Michelangelo Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant

The pizza, while not to my personal taste, was certainly not inexpensive. I appreciate the effort that went into its preparation, but it did not quite meet my expectations.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Spent/ wasted $65.00 on 2 low quality pizzas. Crust seemed either pre-made or microwaved. It was too tough to eat. The sauce was like someone went next door to Publix and threw on a can of stewed tomatoes. My bf is in the food industry, and I told him how great the food was! EPIC FAIL. How embarrassing!! I thought to return it but what's the point when there was nothing good about it! We threw it away! Live and learn.. I feel you owe me my $$ back, I feel scammed.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 2

Pizza was good

We moved to a new house and for a couple of years there, we used another Pizza Place that was a little closer to the house. I kept telling my wife, this pizza is good but
Michelangelo's is much better. About six months ago, we started coming back to Michelangelo's (University Pkwy location) and we are VERY HAPPY we did. We get the same exact thing, every time. One large Pepperoni and one large Cheese and it is always fantastic. The place is next to my wife's office so she always picks it up but she says the staff is great and service is amazing. The only thing I care about is pizza and I love it. The Michelangelo's Pizza we go to is on University Parkway in the Publix mini-mall - don't be fooled by other pizza shops if you want the best pizza in town!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza, Large Pizza, Sausage

Haven’t visited since before Covid and must say THEY HAVE NOT UPPED THEIR PRICES SINCE! The quality, portion and prices were SPECTACULAR!!! We definitely will be back on a regular basis!!! Thank you so much!!!

PS. $17 and we were stuffed enough to take home for ANOTHER MEAL!!!

Gratefully yours!
Michael&April Piccirillo
Bradenton FL

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Stuffed Pan Pizza, Cheese Pizza, Salad, Lasagna, Meatballs, Chicken Parm, Garlic Knots, Mozzarella Sticks, Sausage, White Pizza, Sicilian Pizza

Pizza was very well made and tasted delicious,service wasn’t the best but they were extremely bizzy with carry out orders .

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 3

Best damn pizza I've ever had. The service is excellent. Friendly family atmosphere.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Stuffed Pan Pizza, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, Spicy Chicken, Pesto Pizza, Chicken Parm, Garlic Knots, New Yorker

Great pizza

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Folks, I don't know if you are having a bad night, but... wow that was bad.
The lasagna doesn't look, taste or feel like a lasagna. Please do not call that a lasagna.
the ravioli and stuffed shells ended up being manicotti - it was passable.
The pasta with sauce barely had any sauce, if you want to call that a sauce. Just pouring out a can of tomato puree is not a sauce by itself.
The balsamic dressing for the salads - oh my... it would have been better if you bought one from walmart.
The chicken parm was bland. Big, but bland.
The pizza - I don't know, cause you forgot it.
The vodka sauce with meat had no meat.
I asked for them to deliver the pizza and it was refused. They said reorder and pay again.
Mama mia - that was bad. Never again.

Food: 1

Service: 2

Pizza is absolutely AMAZING. Ingredients are fresh high quality bright and full of flavor. The dining room is small and cozy. You can see your pizza being hand tossed . We did have to wait a bit for food but it was 6 at night and the middle of take out rush so it should be expected.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Large Pizza

This used to be my go to place to go grab two slices and a coke for lunch. Stopped in today to do the same sat for 10 minutes. I was the only customer in the restaurant. There were 5 staff members 10 feet away from me. Not 1 person came over to me. Not one person looked at me could not get waited on. Just for the record, every time I have been in there for lunch. When I get a seven or eight dollar tab, I leave a four dollar tip. Never going back. This is how they close restaurants.

Service: 1

Food is overpriced, flies all over the place, including all over the food they bring you. The staff are standing around on their phones. We had to ask for everything including refills and checks as they don’t come check on the table. It was also very very hot in there.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 2

Bad customer service and my food is never ready when it is supposed to be... it's not that hard. It's just pizza

I ordered the pasta combo which should have had, Ravioli, lasagna and stuffed shells. I got 2 manicotti and 2 stuffed shells. I wanted to give them a try despite their reviews. I won't be giving my business to a restaurant that doesn't deliver what I paid for. It's your restaurant, i should have received what i paid for. Shame on you!

I ordered via DoorDash and really enjoyed their food. Being a New Yorker, I’m picky about my pizza and Italian food. Their classic cheese pizza was good and their eggplant Parmesan was great and done right (sliced thin and fried). The garlic knots reminded me more of rolls as opposed to traditional garlic knots and the marinara sauce was a little bland but otherwise everything was great. I’d definitely order from here again!

Food: 5