Michelangelo Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant

Sunset specials: eggplant parmigiana, chicken piccata, each with a salad, a pasta of your choice, a cannoli. Both delicious dinners carefully prepared by Martino, with friendly service by Sarah. Clean, relaxed, calm dining experience inside. We loved it 😍 THANK YOU 🙏🏾

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The chicken had a gristle like texture and the cheese was a little thick for me but other than that it was good.. the thin crust was thin like I like and they didn't skimp on the veggies.
I recommend them and I will return

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Called in take out & it wasn’t ready. Whoever prepared the chicken parm didn’t have any cheese under the second piece. The Ziti pasta was almost white because there was no sauce on it. Ordered this dinner many times but this time it was very disappointing. The last two pickups was not their best. I know help is hard to get but people have got to be trained before waiting on customers. I hope they get their act together before customers don’t come back. Bill Niccolai ☹️

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

I order on delivery services from many places, but this is the most consistent and best when it comes to pizza. They Always do a perfect job. Keep up the good work. Well done always.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Simply amazing hospitality. The Chicken Marsala was absolutely phenomenal! Great portions. Will recommend to all. Thank you guys.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

These NY boyz know what they’re doing! Grandma’s Sicilian with spicy pepperoni and hot honey, absolutely fantastic. Broccoli Rabe with garlic and EVOO, fresh and yummy. Stuffed mushrooms taste like mom’s. And my mom, who usually only eats one slice but orders two so she can take one home, ate both slices. It’s BYOB, which is fine with me! Chef’s kiss!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I’m very upset at your establishment currently. I came in and spent $81 on two pizzas and some pasta (including a 25% tip). I could have taken my business anywhere else. THERE ARE LOTS OF PIZZA PLACES IN SARASOTA! I try my best to support local business instead of going to major chains. I dine in here on occasion. More than a couple times a year. I also choose to get takeout frequently because I love the Alfredo. This is the FOURTH time I have had my takeout order messed up from this location. The past three times my chicken on my pasta was either BURNT or missing. This to the point I literally stopped ordering chicken on my pasta. I gave your business grace & kept returning, regardless of the countless mess ups. Tonight may be the last straw for me. I asked for extra cheese on my side salad. I repeated myself multiple times to the gentleman that took my order. I get home and surprise, surprise, NO CHEESE on my salad. NO PARMESAN OR CRUSHED RED PEPPER FOR THE PIZZA. This is incredibly irritating. It may sound like a small issue, but it is the repeated lack of customer service that upsets me. I call up there. I was polite, yet maybe stern about my discontent. Instead of offering to fix my order, the girl on the phone speaks to the manager. I hear him yell in the background that he’s “too busy to talk to me and I can call back tomorrow.” I find this behavior from a manager very unprofessional. Coming from someone in the food industry, this is just simply not how you treat a customer who works very hard to support your establishment. I will note that my food was tasty. Supreme pizza was about a 5/10. Cheese was a perfect 10. Alfredo was a perfect 10. Salad, I’m going to give that a 0.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 1

Changed my review been awesome since new ownership!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I've had better Italian in the cafeteria back in high school. The ricotta in the stuffed shells was dry, crumbly, and flavorless. The sauce tasted canned, and was so watery. The Baked Ziti was essentially dry, with a clump of sauce in the middle and a slice of cheese melted on top.
We couldnt even cut the pizza with a pizza cutter, we had to use poultry scissors. DEFINITELY not worth the money.

Food: 1

Ordered the scillian, which we have always loved in the past. However, the crust was like a very thick, spongy foccia bread. And there was barely any sauce!! So disappointing. Hard to eat. Sad, especially for $40.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 2

Service: 3

My husband and I wanted an easy night in so we ordered door dash. 30% off our order deal we tried Michelangelos for the first time. I wanted pasta and he wanted a calzone! MAN we got portion sizes to feed a whole family. The price for what you pay is so worth it. My Tortellini was so heavy and when we opened the box the calzone was in was not expecting a large to be half the whole pizza box. Lots of cheese inside calzone and pasta had the perfect amount of sauce. The fresh bread on the side was a plus. Love the Greek salad dressing. Food arrived quick and still very hot as if it just came out in the restaurant. Will definitely be ordering from here again!

Food: 5

Good pizza, very very nice service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

We love coming here for a quick bite. The team is always in a good mood, food is great!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Very good pizza, excellent service and great atmosphere. This is a good lunch spot. The crust on the pizza slice we got was excellent thin and crispy. The Margarita slice & pesto slice both had lots of flavor and I would absolutely get it again.
The white pizza slice & the Lasagna slice while very tasty we're overpowered with the amount of Ricotta cheese on them. It kinda dulled the flavor and made these two slices a wee bit bland. I probably wouldn't order those types again but that won't keep me from returning to this pizza joint again and again.

PS we got an amazing picture of a freshwater croc in the pond beside the restaurant.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sicilian Pizza, Large Pizza, Pesto Pizza

never thought calamari pizza could taste any better!! it was a first for the person I shared with and he was blown away!! thank you Danny and staff for satisfying my craving!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5