I made a reservation for 7:30, and the day of the reservation, it was changed to 8pm without any reason why. I was not able to get a hold of them after I messaged them on open table and called them. We showed up, and the bar was rented out until 8pm for a private party, but the party was still going on while we were there and seated. The service was slow and it so loud. It was hard to enjoy. It would have been nice if they would have given us a heads up or have the private party actually wrap up at 8pm, so we could enjoy our reservation.
Heather
First time and really enjoyed. Our reservation was a bit earlier than typical Friday night crowd, so the space was (wonderfully) quieter for conversation with great music playing at a reasonable volume.
T
The manager Samuel was very personable.The servers were polite and patient.The ambiance set the mood along with the music and the food.If there was another private event or dinner is being offered, I'd love to come.Especially if Samuel has any part of it.
Billie
The “Feast of Gratitude” dinner with Chef Razia Sabour was phenomenal!! The food left me speechless! Along with the ambiance and the Q10 Cremant du Rose the evening was magical and a true epicurean treat! I hope to attend more events like this at May Peel in the very near future! Cheers!
Kara
We did not have food but it's making my input info. We had a great time and the service was great as were the cocktails.
Louis
My wide and I came for the December Dinner Series and the service, food and wine were absolutely fantastic! We will be back for cocktails and dinner. Great experience.
Sheryl
My friends and I visited after dinner so only had the drinks. We had some rounds of Come My Way and it was delicious. The space is really nice and servers were attentive and friendly. Would love to come for live jazz but definitely nice spot with great drinks.
Julia Santucci
One of the coolest bars I’ve been to in a long time! I visit LA & NYC often, and this was a 10/10 spot! The croquettes were delicious, the staff was so nice and cool, the atmosphere was stylish, chic and I loved the decor. We felt like we stepped back in time. And the drinks wow, the Mrs. Lily, highly recommended!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jaslyn
The design is beautiful and perfectly captures the speakeasy vibes, however the music and food were a bit disappointing. I would like to try again in a few months.
Kevin Jelesnianski
Great Vibes, awesome staff. Good drinks. Definitely a place to check out.
I absolutely love May Peel! The ambiance, drinks, and music is FIRE!! One of my favorite cocktail bars. Highly recommend
Efrem
Lovely experience. My girl had a blast. Service was phenomenal including valet. You will spend a grip though.
Noah
Great ambiance and service. I was so happy the music was at a level that made conversation easy, but still loud enough to keep conversation private. The drinks were great. I'd recommend the Cloud Eleven a thousand time over.
Jordan Crider
When you go ask for Adi! The best experience 10/10 muah
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Josh Griggs
Great atmosphere! My fiancé and I had a lot of fun there after a concert in midtown.
I made a reservation for 7:30, and the day of the reservation, it was changed to 8pm without any reason why. I was not able to get a hold of them after I messaged them on open table and called them. We showed up, and the bar was rented out until 8pm for a private party, but the party was still going on while we were there and seated. The service was slow and it so loud. It was hard to enjoy. It would have been nice if they would have given us a heads up or have the private party actually wrap up at 8pm, so we could enjoy our reservation.
First time and really enjoyed. Our reservation was a bit earlier than typical Friday night crowd, so the space was (wonderfully) quieter for conversation with great music playing at a reasonable volume.
The manager Samuel was very personable.The servers were polite and patient.The ambiance set the mood along with the music and the food.If there was another private event or dinner is being offered, I'd love to come.Especially if Samuel has any part of it.
The “Feast of Gratitude” dinner with Chef Razia Sabour was phenomenal!! The food left me speechless! Along with the ambiance and the Q10 Cremant du Rose the evening was magical and a true epicurean treat! I hope to attend more events like this at May Peel in the very near future! Cheers!
We did not have food but it's making my input info. We had a great time and the service was great as were the cocktails.
My wide and I came for the December Dinner Series and the service, food and wine were absolutely fantastic! We will be back for cocktails and dinner. Great experience.
My friends and I visited after dinner so only had the drinks. We had some rounds of Come My Way and it was delicious. The space is really nice and servers were attentive and friendly. Would love to come for live jazz but definitely nice spot with great drinks.
One of the coolest bars I’ve been to in a long time! I visit LA & NYC often, and this was a 10/10 spot! The croquettes were delicious, the staff was so nice and cool, the atmosphere was stylish, chic and I loved the decor. We felt like we stepped back in time. And the drinks wow, the Mrs. Lily, highly recommended!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The design is beautiful and perfectly captures the speakeasy vibes, however the music and food were a bit disappointing. I would like to try again in a few months.
Great Vibes, awesome staff. Good drinks. Definitely a place to check out.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I absolutely love May Peel! The ambiance, drinks, and music is FIRE!! One of my favorite cocktail bars. Highly recommend
Lovely experience. My girl had a blast. Service was phenomenal including valet. You will spend a grip though.
Great ambiance and service. I was so happy the music was at a level that made conversation easy, but still loud enough to keep conversation private. The drinks were great. I'd recommend the Cloud Eleven a thousand time over.
When you go ask for Adi! The best experience 10/10 muah
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great atmosphere! My fiancé and I had a lot of fun there after a concert in midtown.
Loading...