Tally Fish House & Oyster Bar

We celebrated a birthday there. The food was wonderful and her server was great. Made for a great experience!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I love the Fettuccine alfredo
The server Casey R was the best 💖 We will be back soon

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Food was good not great but good ordered oysters and they came out maybe 5 minutes before the food. Prices are stupid high for what you get. Could have gotten same food for half the price anywhere in town. They need to get real with the prices and the portion you get for that much money.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

Service was good but they only had one waitress and she was doing the best with what she had. Dinner took two hours. Coconut shrimp tasted like it was left over and reheated. No dipping sauce for the coconut shrimp. Hush puppies were burnt. The Alfredo sauce tasted weird and left a weird bitter after taste. Not a good experience and won’t be returning.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 1

Service: 4

Came down to Tallahassee move-in weekend and stopped in to Tallys for a drink. Sean the bartender was phenomenal and so fun! I stayed for the bang bang shrimp and a couple more drinks. 😉 Thank you for a great experience. I'll definitely be back when I'm back in town!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

We have been twice. The first experience was WAY better than the first. I’m giving three stars cause a restaurants inability to be consistent is an issue to me. I ordered a Caesar salad with blacked chicken and a side of cheese grits. My salad dressing was an Italian vinaigrette…. And the server forgot my grits. My dad’s fries came out cold. He asked for some to be brought out that were fresh. They came out cold again. These are simple things that could be easily avoided.

dirty resteraunt, not a pleasant surrounding. they were out of 3 different items I asked for. Then my food came out burnt and way overcooked tasted like charcoal. not pleased and I traveled to get here

We came in town last weekend to take my niece to college and stopped by here. First of all the sign says fresh fish daily and my fish came out partially frozen. DISGUSTING. The air vent above us was dripping water and covered in black mold. To add to that all the bathrooms were literally duck taped off so I had to use the employee one in the back which apparently the lock doesn’t work because I had someone walk in on me. Not to mention there was no toilet paper but instead a roll of paper towels sitting on the toilet. All my families food was undercooked so we payed our overpriced tab and left. I believe they were playing sexxy red in the background of a “family friendly” restaurant which is not appropriate for young children whatsoever. Very disappointing and will not be back. My mom then asked for a to-go water and it had a brownish tint and tasted awful.

The $24.99 Maine lobster actually tasted better than ones we've gotten in New England. Even the fried okra was the best we've ever had, light crispy breading outside and moist inside, like fried eggplant would be. I enjoyed my citrusy white sangria, rather like a mimosa. The Boss oysters from Wakulla were a great suggestion by the server.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Come for the fresh seafood and stay for the humorous bartender, Sean! The food is great! We've never had a bad experience or a bad plate!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Today the food was terrible and the service was mediocre. There was one waitress for the entire restaurant at lunch hour.

Hey guys. Just stopped in at Tally Fish& Oyster. Ordered the Captains platter. Hushpuppies were undercooked and my crab patty looked burnt on both sides. It would have been ok if it hadn't tasted burnt. Oh and the collards were winter tuff.
It wasn't anything like my previous visit. New chef?Please. By the way they replaced the hushpuppies but not the crab patty. I have pictures.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 3

Can not say enough great things about this place! The best meal I’ve had in a long time!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Food was ok but service suck. I waited to get seated, waited to order, the waitress never came back to my table until the food ready. Lastly, the appetizer came out the same time as my meal.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 1

Shawn , greatest bartender of all time !! Wonderful customer service !! Oysters are A1 my new fav spot 🤍

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5