Anthony's New York Style Pizza
TEMPORARILY CLOSED$ •
12041 Anderson Rd, Tampa
(813) 962-8777
About Anthony's New York Style Pizza
Recent Reviews
ordered them through uber eats under the name Tampa pasta bar (same address) manicotti AND The baked ziti were still half frozen. the garlic bread is doughy and barely cooked..they used to be our favorite after Pizza Famiglia started having crappy food. but now with the lack of care/attention that goes into the food, I won't be eating here
Pizza was so good and they have zeppole’s. I haven’t had those since my NY days! 😋😋😋
PLEASE READ, HONEST REVIEW
We’ve ordered here a total of three times and the first time was pretty good. Then we decided to order again bc we liked it and it came out TERRIBLE!! It was practically raw. We called and tried to get some compensation and the person who we spoke to said “we can’t be giving out free pizzas.” Extremely rude. Then tonight we ordered again giving them another chance bc maybe it was a simple mess up, but that was the biggest mistake I’ve...read full review
Menu
People in Tampa Also Viewed
Anthony's New York Style Pizza offers delicious XL slices that taste just like back home. The fettuccini Alfredo is a must-try, and the pizza is huge and reasonably priced. The staff is known for being the friendliest, providing a warm welcome to everyone who walks in. Customer service is top-notch, with the owner showing great hospitality. Clean and welcoming, this place has a great vibe and is a 10/10 for anyone craving authentic New York style pizza in Tampa. Many customers have found the quality of the food to be consistently delicious, and leftovers are just as good the next day. Anthony's has truly become a beloved spot for those looking for great pizza, making it a favorite for locals and newcomers alike.