New York Pizza
$ • Pizza, ItalianAbout New York Pizza
Customers' Favorites
New York Pizza Reviews
Share your opinion about New York Pizza
Haven’t ordered from here in a long time. Had a craving for an antipasto salad. Tonight I ordered the salad, along with a 6” meatball sandwich and a cannoli. (Haven’t had a cannoli in ages.) Let me first say how great the food was! They accidentally sent cheesecake instead of a cannoli but that was no problem. Cheesecake is fantastic! Sandwich was perfect as was the salad! Portions are very large and well worth the money! Delivery (thru the slice app) was faster than I ever...read full review
Best pizza place in Northeast Georgia.We ordered a calzone and garlic knots. Everyone was very friendly and the atmosphere was warm and cozy. Looking forward to going back again soon!
FANTASTIC pizza.
Hartwell is a small town, with a handful of options for pizza, but this restaurant would hold its own a big city. The food is authentic... family SOUNDS like they're from NY (?), and I promise, it doesn't taste like a 'chain' pizza place.
Sometimes there is a wait--sometimes there's not. But if there is, know it's only because like every other small town, we have too many chiefs and not enough indians and help is hard to find. But it's absolutely worth...read full review
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 4 - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 4 - 9PM |
| Thursday | 4 - 9PM |
| Friday | 4 - 9PM |
| Saturday | 4 - 9PM |
| Sunday | 4 - 9PM |
New York Pizza, located in Hartwell, is a well-known restaurant renowned for its amazing food and great service. The menu offers a variety of dishes, including garlic knots, stuffed pizza, antipasto salad, and calzones, all of which have been highly praised by customers. The restaurant's atmosphere is warm and cozy, creating a pleasant dining experience. New York Pizza is considered one of the best pizza places in Northeast Georgia, with former customers from Anderson expressing their happiness since its reopening, stating that the quality of the food has remained consistent.
Customers have recently praised the restaurant's Chicago-style deep dish, describing it as very authentic and great. The service has also been commended, with the staff being very friendly. It is a very friendly family owned business that cares about customer service and experience. Diners have enjoyed the restaurant's great atmosphere and the food, including the stuffed pies and pasta, all of which have been described as delicious and amazing. The cooks are praised for their ability to make great quality pizza.