Tally Mac Shack

824 W Jefferson St, Tallahassee
(850) 570-6858

Recent Reviews

Иван Лепесий

Unbearably overpriced... I paid $10 for an Alfredo bowl, assuming it had chicken in it.. It does not, its and addon that costs $2. The person taking my order didn't even ask if I wanted it. It was good before, but after they changed the menu it's not worth the money.. Do not go

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 2

Christopher Bernhardt

It's kind of a shame, I spent $15 on my own Mac bowl and they put so much gorganzola in it that it just tasted like salty slop. I added garlic butter and there was so much it was like an added cm of butter above the actual food. Tasted terrible. I appreciate the large servings but think about what you're making.Also, there are no menus, you can't scan a menu, and while you order the display of the menu constantly changes so good luck remembering what you want. Everyone just sits there awkwardly while waiting for the menu to flash back as you get another 10 seconds to order.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 5

Gary

Couldn’t find the place. I went looking for like 20 minutes. No dice.

Joslyn Connor

0 stars…….This place does not exist. I drive around for 20 mins trying to figure out where it is and it’s closed.

Joslyn Whitfield

0 stars…….This place does not exist. I drive around for 20 mins trying to figure out where it is and it’s closed.

Amanda P.

This place has really good mac and cheese, creamy and delicious. The staff was so friendly, we enjoyed a drink a Drink at Happy Motoring while we were waiting. A little too hot to sit outside but they do have a cool outdoor area. Loved how they even wrote a little note on our bag with our Tampa Bay Lightning playing that night. Try this place!

Stacy Munford

The food was ok,It was a little warm,could have been hot

Kelly T.

Love, love, loved the outdoor atmosphere and vibe at Tally Mac Shack/Happy Motoring. A little disappointed they no longer had Bye Phylicia. Go for the Gouda Bacon Mac & Cheese and you will not be disappointed. Happy Motoring is the renovated service station and it has fun cocktails, wine slushies, and local beers. Very dog and kid friendly, next to a park, and very hip area.

Bubba Henry

It was a nice little Mac n cheese bowl. They need to season the water with salt when cooking the pasta. Otherwise, solid comfort food. We tried the Buffalo chicken and the BBQ one.

Erica Wiborg

We used Tally Mac’s food truck for our reception. They custom designed more gourmet style Mac and cheese for our special event, and had gluten free and vegan options. They were set up on time and left our guests very happy with the food. Guests didn’t stop raving about it!

BigDaddy M

Don't be fooled by the cute environment, the food was not worth it. I got the buffalo ranch sauce with mac. It was wayyyy too much sauce used to cover desert dry chicken. My partner got the mac with BBQ which wasn't too bad, if you like dessert Mac and cheese.... idk what they put in their BBQ sauce but it's as sweet as southern sweet tea.

David M.

The food here was okay. the price was high, and when it came out it wasn't very hot and fresh. perhaps we just had a bad experience but i'm not sure if come back again.

Ny'Tasha Gail Dionne Easley

Delicious food and drinks great ambiance .

PIP AND ZIP

Amazing sausage covered in mac and cheese and dice jalapenos. One of the best things I have ever eaten. This is my 3rd time here and it never disappoints. I love their creations. Also the buffalo chicken mac and cheese is a great dish as well. Large portions you do not leave hungry.

Leslie Surrency

Went tonight with a group of 8 people… I had the hold the cheese please and everyone else was able to taste it as well and we all loved it. I haven’t found many places that offer both vegan and gluten free and I just say, that Mac was off the chain! Please keep that one on the permanent menu!!

Load More