Fatty's Pizza

587 Cherry St, Macon
(478) 744-9880

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Katy Kreger Miley

The pizza isn't bad but they don't put enough sauce on it especially when you special request it. However their calzones I got mozzarella and ricotta cheese and pepperoni I suggest getting the large it is well worth it and it tastes even better when you reheated when you bring it home it's leftovers. I was a little upset though that the first manager offered me free calzone becoz there was a hair in my calzone when I went to claim my free calzone I found out that there was a new manager and he refused to stand by Laura lb and her offer to give me a free calzone to replace the one that had the hair. They should really stick to what the previous manager say to the customers that is not good customer service. Unfortunately I do not have a photo of the calzone but it is well worth trying

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 2

Howard Hamilton

Good food

Skyla Shugart

My salad had a dead bug in it, and the service was awful.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Bill Kelly

Closed before 1am.

Mike Hunt

A little too greasy for me but still always good $5 lunch specials are the best

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Keshaun

Ordered a medium pizza, lemon pepper wings & garlic kinks for $33. food came out & the wings were small & the pizza was even smaller then was told they don’t even have medium pizzas so they gave us a personal size. why didn’t they tell us that before we paid. other than that the pizza was decent but the wings were super salty. overpriced, could be better for what we paid

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 1

Emily Newberry

We asked for a medium (not knowing they didn’t do mediums) the cashier didn’t correct us or tell us that they did personal pizzas only. Expecting a medium we got a personal pan. I asked about it and the lady said they didn’t do mediums. Luckily we order wings and garlic knots so we weren’t hungry after. But definitely not over 30$ worth of food.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 1

floyd thomas

If the food is as good as the people then
..
Just wow

melvin cox

Great place, better service ? , awesome vibes and yes I will return!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Wacko Taco

They are not open until 2 am on Saturdays. Correct your hours. It's that simple.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Rosa Day

Great staff nice vibe great music
Really clean pizza is the best I’ve after I promise
Yall come down town and see for yourselfs

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Special

Bre Mer

Ordered the $5.00 special.
This consisted of 2 large slices of pizza and a 16oz drink.
It was a delicious pizza!
They have many combinations of toppings to choose from...
The service was wonderful and very friendly and patient with me trying to choose my toppings.The atmosphere was casual and cozy.
They do not bake the crust prior to your order, it is freshly made and assembled after you place your order...the pizza is amazing!!
We will fit Fatty's in our future trips through Macon.
They are situated in the hustle and bustle of town...meter parking , scan code, and follow instructions. May have to park outskirts and walk. Realizing that everyone has personal opinions about food, MY taste buds will give Fatty's will a 5 star from me!

Dietary restrictions: Yes

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

WhatIsUnsweetTea?

Highly disappointed. Knots were 8 dollars for the picture below. They were also overcooked and hard after a 7 minute drive. The pizza white pizza lacked flavor and appeared to have no ricotta, in which I payed for. And was also not warm when I had arrived to my destination. Not pleased after determining to come here, judging by reviews.
Also the text said it would be done at certain time. I arrived 2 minutes after said time and it was waiting for me. (With no notification it was completed) idk how long it was done prior to my arrival

Penny Baker

Personal pizza hit the spot ! Very good will return again and again

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lashekia Hill

The young lady who placed my order on the phone was very nice and polite, as well in person, I waited nearly a hour for the pizza not being hot, I was probably forgotten about but I would’ve waited longer for it to be reheated.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 3

Loading...