Tally Fish House & Oyster Bar

6802 Thomasville Rd, Tallahassee
(850) 900-5075

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Southern Style Oyster Rockefeller Dinner
House-Made Hushpuppies
Shrimp & Grits Dinner
Virginia Clam Strips
Grouper and Grits
Dozen Raw Oysters
Steamed Oysters
Shrimp and Grits
Stuffed Grouper
Grouper Bites

Menu

Appetizers
House-Made Hush Puppies
Sweet onion dough fried golden brown. Served with house-made jam.
Smoked Fish Dip
Smoked fresh catch. Served with house-made crostinis.
Grouper Bites
Gulf grouper, fried, or blackened, and served with our house-made tartar sauce.
Blue Crab Claws
Deviled Egg
Bang Bang Shrimp
Gulf shrimp tossed in our house-made buffalo sauce.
Gator Tail
Tender chunks of Florida gator tail, fries, or blackened.
Coconut Crusted Shrimp
Crispy hand battered shrimp rolled in fresh coconut.
Catfish Nuggets
Chef Jason's Brussels
Crispy Brussels sprouts, balsamic reduction, azar sausage, bacon, caramelized onions, and goat cheese crumbles.
Cajun Shrimp Deviled Eggs
Ahi Tuna
Seared tuna, seaweed salad, corn pico, avocado, and topped with cucumber wasabi.
Baked Scallops on Half Sheel
Treble Hook Trio
Crispy Calamiri
Fresh calamari and banana peppers cooked light and crispy. Served with a side of chilled marinara.
Fried Green Tomatoes
Crispy fried green tomatoes topped with corn pico, balsamic reduction, and goat cheese.
Fried Mushrooms
Mama Shaw's Conch Fritters
Legendary Bahamian Mamashaw's very own recipe.

Seafood Bar
Florida Oysters
Peel and Eat
One Pound of Gulf White Shrimp
Royal Red Shrimp
Gulf Oysters
Florida Royal Reds
One Pound of Florida Royal Red Shrimp

Topped Oysters
Fish House Style Charbroiled (6 pcs)
Gulf oysters topped with butter, garlic, redpeppers, parmesan, and romano.
Crispy Buffalo Oysters
Southern Style Oyster Rockefeller (6 pcs)
Gulf oysters topped with collards, bacon, and parmesan.
Jalapeno Bacon Cheddar (6 pcs)
Gulf oysters topped with bacon, cheddar, and jalapenos.

Soup and Salad
Chicken and Sausage Gumbo
Walnut & Beet Salad
Spring mix, candid walnuts, roasted beets, goat cheese, marinated tomatoes, topped with balsamic reduction, and drizzled with honey.
Captain Frank's Chowder
Blue Cheese Wedge
Halved romaine, pressed egg, smoked bacon, cherry tomatoes, blue cheese crumbles, balsamic reduction, and bleu cheese dressing.
Caesar Salad
Halved romaine, croutons, cherry tomatoes, and parmesan.
House Salad
Spring mix, marinated tomatoes, pickled onions, shredded cheese, and croutons.

Handhelds
Fresh Fish Sandwich
Po' Boy
Shrimp or oysters in a locally baked roll topped with spring mix, shredded cheese, marinated tomatoes, pickled onion, and house-made po'boy sauce. Served with one side.
Trigger Reuben
Russ Tacos
Choice of shrimp or mahi in two flor tortillas with spring mix, marinated tomatoes, corn pico, shredded cheese, pickled onions, and house-made taco sauce. Served with one side.
All American Angus Burger (2/3 lb)
Double-smashed patty, American cheese, spring mix, marinated tomatoes, pickled onion, pickles, and house-made burger sauce.

Signature Plates
Shrimp N Grits
Gluf shrimp, smoked bacon, Azar sausage, and onion over cheese grits.
Whole Fried Gulf Snapper
Fresh caught snapper, scored, breaded, and lightly fried.
Seafood Kitchen Combination
Fresh Gulf chrimp, Gulf select oysters, cold water scallops, fresh, and house-made stuffed deviled crab.
Shrimp Scampi
Blackned gulf shrimp, capellini pasta tossed in garlic, white wine, and butter sauce.
Margo's Crab Cakes
Creamy Maryland style with hints of tangy mustard, and zesty lemon, and topped with corn pico.
Whole Fried Flounder
Fresh caught Flounder, scored, breaded, and lightly fried.
Stuffed Gulf Grouper
Gulf grouper loaded with house-made crab meat stuffing and cheese.
Fresh Catch Gnocchi
Chicken Tenders Meal
White meat chicken strips and blackened or fried.
Low Country Boil
Gluf shrimp, Azar sausage, potatoes, corn, and onion.
Poke Bowl
Fresh ahi tuna, seasonal veggies, mildy hot poke sauce, and sticky rice.
Tuscan Pasta
Just Caught Grouper N Grits
Fresh blackened grouper served over bacon, Azar sausage, onions, and cheese grits.
Cluster Snow Crab

Fresh Just Caught Seafood Dinners
Gulf Shrimp Shrimp
Grouper
Honey Glazed Salmon
Catfish Fillets
Gulf Oyster Dinner
Fried Oysters
Gulf Red Snapper
Virginia Clam Strips (freshly Shucked)
Atlantic Trigger Fish
Soft Shell Crab
East Coast Flounder
Cold Water Scallops
Atlantic Mah-Mahi

Locally Made Desserts
Key Lime Pie
A local favorite made by Flour Blossom bakery.
Bread Pudding
Sawgrass Chocolate Cake
Four layers of double chocolate heaven.

Mains
Chicken Biscuits & Gravy
Fried chicken tenders, 2 biscuits, scrambled eggs, sausage gravy, and cheese grits.
The Captain's Breakfast
3 eggs, azar sausage or bacon, biscuit, sausage gravy, and cheese grits.
Tally Scramble
Crispy potatoes, bacon, azar sausage, corn pico, cheddar cheese, scrambled eggs, and bang bang sauce drizzle.
Boat Yard Waffle
Whipped cream, mixed berry jam, and maple syrup. Served with 2 scrambled eggs.
Shrimp N Grits
Gulf shrimp, smoked bacon, azar sausage, and onions over cheese grits.
Just Caught Grouper N Grits
Fresh blackened grouper served over bacon azar sausage, onions, and cheese grits.
Fried Green Tomato And Crab Cake Benedict
Halved biscuit topped with fried green tomatoes, eggs, maryland style crab cake, and hollandaise.
Breakfast Burrito
Sautéed shrimp, bacon, or sausage, red peppers, onion, cheddar cheese, scrambled eggs, topped with house-made taco sauce, and hollandaise.
Fish House Omelette
Baked omelette with sauteed shrimp, crab meat, red onion, tomato, and cream cheese.
French Toast
Dipped in vanilla custard, grilled to perfection, and topped with whipped cream. Served with 2 scrambled eggs.
Chicken and Waffles
Shrimp and Crab Omelette

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+42 photos
Photo credit: nextdoor
+41 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Food was good not great but good ordered oysters and they came out maybe 5 minutes before the food. Prices are stupid high for what you get. Could have gotten same food for half the price anywhere in town. They need to get real with the prices and the portion you get for that much money.
September 2025
Came down to Tallahassee move-in weekend and stopped in to Tallys for a drink. Sean the bartender was phenomenal and so fun! I stayed for the bang bang shrimp and a couple more drinks. 😉 Thank you for a great experience. I'll definitely be back when I'm back in town!
September 2025
We have been twice. The first experience was WAY better than the first. I’m giving three stars cause a restaurants inability to be consistent is an issue to me. I ordered a Caesar salad with blacked chicken and a side of cheese grits. My salad dressing was an Italian vinaigrette…. And the server forgot my grits. My dad’s fries came out cold. He asked for some to be brought out that were fresh. They came out cold again. These are simple things that could be easily avoided.
August 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Siam Bistro - 6808 Thomasville Rd Ste 109
Thai, Japanese, Asian, Gluten-Free, Vegetarian
Z Bardhi's Italian Cuisine - 3596 Kinhega Dr
Italian, Vegetarian
New Garden - 6753 Thomasville Rd #116
Chinese, Vegetarian

Tally Fish House & Oyster Bar

6802 Thomasville Rd, Tallahassee, FL 32312
(850) 900-5075