Mayday Ice Cream Midtown St. Augustine
1765 Tree Blvd #5, St. Augustine
(904) 339-2825
Customers' Favorites
Queen Salted Caramel Pilot with Chocolate Sauce Cacao Nibs and Sprinkles
Two Scoops Almond Butter Chocolate with Sprinkles Cacao Nibs & Cookie
Pilot 1 Scoop of Queen Salted Caramel in a Cup
Pilot One Scoop Ice Cream Cups
Smores Pilot with Cacao Nibs
Various Ice Cream Selections
Key Lime Pie Ice Cream Pint
Pints of Ice Cream to-Go
Blueberry French Toast
Banana Pudding
Menu
Photos
+22 photos
+21 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Incredible ice cream! Probably the best I’ve ever had in Florida. The quality and richness is so good. I’m so tired of overrated places that have cheap-tasting ice cream. This place is the BEST!
Delaney Riley is the best server we have encountered at Mayday . She is patient, friendly, and knowledgeable. She seems to enjoy her job and thus makes Mayday look even better.
Vegetarian options: Ice cream for vegetarians or vegans
Parking: Always available
Vegetarian options: Ice cream for vegetarians or vegans
Parking: Always available
The service was poor. He rolled his eyes at me and was very grumpy. The selection of ice cream was lacking with 2 containers of at least 3 of their flavors. The atmosphere was nice, but nothing to write home about.
You May Also Like
Yamato Japanese Steak House & Sushi Bar - 601 Tingle Ct
![]()
Japanese, Sushi Bar
Panera Bread - 600 Tingle Ct
![]()
Cafe, Salad, Soup, Vegan
Sonic Drive-In - 704 E Geoffrey St
![]()
Fast Food, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Burgers