New American Restaurants in St. Augustine, FL

“new to town and decided to try this restaurant since it's only 5 minutes away. Boy am I glad I did! I got the pan fried fish and crab cake. It was amazing and very heavy portions as well. my boyfriend got the swiss burger which was just as delicious. and the service was amazing. Sam was our bartender, she was very helpful and gave us 10/10 service. Will definitely be back again very soon.“

“A group of us went to Sonnys on the Fourth of July for lunch. The ribs were very good some said the best they’ve ever had. I had the big meal deal with the beef sandwich and the beef was very tender. Service was great. Only thing we miss is the salad bar🥲“

“We had Sporks cater our wedding December 14, 2024, and they did a phenomenal job! Miles and Libby were so helpful. The food and service was phenomenal - plus we love their restaurant too! Highly recommend them if you have a function that needs catering!“

“This is a hidden gem, so I’ll type type quietly. The food here is fresh, tasty and good looking! I had the salmon salad. The salmon was fresh with a smoky flavor. Bottom was nicely done with-a brown crisp to it Home made salad dressing was tossed with the salad. Salad had greens,capons , mushrooms, red onion, cheese and a very good flavor. Hubby had the shrimp wrap with a spinach tortilla. Delightful flavor all around“

“Great brunch! Food was amazing and the staff was amazing too!“

“A True Hidden Gem in St. Augustine The Collage exceeded all our expectations. We’ve visited St. Augustine many times, but this was our first time discovering this incredible restaurant, and what a find! We were celebrating our 21st anniversary and stumbled upon The Collage online. Thinking it would be quiet on a Wednesday night, we didn’t make a reservation. Despite being fully booked, Megan, the restaurant manager, went out of her way to accommodate us, which we truly appreciated. Our server, Franco, was warm, attentive, and very knowledgeable. The food was absolutely phenomenal from start to finish. We began with the beef carpaccio and watermelon salad; both beautifully prepared. For our main course, we each had the 8oz filet topped with gorgonzola sauce, and every bite was mouthwatering. Between courses, we were treated to a refreshing raspberry sorbet to cleanse our palates—a lovely touch. For dessert, we shared a warm pound cake with raspberry coulis and fresh whipped cream, paired with perfectly made espressos. The ambiance was quaint, cozy, and romantic,ideal for a special occasion like ours. We especially loved that the menu changes regularly, offering something new to look forward to each time. We’re so happy to have found this gem and will absolutely be returning. Highly recommended! Thanks Again, The Gennaro’s“

“Had an amazing evening at the Forgotten Tonic. The drinks were creative and well made. The food was to die for, we are considering replacing pumpkin pie with pumpkin bread pudding at Thanksgiving this year thanks to our experience. The whole night was enhanced by our lovely server Tamara. She was professional, knowledgeable, and an absolute angel. We will be returning in the future and recommending The Forgotten Tonic to anybody who cares to listen.“

“From the drinks to dessert everything was perfect. Once again, our dinner was fabulous! Steve had the filet, was outstanding. I had the tuna tartare stack, amazing! We shared the chocolate molten cake which was delicious, can’t find the appropriate word to describe because it was the BEST we have ever had. This is our favorite restaurant.“

“Delicious food!! so glad we saw this place while turning around in the parking lot. the food was fresh and absolutely yummy. definitely will be going there again! had the turkey bacon sandwich on a bed of lettuce instead and added avocado. wow! and the sweet potato fries were cooked to perfection.“

“Amazing service and food. We just love the ladies here.“

“We had dinner at Elkhouse Eatery and were so very pleased with the service and food. Wonderful presentation and delivery. It's a must try when your in town.“

“Always friendly service and delicious food at the Amelia Island location!“

“The food was absolutely delicious. We tried the escargot and definitely did not regret it. The atmosphere in the once past pool was a different experience. Quiet, romantic and simply beautiful. Our waitress was phenomenal and cared to our every need. We can’t wait to come back.“

“We had a wonderful experience here and the dining area so pristine. Delicious eats and we also loved our waitress. Went with my sister and her boyfriend. Parking was great . Overall just a good time!“

“Stopped in here for an after dinner drink. Service was friendly and attentive. Atmosphere was warm and peaceful even though their were other groups around. If you're looking for a place to talk while having food or a beverage, I highly recommend.“

“Service was great. I ordered the wrong drink for my mom they were super accommodating and fixed it all for us. Food was fresh and hot. Crispy fries and the turkey grilled cheese is great. Been here twice both times good stuff. Grab and go as you walk St George St“

“Evening food and service are top notch. The present crew: Stephanie, Cecelia and Jordan are the absolute best with friendly service, not to mention a great chef, kitchen, staff and management. Could do a little better on architectural ambiance, mood lighting and seating...“

“Little Margie’s is the best place to visit in St. Augustine Beach. Very family oriented and friendly. Food is fantastic as is Margie herself and everyone I’ve met in the restaurant. Highly recommend for breakfast/brunch/lunch/dinner😊“

“Stopped by today 2/14/2025 and sat at the bar for an adult beverage and dessert:) It was a different kind of experience sitting there (usually at a table eating!). Well let me tell you the 2 bartenders Taylor & Lena were the best!! So fun watching them being “mixologists”….so good!! They were so sweet too! And of course our drinks were sooo good, “a chocolate covered kiss and simple beer for the hubby!”. But to top it off Eddie, the chef came out and delivered a special dessert to me. So yummy and he is soooooo nice. OC White’s are so fortunate to have these 3 as part of their staff and many others. And let me mention their food is the best!! Thanks for topping off our Valentine’s Day!!! Jacqueline & Bob Scheidler ♥️“