Gaines Street Pies
1184 Capital Cir NE Suite E, Tallahassee
(850) 329-2141
Customers' Favorites
Pepperoni and Mushroom Pie with a Local Stout and Blonde Ale
The Cheesecake Calzone
Sausage and Mushrooms
Caesar Side Salad
Margherita Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Cheesy Bread
Garlic Knots
Slice
Featured items
18" Pie
14" Pie
14" Works
Pepperoni, italian sausage, ham, bell peppers, red onion, mushrooms and black olives. Classic.
Jalepeno Poppers
Fresh (not frozen!) jalapeño poppers stuffed with a savory blend of cream cheese and cheddar, wrapped with bacon and baked to perfection. Served with homemade ranch for dipping.
10" Derek Sanders
Green peppers, black olives, onions, spinach, mushrooms, fresh tomato and garlic.
18" Works
10" Margherita
Not yo mama's margherita pizza! A combination of fresh cut basil, tomato and extra virgin olive oil with a fresh Mozzarella twist and then finished with a hint of cracked black pepper.
18" Animal
14" Bruno
A Pepperoni pizza with ham, capicola, pepperoncinis, and garlic.
10" Animal
Pepperoni, Sausage, Ham, Bacon, and romano.
Pizza
10" Pie
14" Pie
18" Pie
Slice
10" Calzone-Regular Price
10" Calzone-Chicken Florentine
14" Calzone-Regular
14" Calzone-Chicken Florentine
Hot-Pepperoni
10" Specialty
10" Margherita
Not yo mama's margherita pizza! A combination of fresh cut basil, tomato and extra virgin olive oil with a fresh Mozzarella twist and then finished with a hint of cracked black pepper.
10" White Album
Ricotta base with arugula, tomato, onion, garlic, basil and truffle oil.
10" Metal Mike
Another GSP favorite! Chicken, bacon, ranch, garlic, sriracha and green onions.
10" Saucy Minx
Our marinara sauce base topped with homemade meatballs, ricotta cheese dollops, bell peppers and fresh basil.
10" Temptation
Vegan. Follow your heart "cheese", garlic and olive oil base, portable mushroom, arugula, pineapple, basil and balsamic glaze.
10" Figure Four
Hot capicola, roasted figs, fresh garlic and goat cheese with an olive oil base.
10" BBQ Chicken
Light tomato sauce, smothered with house BBQ sauce, chicken and yellow onions.
10" Mo Rockin'
Basil pesto base, eggplant, onions, feta, fresh garlic, basil, and cracked black pepper.
10" Buffalo Chicken
Ranch dressing base, buffalo sauce, chicken, gorgonzola, green onion, and candied jalapeños for good measure.
10" Works
Pepperoni, italian sausage, ham, bell peppers, red onion, mushrooms and black olives. Classic.
10" Honey Pigs
Smoked andouille sausage, cream cheese, orange blossom honey and candied jalapeños.
10" Harty Party
Vodka sauce base with Fresh Mozzarella and Pesto Swirl
10" Derek Sanders
Green peppers, black olives, onions, spinach, mushrooms, fresh tomato and garlic.
10" Pesto Chicken
Basil pesto topped with fresh tomato, onions and baked chicken breast.
10" Sword
Oil and garlic base with chicken, fresh pineapple, feta and arugula, drizzled with balsamic reduction and garnished with fresh basil.
10" Animal
Pepperoni, Sausage, Ham, Bacon, and romano.
10" Bacon Bleus
Bacon, Gorgonzola and house roasted red peppers.
10" Freaks
Olive oil sun-dried tomato base with artichoke, roasted red peppers, pepperoncinis, feta and kalamata olives.
10" Smitty
Double pepperoni, mushrooms, sriracha infused pizza sauce and garlic.
10" Bruno
A Pepperoni pizza with ham, capicola, pepperoncinis, and garlic.
10" Specialty Pie Of The Month
10" Mitchka
A savory blend of sausage, baked eggplant, fresh garlic, romano and mozzarella
14" Specialty
14" Works
Pepperoni, italian sausage, ham, bell peppers, red onion, mushrooms and black olives. Classic.
14" Margherita
Not yo mama's margherita pizza! A combination of fresh cut basil, tomato and extra virgin olive oil with a fresh smoked Mozzarella twist and then finished with a hint of cracked black pepper.
14" White Album
Ricotta base with arugula, tomato, onion, garlic, basil and truffle oil.
14" Honey Pigs
Smoked andouille sausage, cream cheese, orange blossom honey and candied jalapeños.
14" Buffalo
Ranch dressing base, buffalo sauce, chicken, gorgonzola, green onion, and candied jalapeños for good measure.
14" Bruno
A Pepperoni pizza with ham, capicola, pepperoncinis, and garlic.
14" Metal
Another GSP favorite! Chicken, bacon, ranch, garlic, sriracha and green onions.
14" Figure Four
Hot capicola, roasted figs, fresh garlic and goat cheese with an olive oil base.
14" Saucy Minx
Our marinara sauce base topped with homemade meatballs, ricotta cheese dollops, bell peppers and fresh basil.
14" Mo Rockin
Basil pesto base, eggplant, onions, feta, fresh garlic, basil, and cracked black pepper.
14" Pesto Chicken
Basil pesto topped with fresh tomato, onions and baked chicken breast.
14" Derek Sanders
Green peppers, black olives, onions, spinach, mushrooms, fresh tomato and garlic.
14" Smitty
Double pepperoni, mushrooms, sriracha infused pizza sauce and garlic.
14" Harty Party
Vodka sauce base with Fresh Mozzarella and Pesto Swirl
14" BBQ Ckn
Light tomato sauce, smothered with house BBQ sauce, chicken and yellow onions.
14" Sword
Oil and garlic base with chicken, fresh pineapple, feta and arugula, drizzled with balsamic reduction and garnished with fresh basil.
14" Bacon Bleus
Bacon, Gorgonzola and house roasted red peppers.
14" Temptation
Vegan. Daiya "cheese", garlic and olive oil base, portable mushroom, arugula, pineapple, basil and balsamic glaze.
14" Freaks
Olive oil sun-dried tomato base with artichoke, roasted red peppers, pepperoncinis, feta and kalamata olives.
14" Animal
Pepperoni, meatball, ham, bacon, and romano.
14" Specialty Pie of the Month
14" Mitchka
A savory blend of sausage, baked eggplant, fresh garlic, romano and mozzarella.
18" Specialty
18" Animal
18" Margherita Mayhem
18" Figure Four
18" Metal Mike
18" Honey Pigs
18" Works
18" Smitty
18" Bacon Bleu
18" Buffalo
18" MO Rockin
18" Harty Party
Vodka sauce base with Fresh Mozzarella and Pesto Swirl
18" Derek Sanders
18" White Album
18" Saucy Minx
18" Bruno
18" Sword
18" Pesto Chicken
18" Freaks
18" BBQ Chicken
18" Specialty Pie Of The Month
18" Temptation
18" Mitchka
Appetizers
Garlic Knots
6 stone-baked, puffy wonders of garlicky, buttery goodness topped with Romano cheese and served with a side of marinara.
Spinach And Artichoke Dip
Fresh, hot and delicious! Made in house and served wit our freshly baked pita bread.
Jalepeno Poppers
Fresh (not frozen!) jalapeño poppers stuffed with a savory blend of cream cheese and cheddar, wrapped with bacon and baked to perfection. Served with homemade ranch for dipping.
Hummus Plate
A generous portion of hummus served with baked fresh pita bread, roasted red peppers, cucumber slices, kalamata olives, and feta cheese.
Caprese Salad
Layers of tomato and fresh mozzarella, topped with basil and balsamic reduction.
Cheesy Bread
Our 10" Garlic-Buttered Hand-Tossed dough loaded with mozzarella, provolone, cheddar, and Romano cheeses. Served with homemade ranch.
Salads
Southern Greek Salad-Regular
Arugula Apple Salad-Regular
Arugula Apple Salad-w/ Chicken
Southern Greek Salad-w/ chicken
Side House Salad-Regular
Side Caesar salad-Regular
Ceasar, Stay Classy-Regular
Ceasar, Stay Classy-w/ Chicken
House Salad-Regular
Side Caesar salad-w/ chicken
Side House Salad-w/ chicken
Spinach Salad-W/ chicken
House Salad-With Chicken
Spinach Salad-Regular
Cobb Salad
x 1/2 Pan Catering Salad-House
x 1/2 Pan Catering Salad-Caesar
x 1/2 Pan Catering Salad-Apple and Arugula
x 1/2 Pan Catering Salad-Spinach Salad
x 1/2 Pan Catering Salad-Southern Greek
x 1/2 Pan Catering Salad-Cobb
Large Catering Salad
Sandwiches
Chicken Parm Sub
Fresh baked chicken breast, our house made marinara and a blend of mozzarella and romano cheeses on a hoagie roll. Served w/ side
Meatball Sub
Family recipe homemade meatballs with our house made marinara and a blend of mozzarella and romano cheeses on a hoagie roll.
Chicken Caesar Sub
Tender chicken breast, mozzarella, crisp romaine and onion tossed in romano and our house caesar dressing. Served w/ side.
Newsoms Italian Sub
Pepperoni, capicola, ham, arugula, onion and tomato with cheese and balsamic vinaigrette.
Eggplant Sub
Eggplant with our house made marinara and a blend of mozzarella and romano cheeses on a hoagie roll. Served w/ side.
Wrights Sausage Sub
Wraps
Buffalo Bleu Wrap
Baked chicken, sliced onion, mozzarella and gorgonzola, tossed in buffalo sauce and homemade ranch.
Bowsers Bluff Wrap
Baked chicken, bacon, our homemade spinach/artichoke dip, mozzarella, goat cheese and sriracha infused ranch!
BBQ Chicken Wrap
Baked chicken, onion, mozzarella and cheddar tossed in bbq sauce and baked until crispy.
Hero Wrap
chicken breast, fresh spinach, kalamata olives, onion, mozzarella and feta with our homemade sun-dried tomato dressing.
Desserts
Cookies & Cream
Our hand-tossed dough topped with a delicious blend of rich butter, cream cheese, white chocolate and Oreos.
Cheesecake Calzone
New York Cheesecake filling and milk chocolate baked into a 10" calzone and topped with cinnamon.
Sauce
Ranch-Regular
Garlic Butter
Marinara
Ranch Jar
Blue Cheese Dress
Caesar Dressing
Pesto
Sdt
Bbq
Balsamic Vin
Hot Sauce
Photos
+33 photos
+32 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Can we give this 6 or 7 stars??? I need this in Texas!?!? We stopped in Tallahassee for the night, on our way to Orlando. Our favorite part of our road trips, is finding places to eat we can’t find at home. And pizza is my husband’s fave. I don’t normally gravitate to pizza, but this menu had my attention! We ordered the Honey Pig and and pepperoni with marinated portabella mushrooms. These were, simply put, the best pizzas we have had to date on a road trip! Hands down!...
April 2025
This restaurant lost us as loyal customers today. I cannot eat gluten or dairy but I love pizza. We have been ordering from here a couple times a month as it’s the best gf/dairy free I’ve found in town. Every once in a while they mess up and give me mozzarella instead of vegan cheese. This happened a couple weeks ago and at the time it was handled beautifully. They cooked the pizza over again and sent their driver to deliver the remake free of charge. I was super grateful...
September 2024
The pizza that we order here is always good, my only complaint with this place is that the hummus platter is always served different, there is no consistency. This time I got 3 slices of cucumber last time the dough was raw. They will give me platters with only a few of the different toppings or much more than needed. Other than that, the food here is pretty good.
August 2024
You May Also Like
Captain Pete's House of Gyros - 1184B Capital Cir NE
![]()
Mediterranean, Greek, Salad
RedEye Coffee Capital Circle - 1196 Capital Cir NE ste d
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee, Coffee & Tea, Flowers & Gifts
Lucky Goat Coffee - 668 Capital Cir NE
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Coffee Roasteries, Coffee, Cafe