Lenny'z Pizza and Island Bar

Lenny'z has a great atmosphere. The pizza was fantastic - New York style of course. The meatball appetizer was especially good. Our server Caleb brought the whole experience together with skill and a great attitude. He was outstanding. Thanks.

The gluten free pizza is excellent. They offer a cauliflower crust that is superb! if I could eat pizza every day, this is where I would go. So delicious!!

Amazing service! They’re family friendly. A huge connect four inside for people to play while waiting for food. The waiter brought out kid dough for the kids to “create” their own dough. It kept them occupied the WHOLE time waiting. Great touch you guys. Josephine was our waitress and she was phenomenal. I would HIGHLY recommend coming here to everyone and anyone.

pizza was awesome. service was perfect. Calib did a great job. we will be back.

Went to Lenny’z to watch the Steeler game and had a wonderful experience! The staff was super friendly, Caleb was a wonderful server, the food was great and very reasonable! This will definitely be a stop for us every time we are in Siesta Key!

We ate here last night. We were actually seeking out the pizza truck that parks at the brewery wanted some before we head home but he wasn't there.. so we saw reviews and tried it.. hubs got carnivore and it looked delicious but I didn't try it cause I don't always handle pepperoni well and I detest sausage. He said it was delicious. Son and I shared a Margherita pizza. The cheese was fresh basil was perfect and loved crust but found the pizza sauce to be just "eh". We did New York style crust. We had plenty of leftovers (2 cokes 2 16 inch pizzas $51.00) and I reheated 2 slices just now in oven on cookie sheet on 350 for about 5 minutes and then under broiler on high to melt cheese. It warmed up beautifully and for that I'd give them 4.5 ? ⭐ would go there again. Parking was free and not an issue. Friendly plenty of seating indoor and out too.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Just all around a great place, good food and awesome service! A true gem!
Dianna was our server and did a phenomenal job considering how busy it was. Absolutely bring your family here for lunch or dinner. Hot honey pizza was ? and so good!? I’m so happy!

Atmosphere: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

The pizza was great, and the ice cream over the hot cookie was amazing!! The owner was so nice, and so was our waiter!! We will definitely be back!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Very good ! We love
We will come back more often

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Parking: Great place for good quality food. Their pizzas are very filling. Highly recommend their meatballs, either the sub or appetizer. Staff is friendly and effective. Well stocked bar with plenty of beer choices.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Meatballs, House Salad, Waffle Fries, Meatball Sub

Highly recommend Lenny’s! We went here with our two toddlers and they went above and beyond for us…As soon as we sat down they gave our kids coloring pages and crayons in addition to sidewalk chalk! Perfect thing to entertain a 4 and 2 year old while the parents enjoy a cocktail. :) A little while later they brought pizza dough for our kids to play with- SO fun! Besides the pizza being AMAZING the service was outstanding. Couldn’t recommend this place enough. Will be coming back on our next trip!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great food, friendly service, loved it! Such a huge but pleasant surprise! It will for sure be a regular stop!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I ordered the jalapeno burger, medium rare with waffle fries. It was amazing, one of the best burgers I've ever had. The only complaint I have is they burnt the meat, there was no pink in it, it was cooked well done. Not sure if that was a miscommunication or just an accident but it was an amazing burger either way. Definitely recommend, just make sure to say you want it extra rare if you like it medium.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Lenny’z Pizza & Island Bar was delicious and priced right! 10/10 recommend!!!

We highly recommend getting the mozzarella sticks - they are huge! All the food came out piping hot!

Also, huge shout out to the staff and owners! They were very kind and on their A game.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Finally! Great service, clean facility, and most importantly DELICIOUS PIZZA!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5