he wouldn’t have had time to drive there, place the order in person, and then drive back. Would’ve been nice if he could place it online ahead of time, and then pick it up. I think adding a phone number while still requiring pick up in person is a good balance and it would still be personable. I think as a company you will make so much more dough $ (pun intended) with a phone number available. Food for thought, please reconsider. Also, if you start using olive oil to cook the pizza dough instead of generic soy or canola, it would crank this pizza up a notch. Still Love the GOAT!!!“

“Their food is absolutely amazing!“

“just enjoyed an AWESOME meat lovers. A great pie & a great owner“

“So good. NY Style at its best. My wife is from Brooklyn and loves it.“

“Great fried ravioli with marinara“

“Oceanside Pizza Cocoa is a great place serving delicious pizza. Stopped in for lunch a few times and it can be very busy, but service was quick and attentive. Parking is no problem as they share a large lot. Inside there are tables and bar seating in a large area. Ordered the chicken wings which were good and slices of pizza which were very tasty. Pizza was especially good and would recommend. Appetizers run $8-12 and pizza, stromboli, etc $14-23; gluten-free options are available which is nice. Large outdoor patio area, but this is Florida, so most of the year it is not used. Overall a great stop and would return again.“

“We love Pozzy Bros! They listen when you say you want it a little well done! Their pizza has a nice crust and great flavor. Salads could use more tomatoes, but are nice.“

“The best food with a view!!!“

“Can't eat inside but the car worked fine. Stopped here after going to KSC. We split a large meatball sub (not really a sub, more like a small pizza folded in half.) So good! Great flavor, good amount of cheese, (I'm from Wisconsin so I'm basically an expert on cheese.) Wish we had this chain up here. Best thing I ate all weekend.“

“It always tastes so fresh ! love Hunt Brothers pizza! I highly recommend it.“

“Marco’s Pizza is delicious and they use fresh dough, They also have Salads,Calzones,Subs,Desserts. They also have thin crust and cauliflower crust for gluten free menu Team Marco’s are good in Hospitality and customer service .“

“They hired a new GM named Mike, order was correct and pizza was fantastic. Great customer service and will definitely come back and order again.“

“the best pizza in town!!!“

“Esta comida es muy buena me gusta chewpar la manteca de la peeza asta la mesa“

“I order pizza here pretty often, and they always get it right. Very nice people that work there, they all seem friendly and easy to get along with. Most of the time I order there, it's very fresh. I haven't ever received anything lukewarm or stale. Pretty good deals too. If I am the only one eating, I can normally find a deal on the app that will get me an entire large pizza, and if I have reward points, I can get a side of garlic bites for around 10 to 12 dollars for everything. Pretty good deal.“

“I get a pizza too often for lunch but they are the best here so its hard not too. Jordan is always there with a smile when I walk in which is nice to see in that industry. Pizza is always ready and delicious. The place always looks brand new inside. So thanks Dominoes for this awesome location with good employees running it.“

“Great experience at Kelsey’s, pizza was quick and great! But most importantly EVERY employee was kind, nice and taking care of everyone in there! It was great!“

“Food, wine and desserts were out of this world for the 4 of us. Chef Alfredo went out of his way to check on his patrons dining at the restaurant this evening. I can go on and on, but I'll save it for later because I plan on frequenting Paradiso from now on. What a very pleasant surprise experiencing this restaurant that I had thought just opened in the past year.“

“We ate at The Kings Duck for dinner last night (11/19/25) and had Fish and Chips and a Mushroom Cheeseburger both with fries. The fries were some of crispiest, and tastiest we have ever had! Also, the Mushroom Swiss Burger cooked medium rare was perfectly cooked, which is hard to get done correctly. The Fish was also very good!!! I would recommend The Kings Duck for really good food!“

“New to the area and went today for the first time for lunch. Greeted immediately by the owner, ordered by the slice and could add any toppings. Pizza was absolutely delicious, hot, lots of toppings, prices were great!! 5+ stars highly recommend to all to try!!“

“Mimmo’s has high quality ingredients and a delicious pizza. The grandma pizza is a MUST! It keeps us coming back for more.“

“This is my neighborhood Domino's. I suggest using the app which provides great deals. It also allows you to keep track of any delivery you might have pending with Domino's. The New York style pizza is very good as is the Chicken Parm sandwich. My daughter loves the Parmesan bread bites. I usually pick up my order and the staff is always friendly and professional. I had my first delivery yesterday and I received my food in the time given. The driver, Samuel was very pleasant and professional.“

“fast and friendly :) curbside available“

“I frequent this place quite often. Every experience there has been wonderful. I could continue to gush like a kid with a crush but I won’t. Although, I will say that delivery 🚚 driver, Jenée Joy Krzyston, she definitely deserves a raise if she still works there. Side note 📝: She is even hotter than your pizza 🍕. Thanks for all the meals you have prepared for my family. We appreciate all that you do.“

“I was lucky enough to get help from a young lady name Kaswayla the other day. She was so sweet and friendly. I saw her working hard by herself not complaining, cooking, cutting, filling orders, and helping customers.she was just a ray of sunshine. I hope whoever is in charge gives her a raise! Thank you for helping with my order. I wish you the best Ms. Kaswayla! It was a pleasure meeting you!“

“So the babies and I just got Domino’s because we were hungry and I have a migraine so I didn’t want to get up. The delivery girl, Lexi, was seriously the sweetest and most bubbly person ever. She’s been gone for a while now and my kids are still talking about that “cute girl with the colorful hair that gave us pizza” So, Lexi, thank you for being a sweetheart! The babies and I adored that small encounter with you! Merry Christmas!🥰“

“Ms manager Mary Jo messed my order up and got nasty with me and hung her phone up in my face twice. She is very rude and need to be fired asap. I will be contacting corporate bright and early in the morning. I will not stop until she is Fired.“