the best cakes in town! always go to them for special occasions
Katya Fernandez
Our wedding cake was delicious - our guests were raving about how richly tasty all the different layers were. In terms of planning, the staff at Cecilia's was really easy to work with and super helpful. I had some inspiration photos and a rough idea, but it wasn't until Cecilia's drafted an image of what they thought could work that I knew they were the best choice for us. They didn't disappoint - the cake was both beautiful and delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Caleb Downing Murray
Great cake makers, funny and sweet designs ( and tasty ).
M Elizabeth
Got our wedding cake from this owner in 2007. Keep coming back years and years later for other occasions or random cupcakes they may sell. There is nothing like their dense cakes. It’s very distinctive and I could pick any cake of theirs out of a line up during a taste test. It’s just that special. Should have taken a pic of my cupcakes from this weekend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Emma Brady
We ordered a three-tier cake and 10 white chocolate cheesecakes for our 175-guest wedding—and it was hands down the best cake I’ve ever tasted. Our cake featured red velvet, Italian crème, and red raspberry layers, and every single one was absolutely delicious. Our guests raved about the variety and flavor.
The team at Cecilia’s was phenomenal throughout the process. They helped us determine the right quantity, made design adjustments with ease just weeks before the wedding, and delivered everything on time and in perfect condition. Having them deliver and set up the cake was a huge peace of mind—especially considering we originally debated picking it up ourselves before switching to a larger cake.
We’re so glad we chose Cecilia’s and look forward to using them for future birthdays, anniversaries, and all of life’s sweet celebrations!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, White Chocolate Cheesecake
Leslie Granberry
Cecilia’s Cake Shop is the best! Our daughter’s wedding cake was beautiful & delicious! I’ve ordered many cakes from them over the years and they are amazing!
Shelby Musich
Cecilia’s made our wedding cake and it was amazing!! One of the best cakes I’ve ever eaten. We did the red raspberry flavor and it was delicious. Heather was easy to work with and replicated our vision exactly how i pictured it. I would definitely recommend them for wedding cakes!
Julia Patterson
We had Cecelia’s do our wedding cake and it was absolutely stunning! We chose the Spanish Lemon for all 3 tiers and we had so many compliments on it. The cake was perfectly moist and was not overwhelming sweet. Heather was wonderful to work with and did a beautiful job on the buttercream flowers. If I could I would give this lovely family business in Athens 10 stars!
Flori Weddings
Heather outdid herself with the cake for the Jordan & Colin's wedding! Not only was it stunningly elegant, but the flavor was out of this world. Guests couldn’t stop raving about it! Every tier was perfectly executed, and Heather was a joy to collaborate with from start to finish. Highly recommend for any couple looking for a show-stopping (and mouth-watering) wedding cake!
Kristi Taormina
I ordered a custom graduation cake from Cecilia’s Cake Shop, and it was perfect! Easy online ordering, beautiful design, and absolutely delicious. The staff was responsive and everything was ready on time. Highly recommend!
I’ve had many cakes from Cecelia’s and they are always 10/10! Every flavor I’ve had is delicious and their cakes are never dry. My boyfriend ordered the most perfect cake for my birthday this year and it was more perfect than I could have ever imagined!!!
Megan Stewart
I got a caramel birthday cake. The cake was dense almost like a pound cake, which held up to the rich caramel flavor icing.
Alanna Dieball
My wedding cake was absolutely perfect! It completely captured the vibe of my wedding. I received a lot of compliments on how beautiful and delicious it was. Cecilia's was so helpful and communicative throughout the process from start to finish. I couldn't have been happier with my cake and it was truly the icing on top of a perfect day!
Matthew Cohen
Awesome little family owned shop. Stopped in and found a perfect cheesecake they helped make fresh on the spot. Feel some of the reviews are people not being human as they were super amazing! Cake is delicious and service was impeccable. Will totally be back!!!
Maria Ortiz
This place can't play with people's time.
I ordered a cake for December 14 and it was paid.
I said I would pick it up at 10:00 a.m. and when I arrived at their establishment they didn't have my cake and I didn't have it on their list.
Unfortunately that day I had to arrive at my job at 11:00 and while they attended to their customers I was waiting for them to find my order because of their negligence I arrived late to my work.
If you make an order at the moment, they ask you for payment.
But they are very irresponsible.
I hope it doesn't happen to more people since it's frustrating to tell you that they can't find your order.
the best cakes in town! always go to them for special occasions
Our wedding cake was delicious - our guests were raving about how richly tasty all the different layers were. In terms of planning, the staff at Cecilia's was really easy to work with and super helpful. I had some inspiration photos and a rough idea, but it wasn't until Cecilia's drafted an image of what they thought could work that I knew they were the best choice for us. They didn't disappoint - the cake was both beautiful and delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great cake makers, funny and sweet designs ( and tasty ).
Got our wedding cake from this owner in 2007. Keep coming back years and years later for other occasions or random cupcakes they may sell. There is nothing like their dense cakes. It’s very distinctive and I could pick any cake of theirs out of a line up during a taste test. It’s just that special. Should have taken a pic of my cupcakes from this weekend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We ordered a three-tier cake and 10 white chocolate cheesecakes for our 175-guest wedding—and it was hands down the best cake I’ve ever tasted. Our cake featured red velvet, Italian crème, and red raspberry layers, and every single one was absolutely delicious. Our guests raved about the variety and flavor.
The team at Cecilia’s was phenomenal throughout the process. They helped us determine the right quantity, made design adjustments with ease just weeks before the wedding, and delivered everything on time and in perfect condition. Having them deliver and set up the cake was a huge peace of mind—especially considering we originally debated picking it up ourselves before switching to a larger cake.
We’re so glad we chose Cecilia’s and look forward to using them for future birthdays, anniversaries, and all of life’s sweet celebrations!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, White Chocolate Cheesecake
Cecilia’s Cake Shop is the best! Our daughter’s wedding cake was beautiful & delicious! I’ve ordered many cakes from them over the years and they are amazing!
Cecilia’s made our wedding cake and it was amazing!! One of the best cakes I’ve ever eaten. We did the red raspberry flavor and it was delicious. Heather was easy to work with and replicated our vision exactly how i pictured it. I would definitely recommend them for wedding cakes!
We had Cecelia’s do our wedding cake and it was absolutely stunning! We chose the Spanish Lemon for all 3 tiers and we had so many compliments on it. The cake was perfectly moist and was not overwhelming sweet. Heather was wonderful to work with and did a beautiful job on the buttercream flowers. If I could I would give this lovely family business in Athens 10 stars!
Heather outdid herself with the cake for the Jordan & Colin's wedding! Not only was it stunningly elegant, but the flavor was out of this world. Guests couldn’t stop raving about it! Every tier was perfectly executed, and Heather was a joy to collaborate with from start to finish. Highly recommend for any couple looking for a show-stopping (and mouth-watering) wedding cake!
I ordered a custom graduation cake from Cecilia’s Cake Shop, and it was perfect! Easy online ordering, beautiful design, and absolutely delicious. The staff was responsive and everything was ready on time. Highly recommend!
Restaurantji Recommends
I’ve had many cakes from Cecelia’s and they are always 10/10! Every flavor I’ve had is delicious and their cakes are never dry. My boyfriend ordered the most perfect cake for my birthday this year and it was more perfect than I could have ever imagined!!!
I got a caramel birthday cake. The cake was dense almost like a pound cake, which held up to the rich caramel flavor icing.
My wedding cake was absolutely perfect! It completely captured the vibe of my wedding. I received a lot of compliments on how beautiful and delicious it was. Cecilia's was so helpful and communicative throughout the process from start to finish. I couldn't have been happier with my cake and it was truly the icing on top of a perfect day!
Awesome little family owned shop. Stopped in and found a perfect cheesecake they helped make fresh on the spot. Feel some of the reviews are people not being human as they were super amazing! Cake is delicious and service was impeccable. Will totally be back!!!
This place can't play with people's time.
I ordered a cake for December 14 and it was paid.
I said I would pick it up at 10:00 a.m. and when I arrived at their establishment they didn't have my cake and I didn't have it on their list.
Unfortunately that day I had to arrive at my job at 11:00 and while they attended to their customers I was waiting for them to find my order because of their negligence I arrived late to my work.
If you make an order at the moment, they ask you for payment.
But they are very irresponsible.
I hope it doesn't happen to more people since it's frustrating to tell you that they can't find your order.
Loading...