Custom Cakes near Sarasota, FL

“The best wedding cake I've ever had...and it was so beautiful“

“Naranjo Café Bakery is a hidden gem for anyone who loves authentic Cuban pastries and baked goods. From the moment you walk in, the aroma of fresh bread and pastries fills the air, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. I recommend anybody looking for bday cakes, wedding this is your guy!“

“We ordered a custom carrot cake for my mom’s 65th birthday back in November 2025. Ordering was quick, easy, and Richard was so helpful! The cake design was so beautiful and exactly what we asked for. Not to mention, it tasted absolutely delicious as well. Will definitely be ordering again.“

“Delicious ice cream it reminded me of when I was a kid. My friend and I will be coming back to get ice cream here again once all the construction to the mall is done. The young woman with glasses I think was in charge reminded me that I shouldn’t judge a book by its cover. She was friendly and very helpful. Her and another young woman were able to direct us to the store we were searching for.“

“Wow…Once again FANTASTIC job! I sent in a picture of a cake I seen online for my sons bowling birthday party. Not only did sugarpaste make this beautiful cake , it tasted delicious! Excellent friendly customer service. Couldn’t be happier-
Thank you for making beautiful memories. Kristi
A+++++++++“

“We were immediately greeted by smiling staff and were patient while my daughter tried 3 flavors before deciding. Icecream is fantastic and a big thank you to Zachary for going above and Beyond when my daughter needed a lid to go, but the ice cream was in the car so he personally walked outside to find the right size for her, which was very nice“