Cariera's Fresh Italian

Name: Cariera's Fresh Italian
Address: 1041 S Dillard St, Winter Garden, Florida, 34787, US
Telephone: (407) 554-3622
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.4

$$ • Italian, Vegetarian

Hours:
1041 S Dillard St, Winter Garden
(407) 554-3622

Menu Order Online Reserve

About Cariera's Fresh Italian

Cariera's Fresh Italian is a warm and welcoming family-owned restaurant serving authentic Italian dishes. The friendly staff provides excellent service, making sure to check on customers regularly. The menu offers a large variety of delicious meals like blackened mahi mahi over lemon pasta, shrimp with sun-dried tomatoes in creamy Alfredo sauce, and Tuscan Grilled Chicken with garlic Alfredo. The portions are generous, and the desserts, like the Limoncello Cake, are a must-try. The cozy atmosphere, complete with live streams of Italy, adds to the dining experience. Customers say the food is consistently good, full of hearty, flavor-packed meals that make you want to relax and enjoy. Favorites include crispy Chicken Parm, bubbling Baked Ziti, and dangerous garlic rolls that are hard to resist. The cannolis are described as a crispy, creamy dream, one of the best in town. The restaurant also offers the best Alfredo that many have ever tasted and features dishes like carbonara and sausage ala vodka that are noted for their perfection. The thin crust pepperoni pizza is considered insanely delicious. Even when doing pickup, the place is lively and friendly, with quick service and a clean, inviting space. The restaurant offers huge portions for the price, easily feeding two people or providing leftovers. It is a hidden gem in Winter Garden—casual, cozy, and reliably delicious. Whether craving pasta, pizza, or dessert, guests feel like part of the family from the first bite and frequently return, making it a favorite stop on trips. This family-friendly Italian restaurant is known for fantastic quality and generously homemade-tasting dishes that bring people back time and again.