24 Best Italian Restaurants in Tallahassee

“Amazing food and atmosphere!“

“Best restaurant in Tallahassee“

“McKenna was amazing and the food was so yummy! ❤️“

“Excellent service & delicious food!!“

“omgosh amazing food and service. had the pork duo, braises beef ribs, crab cakes, and bread with herb infused oil. definitely a 10/10 in our books. it's not a quick eating place takes about 1.5-2 hours and price is up there so sharing maybe an option especially with what we had but glad we chose our own meals instead of sharing.“

“Love the food and service was excellent! The only concern I had was the hostess just pointed to the table she wanted us to sit at….did not take us to the table, we were the only ones wanting to be seated. As the evening progressed, she sat some, pointed to the table to others.“

“the food is amazing (esp the cream of mushroom soup) but what makes this place so special is the amazing service. every time i go in, i ask for sarah and she never ever disappoints. she’s friendly, attentive, our drinks are never empty and she’s knowledgeable. she is what makes our experience so great.“

“Only thing I found ! Chicken in tour of Italy salty and dry! Still ok! Employees coming few minutes before opening not a good idea! Should be at least 15 with pay so they are ready when doors open !“

“Fantastic italian food....best in Tallahassee by far. We dined in for lunch. Portion sizes huge and delicious. Our new favorite spot“

“This place reminds me of an old Italian restaurant I worked for in high school. The staff is always nice, the atmosphere is typically what you would expect from an Italian restaurant, and it's normally pretty quiet, but gets busy when the students are back. The prices are good in comparison to other chain imposters. The food is always prepared fresh, the pizza is good, the clazone's are outstanding. It's become a favorite of my wife and I.“

“The best Italian food in Tallahassee! We had several different items off of their menu that were all great! The one that stood out the most was the veggie soup! 🥣 I’ve never been a fan of veggie soup but decided to try it & it’s the best soup I’ve ever had! I ended up leaving with two Togo orders 😂 Annagail provided excellent service We will be back next Friday!“

“Date night dinner with my husband. Delicious food, nice atmosphere! Great “above and beyond” service by Sevonnah!! ♥️ Huge portions and complementary bread. Already planning a return trip!“

“Just wow!!! This is now my favorite pizza! I'll be making the trip to bring this home. Definitely worth it.“

“Today was my first time dining at PrimoHoagies and it definitely will not be my last! Upon arrival, I was greeted by Ted Santiago, the manager. He was courteous and patient with me throughout the entire ordering process. I ordered the philly cheese sub combo, which also came with a bag of chips and a beverage. The meat and the veggies were tender and well seasoned. Moreover, the honey BBQ chips were 🔥 – the best chips I'd had to date! Thank you Ted for making my first experience an enjoyable one. I'll be back soon.“

“It was all great! Food was as good as it can be and service by Garrison was exceptional. We especially like the ambiance of the table seating in the bar area.The Reward Plan is a good idea although it takes a lot of purchases for a $15 reward.“

“There were 2 girls working one had blonde hair and the other brown or black and they immediately greeted us and were very nice and attentive, and the pizza was good literally the best in town, Super hot and fresh. Other places I’ve gone taste like a frozen pizza I’m not even lying when I tell y’all it was amazingggg“

“Past couple times I ordered my food it was great and both delivery dudes (Kurt & william) have been awesome! Quick with a positive attitude! Thank you!“

“We traveled 2 1/2 hours from Alabama to Tallahassee. We found things to do downtown to add to our day. However, the main purpose of our trip was to visit this restaurant. The pizza was amazing. We went that far based on the recommendation of 2 of my Italian 🇮🇹 Army flight students at Fort Novosel (Rucker). They told us your restaurant had the most authentic Italian 🇮🇹 style pizza they had found within 3 hours of Fort Novosel. I fully agree with their assessment. The pizza was nearly identical to what we ate in Naples, Italy 🇮🇹 6 years ago. We look forward to visiting again in the future. Maybe when we go back, it will be warmer so we can enjoy more of Tallahassee. BTW, for those in other reviews that complained about the crust being nearly paper thin, that is how it is in Italy 🇮🇹. This restaurant aims to make authentic Italian pizzas. If that is not what you are looking for, you need to find an American 🇺🇸 style pizza restaurant.“

“I'm not sure if they are the same as the Marco's In Bethlehem pa but damn it sure reminded me if home got 3 pizzas philly cheese which I loved cause of the American cheese 🔥, bbq chicken 🔥 last but not least the pepperoni magnifico kids loved it the mini cup pepperoni is classic I will definitely put this in my top 3 of pizza in tallahassee.“

“Best pie in Tallahassee. I love a number of pizza joints in town, and I had never heard of brickyard (no idea why), but it's right by the house amd I gave it a try. It is now our ONLY pizza that we get.

My son always wants to do the Dave Portnoy "1 bite" rules when rating pizza, so we ordered the specialty cheese, with crispy crust last night.

I scored it a 9.1 (my no 1 in town) and my son scored it 9.5 (his highest score ever)

Zero bend in the crust, not greasy, fantastic flavor.

Highly recommended!“

“xoxo xoxo xoxoxo xoxoxo xo xoxo“

“During Covid 19 currently in September HH has drive-thru carryout or delivery available. My go to locations are on W. Pensacola Street or Blair Stone Road near Southwood. The pizzas are always delicious!“

“This my regular go-to Hungry Howies and I never had any big issues, they might have not cooked the cheese all the way through or been skippy with it but on average it's good. Now on Tuesday, 02/11/25 somebody was in there who either loves their job or cares about the food they put out. They did a wonderful job, I got a large cheese/sausage with extra cheese and I requested the cheese be well-melted and they came through for your girl. Shout out to them and I hope it's a consistent thing. Thank you to whoever made my pizza!“

“The man that took my order was very pleasant and knowledgeable and I appreciated that since it was my first time in Howies. It was quick service and he actually served us like waiter would. Different flavored crystal was fabulous! Got the Cajun and garlic......was great!!!“