Catalina Cafe

603 W Gaines St #6, Tallahassee
(850) 999-1559

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Breakfast blt Regular
Lox Bagel Regular
Egg and Cheese
Lox Sandwich

Menu

Toast
Loaded Avocado
Avocado, tomato, and cucumber on toasted sourdough bread spread with whipped cream cheese
Tomato and Pesto
Sourdough toast with Catalina's house-made pesto, tomato, and drizzled with balsamic reduction.
Hummus
sourdough toast with hummus, tomato and cucumber

Breakfast
Meat, Egg, and Cheddar
bacon, sausage or turkey, egg and cheese, served on bread, bagel or wrap
Bagel and Cream Cheese
Choice of bagel with whipped cream cheese.
Hungry Tally Sandwich
bacon, sausage, egg and cheddar, served on ciabatta or whole grain bread
Egg and Cheese
egg and cheese (provolone or cheddar), served on bread, bagel or wrap
Breakfast BLT
bacon, romaine, tomatoes and cream cheese on your choice of ciabatta or whole grain bread
Lox Bagel Sandwich
Lox(salmon), cream cheese, tomatoes, capers, and pickled red onions.
Spicy Breakfast
sausage, egg and tomato with sriracha cream cheese served on ciabatta or whole grain bread

Lunch
Catalina Turkey Bacon Club
turkey, bacon, romaine, tomatoes and mayo, served on whole grain bread or ciabatta
Turkey Brie Raspberry
Turkey, brie, and raspberry preserves, served on ciabatta
Pressed Grilled Veggie
seasonal grilled vegetables with tomato, pesto and cheese, served on wrap or ciabatta

Gluten Free Bowls
Protein, Egg, and Cheddar
bacon, sausage or turkey, egg and cheese - bread free!
Breakfast BLT
bacon, romaine, tomatoes and cheddar cheese on top of our original recipe scrambled egg
Hungry Tally Bowl
Both bacon and sausage with egg and cheddar - bread free!
Egg and Cheese
egg and cheese (provolone or cheddar) - bread free!

Drinks
Signature Latte
16 oz, latte made with house-made syrups and sauces, three shots of espresso and your choice of milk
Latte
16oz, drink with three shots of espresso and choice of milk
Catalina Cold Brew
16oz Cold Brew
Café con Leche
16 oz, drink made with three shots of espresso and 4 teaspoons of organic sugar with your choice of milk
Seasonal Iced Tea
16 oz, iced tea made in house with organic teas and ingredients
Chai Tea Latte
16 oz, TallahasseeTea Company's masala chai tea with milk served hot or cold
Bottled Water
Gatorade
12 oz, can of Gatorade - if flavors are not available we will substitute
Mazagran
16oz, Iced lemonade and cold brew concentrate
Americano
16 oz, drink with three shots of espresso over water
Drip Coffee
16oz Hot Coffee

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+56 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+55 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

This place was a godsend. I'm on Wegovy so I needed a high protein meal without all the greasy, fatty ingredients that usually come with a breakfast sandwich. I ordered a turkey, egg, and cheese sandwich on whole grain toast. It was amazing.
February 2026
Love love love this coffee shop, but I only come here to have a place outside of my apartment to study and recently something must have changed with their wifi because I can’t access any websites including my canvas page while on the wifi here. Will have to start going somewhere else because I need a productive place to work.
January 2026
We came here for coffee and breakfast both days we were in town. The coffee is consistently delicious, and the egg bowls are the most satisfying breakfast I've had at a coffee shop. I highly recommend the French toast sticks for an indulgent, sweet treat. We're so happy to have found Catalina Cafe during our stay.
January 2026

More Reviews

Catalina Cafe

603 W Gaines St #6, Tallahassee, FL 32304
(850) 999-1559