Libby's

1917 S Osprey Ave, Sarasota
(941) 236-5826

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Joe

As always....consistently great food and service at one of our favorite local spots. Klaudia was our server and she was wonderful.

Dave

We've been to Libby's many times in our 20 years here and this was our best experience. The revamped menu has lots of choices both old and new. The prices are reasonable and the food was delicious. The portions are generous. Our waiter was new but very earnest and attentive without being overbearing. All in all, lots of reason to go back soon.

Helen

The food is excellent. Many delicious dishes to choose from. Wonderful contrast of flavors and textures. Ambiance is relaxing. Servers as well as management, do an excellent job at taking care of their diners.

Patricia

We started out with the meatball appetizer. It was so good that my husband then ordered the spaghetti and meatball dinner. It was happy hour and their wine was only $5/glass for their house Pinot Grigio - and they were generous with the pour. I ended up ordering their Thai Noodles and it was absolutely delicious! We have eaten at Libby's before and every time it has been great! Tonight was the best ever! Our waiter was very attentive and we had a wonderful experience. I highly recommend Libby's!

Dr C T

Libby's is one of our favorite restaurants. Always consistent! HH drinks are great! Everything we have ever ordered has been great! Service is always excellent.

randall

My eggs Benedict were not cooked. It was almost like eating raw eggs. I would have sent them back to the kitchen, but our waitress was nowhere to be found.

Heidi

We've been going to Libby's for about two years and have never been disappointed.

Dr. C T

We had our weekly dinner here Thursday night. Mitch did an outstanding job as our server. It was so nice to see Ericka as she came by to see us. The entire staff is just wonderful! Every dish we had was great! HH cocktails are amazing! We love Libby's.

Chris

Carbonara had too much bacon and therefore smoke overwhelmed the flavor. Also much of the bacon was underdone so was just pieces of raw fat. Crispy panchetta would be a better choice.

Howard

Great menu for value. Had the half rack of ribs. Fell off the bone and were delicious. My wife had the salmon. Always perfect.

Suzy

Typically this is one of our ‘go to' places ; however, this visit left us with a mediocre experience. Started out good w an on time reservation and attentive server where we received our drinks and ordered in a timely manner. Once our food arrived our server disappeared for the duration of our visit. We were never asked if everything was ok (one of our salads came w no dressing), if we'd like to order a second drink (which two of our party would have done), and our bill took a very long time to be presented to us. All in all a good but not great dinner out.

Cathy / Doug

Great find! Just outside the downtown with easy parking. Sat on the patio. I had salmon and husband had the Thai noodles. Both scrumptious. We did happy hour cocktails and were treated to a complimentary dessert as first timers. The Key Lime Pie OMG! Best I've ever had. We'll be back!!

Thomas Hemingway

Celebrated our wedding anniversary at Libby’s and this was the first time for my wife. We found the LWR location to be convenient, great atmosphere, with a broad menu! Portions were bordering on excessive! But we powered through some absolutely delicious food! The staff ensured we were well taken care! Carlos especially was outstanding and made sure we had a memorable and tasty anniversary dinner! She ordered the orange chicken I had the brisket burger with truffle fries You can be sure We’ll be back! Soon!! Thank you Libby’s and staff for a great evening!

Connie

The restaurant was a little warm and the staff kept leaving the sliding glass door to the patio open. Unfortunately, I was sitting close to that door.  The grilled chicken on my Caesar salad was dry and my croutons were soggy. Our waiter was very nice and did a good job, but came up missing quite frequently. He stated early on that they had seated several tables at the same time for him.

Gabriela Lopez Barnum

I came here for the first time tonight and was so blown away with the food and service! My husband and I came for a late dinner after a long day at work thinking it would be a basic American food restaurant but it was a lot more than that! The restaurant is beautiful (full of twinkle lights outside and great mood lighting inside) and is puppy friendly— the vibe is really awesome too. The food was so delicious, from the appetizers to dessert. Matthew was our waiter and he was the absolute best making our experience even more elevated! We will definitely be coming back— highly recommend coming here.

P.s. get the key lime pie! ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Orange Chicken

Loading...