50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Thonotosassa

“I’ve been eating here for years and the food and service is always amazing. The manager has been at the same store for over 20 years and he always runs a tight ship with a great crew.. The salads are always fresh. The pizza is always good quality and it’s always quick and ready. They are conveniently located in a large shopping center with lots of parking and there’s always coupons and deals for pizza and sides. I would definitely recommend this location to everyone.“

“The Best Cuban Pizza in Tampa!“

“A Slice of Home at Willie's Bloomingdale Pizza As a lifelong lover of pizza and Italian food—raised in the suburbs of Philadelphia where great pizza is almost a birthright—I was genuinely surprised by how hard it was to find truly good pizza after moving to Florida. For a while, I had resigned myself to the usual national chains, which, while convenient, just don’t offer that authentic flavor or neighborhood warmth I grew up with. That all changed when I discovered Willie’s Bloomingdale Pizza on Oakfield. From the moment I walked in, I was met with a welcoming atmosphere. The service is both friendly and professional—they treat you like family without ever compromising on quality. You can immediately tell that this is a place run with heart. The owner is a standout—professional, down-to-earth, and clearly passionate about both the food and the people who walk through the door. It's rare to see that kind of genuine care, and it absolutely shows in every bite and every interaction. The pizza? Outstanding. Flavorful, fresh, and made with an attention to detail that rivals what I grew up with back in Philly. For someone who’s picky about their pizza & Italian food, that’s saying a lot. Good pizza is hard to come by in this part of the Sunshine State, so when you find a place like Willie’s, it’s truly cause for celebration. And what better way to celebrate than with a slice in hand? Willie’s Bloomingdale Pizza is hands-down the #1 spot for pizza & Italian food also cheesesteaks in the area. If you’re nearby and craving something real—something that feels like home—I can’t recommend this place enough.“

“Met the nicest gentleman, Brian, who made the best mushroom pixxa!! Very tasty, indeed.“

“Went there yesterday with my husband and daughters. That was by far the best pizza I've had!!!! The owner was soo nice & we promised we'd leave a review about the pizza & not the bathroom that's getting remodeled!!! Lol“

“Usually don't give places five star across the board, this place was pretty cool, food way easy to order and things came out really quickly, the pizzas were fired right there on the spot, nice thin crust New York style, you can add toppings and everything like that., and that you tip the people there.“

“I accidentally placed my order at a different Hungry Howie’s location, and the manager, Ray, was incredibly kind and helpful. He immediately contacted the other store, made sure I was reimbursed, and then prepared my pizza fresh and quickly. His customer service was outstanding, and he truly went out of his way to help me. The pizza tasted great, and the entire experience turned what could’ve been frustrating into a really positive one. Huge thanks to Ray for the excellent service!“

“Outstanding pies (pizza), salads, bread, garlic knots, and Bake Ziti. True Italian style!! Service was second to none. I would say, "The Best in Tampa Bay."“

“SO YUMMY“

“Great Service! Everyone is great! I always feel like family! I from NY and the Pizza is as close to home as I can find. Always keep coming back. I strongly recommend. Thanks Taste of NY.“

“This was hands down one of the best experiences I’ve had in a LONG time walking into a food establishment. The positive energy of the staff, the cleanliness of the store, the customer service in general. Whatever Nate and his team are doing, it’s working! And to be completely honest, I was only doordashing last night and while I wasn’t a Papa John’s supporter before, I am now. Nowadays, you walk into food establishments and you. An just feel the heavy and dark energy, but this place was different. And it was genuine. Thanks again to Nate and his team!“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️½
I recently visited NYNYPizzeria in Ybor City and it was a delightful experience from start to finish. The service was warm, attentive, and genuinely friendly—our server made us feel welcome and made great suggestions. The food itself was outstanding: perfectly crisp crust, rich and flavorful toppings, and cooked just right. The atmosphere was lively yet comfortable, with the right balance of casual fun and inviting energy. Whether you’re looking for a relaxed dinner or a fun night out, this place is a winner. Highly recommend it—I’ll definitely be returning.“

“Awesome place. The best garlic knots and stromboli in town...“

“Great flavors! Amazing pizza“

“My wife and I after enjoying the Christmas festivities over here in Wesley chapel as we were visiting from Lakeland, we saw this place looking for a bite to eat and it was approximately 8:52 p.m. when we walked in. we asked how late they were open and they said 9:30 but would we still like a table, that spoke volumes so we said yes we would like to try this great smelling Pizza that we could smell as we were walking in. as we got in everybody's smiling happy the owner is just as friendly as can be the decorative walls is what really caught my eye. I have a friend from the island in Italy so it was very warming to know the detail of all the places about Italy. We got the Hawaiian pizza and we knew that this was definitely different than what we've had in the past, the ingredients were spot on the way it was made was incredible and we just sat there not being rushed to enjoy our meal everyone just going about doing what they do best and we just talking over the events of the evening and several times we just remarked about how good this pizza is. as we were close to leaving cuz we did not want to keep anyone late we were just wanting a quick bite to eat but something very good and we got it from this wonderful place the owner came up and asked what we thought and I remarked to him" questo è eccellente" this is excellent in Italian very kind-hearted man, sweet disposition and you see the love of what he is committed to, but I could honestly say when I seen how the workers just cheerful and in a very relaxed environment there's magic in this place, looking forward to going back on purpose to visit this particular place over in Wesley chapel!“

“Great pizza with fun waitstaff.“

“Best pizza I've had in awhile. Pinellas has 1 that is authentic; this place was fantastic. Staff were so nice. If going to concert eat here first!!“

“Great pizza! Fast service.“

“I love Anthony’s food especially the chopped salad and the Desserts 🧁“

“My daughter’s new fav! Loves the crust. The other food was great$ new go-to! Super nice and smells amazing! Thank you!“

“Great pizza. Waiter was awesome. Hostest staff was lacking (person calling names was so quite that a costumer missed their name called) and I waited in the wrong line (one for picking up pizza and one for eating in) and no one asked if I was picking up or dining in till I got to the front. Still give it 5 stars though. I would go again.“

“Great pizza restaurant with great food, The service is amazing and Bailey at the front desk had great customer service and quick. The atmosphere is like any old school pizza restaurant with wood table and checkers floor which gives that old school pizza restaurant vibe. I definitely will be going back when I get the urge to have pizza.“

“We just did a Google search and thought we'd try this place out. So glad we did!! Best pizza I've had in a long time, the crust was amazing, no skimping on the toppings. Very friendly! Give it a try you won't be disappointed! Great price as well💗“

“Cali is my favorite place in the area. The food is amazing and is served very fast. It is a restaurant where you never have to worry about the quality being “off”.

The staff is incredible! Jillian is amazing and makes you feel truly cared for. Jose is the man! Everyone is so welcoming and accommodating.

Link Run Crew Loves Cali!“

“Delicious food, flawless service! We used Johnny C’s for a corporate luncheon, and they absolutely knocked it out of the park! The trays of pasta were hot and fresh, the meatballs were a crowd favorite, and the garlic knots disappeared within minutes. Picked up was on time and the setup was effortless due to the trays being ready to go! Highly recommend for any event—you won’t be disappointed!“

“Lunch deal with great for $11. My first time at Blaze and I’ll surely be back. You can customize your pizza, or get half of a personal pizza to pair it with a different side. The crust is delish, thin and wood fired crunchy. I liked this place! They have vegan or gluten free options and very interchangeable menu. My friend got vegan and the Workers will change their gloves when working with your speciality pizza too.“

“We absolutely love Via Italia. We placed a large order for a family birthday last night, and the entire experience was flawless. From ordering to that first bite. Everything was superb. The pizzas were incredible, and the salads were packed with fresh greens and the perfect balance of flavor. Couldn’t have asked for better.“

“Wow! We had two food trucks (2 Rowdy Roosters and The Chief's Cantina) at our school's Prom. The kids absolutely loved it. They provided great options, the delicious food, and everyone we interacted with was kind and helpful. Kim was a pleasure to work with to coordinate the truck and menu options. We will definitely book them for a future event!“

“We have been going there for years and is always great food, great people, and always a family favorite.“

“Called about specials, I was greater with a smile and passion! They asked about the amount of people I was feeding and recommend different menu options. I was very pleased can't wait to devour this New York style pizza“

“Ok. I am not a reviewer. Pretty much ever. I’m barely even a commenter on social media. HOWEVER. Exceptions must be made. Tonight I ordered pizza from Westshore, not because I had no dinner plan, but mostly because by the time I got finished fighting all the harpies at Homegoods and Target to finish my Mother’s Day shopping, I no longer cared. Hence, when it took me OVER 30 MINUTES to complete my on-line order due to bugs in their website, I was pretty annoyed, and recalled why I haven’t ordered from them in over a year bc their online ordering is literally a dumpster fire of issues, and I only order pizza anyway when I’m over it and refuse to cook. Nevertheless, I persevered, completed my order, and emerged victorious with a few dollars saved using online coupons and a screen shot of my order confirmation that stated a pick up time of 7:25:16 pm. Pretty specific. So my husband arrived at 7:26 pm, only to receive lukewarm (albeit tasty) pizza, and to be greeted by a sign that read: 14 inch pizzas, BOGO. Obviously, upon learning this I immediately wanted to know why the three pizzas I bought were not subject to this deal, since it is not listed on their website (in fact a bogo coupon that is listed doesn’t work), and I ordered 2 14 inch pizzas and 1 18 inch pizza. Reluctantly, I called the store to ask about the promo, expecting to learn my husband had been mistaken. Nope. 14 inch pizzas, BOGO. Umm. But…. I began to stutter out my explanation of why this was unfair, blah blah blah… bad website blah blah blah… took me 30 minutes to order online blah blah blah… cold pizza blah blah—and do you know what? The manager (owner) didn’t even listen to my whole story. He COMPLETELY COMPED MY ENTIRE ORDER before I could even fully explain. I didn’t even want the whole order comped— I just wanted him to honor the bogo promo not listed online. He told me it was already done and Happy Mother’s Day, so at that point all I could really do was thank him and swallow my indignation along with a slice of tasty veggie pizza. I think he said his name is Mike. I think he said that he just purchased this franchise and is still trying to turn things around. He asked me to follow his store on social media, and said he understood why I gave up on them over a year ago, even though I do like their pizza and salads. Wings are good too actually. I was a bit surprised by this entire exchange to be honest, given the fact that I spent some of my day reporting the $400 that was stolen from my checking account by identity thieves, and the rest of my day weaving my way through over privileged ladies in tropical prints who consider shopping to be a competitive blood sport. I’m not jaded. I’m just tired. So, thank you very much Mike for comping my family’s dinner when you didn’t have to, and thank you for surprising someone who is almost never surprised with your excellent customer service. I have lived in New Tampa for a long time, and it still amazes me that I can patronize the same mom and pop small businesses for years (food, coffee, nails, car wash, dry cleaners— whatever) and the owners/ managers rarely acknowledge that they A) recognize you, and B) appreciate your business. You managed to accomplish both of these feats in a less than 2 minute phone call. I look forward to ordering your pizza more often, and I am actually impressed. I think your chances of success are strong if this is the way you treat your customers. I will be back, and will be recommending Westshore Pizza New Tampa to my friends.“

“Always have an excellent time. Going to Cappy’s. The pizzas excellent and it’s a great atmosphere. Staff is always on point.“

“Everything we had was delicious! Highly recommend!“

“Best pizza in town!!! Always fresh!“

“I highly recommend Papa John's at the County Line Road location in Lutz..I was really surprised by the store manager Tyler, who went beyond what i was expecting when an order of ours was messed up..He took care of the problem quickly and i was very impressed with his professionalism and customer service! I'll continue to be a loyal Papa John's customer.“

“The absolute best pizza In tampa and in the whole state of Florida. . If you’re looking for a NY style pizza with extra garlic pizzazz this is defiantly your place. Hailey the bartender is super amazing. Carla the manager is on point and one of the best managers around. You need to go to bubbas if you want good anything in the tampa Bay Area.“

“Food and staff are Awesome. Excellent daily specials.“

“Decent food. Vegetables are as close to natural as you can get.“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Outstanding Local Gem on Fletcher Avenue
If you’re looking for authentic, family-owned Italian food near the university, Pizzeria Famiglia is a must-visit.
The pizza is absolutely outstanding—true New York–style with great cheese, a perfectly crisp crust, and incredible flavor in every bite. We also ordered the spaghetti and meatballs and a chicken cheesesteak, and both were just as impressive—fresh, hearty, and clearly made with care.
Just when we thought the meal couldn’t get any better, Sal—the owner—surprised us with dessert, and wow. The red velvet cake was one of the best I’ve had in a long time: moist, rich, and literally melted in your mouth. The cheesecake was equally excellent—perfectly chilled, smooth, and delicious.
Huge kudos to Sal and his family for creating such a wonderful neighborhood restaurant. Amazing food, friendly atmosphere, and that true family touch that keeps you coming back. Highly recommended! 🍕🍰“

“👍 pizza and service. friendly staff“

“Loved it. The eclectic menu makes it hard to know what to order, because it all sounds so good. The prices are very reasonable. It’s located in an industrial park, so call in your order ahead of time, and head over there. Very friendly service, and clean establishment. My husband had the chicken stir fry, and I had the Caribbean chicken curry. No complaints“

“Love getting Jets pizza. Delivery driver tonight accidentally gave us the wrong pizza. When I called to share my frustration the staff was absolutely amazing! They were so kind and immediately fired up our order again and was at our door within 20 minutes. Great location!“

“Been there a few times & love their pizza! They offer a variety of different pizzas (they have wings & garlics knots etc.)but pizza is their specialty- they’re always friendly and they get your order in quickly. Definitely a hidden gem!“

“Great service , love the crust, good pizza!“

“After hearing about how good the pizzas are, we brought a pizza home and had a mango shake there! The shake was absolutely delicious! And when we got home we ate our pizza and it was delicious! I am so glad that we stopped there today 10/08/2025!“

“Fantastic food! My grouper was perfect. I haven’t enjoyed a restaurant meal so much in a long time. I’ll be back!“

“Hungry Howie's is one of those places where you're always going to get the same service, same quality, and weekly deals for family meals. Good food on a very decent budget. We can go there and get salads, pizza, cheesy bread, desserts, and sodas just to vary a little bit. It is solid quality and family friendly to our budget. Our favorite is butter garlic crust pizza with extra cheese. You can never go wrong“

“Just ordered pizza for my daughters school. The person on the phone was amazing. Took my order at 10:45 and delivered it by 11:15 even though they don’t technically open until 11! Wonderful!“

“Y'ALL HAVE THE BEST PIZZA AROUND.. me and my fiance keep coming back and I would definitely give you guys 5 stars.“

“Hands down the best cheesesteak I’ve ever had! Alex, the owner makes you feel right at home! If you’re in Ybor City this is a must-stop!“