Dropped into have lunch on a leisurely visit to Madison. We were very impressed with the taste and quality of the pizza here. I've seen the shirts around so I was curious and the food definitely is worth a visit
Claire Bronstein
Slow service to start then it got better.
jimk351
Service was adequate, food and ambiance was good. Drink special ran out immediately and they refused to substitute for same price; bait and switch in my opinion. They left the special drink sign up long after special was sold out. Not sure I would go back though wings were very good.
Steven A
The food is good for the price. Service is very attentive... well trained! Service is quick for a place so large, which is good since the seating is not meant to invite a long stay.
John F
Very Disappointed with the extra charges they applied to our bill. At least tell the customer first before charging extra for dressing. I wasn't going to post this because I sent the manager an email in hopes he would handle this, but after 2 emails, I had no reply, so I am posting this so ever one that comes here will know in advance. This is the exact email that I sent the manager (twice) ---------------------------- We come to Madison often and always enjoy coming to your place, but we were there yesterday and we were very upset about our bill. Our son lives in Athens GA and we met him at your place for lunch. I didn't notice it at first but later we looked at the bill and we were charged an extra $1.00 each for our salad dressings. At least when asking for extra dressings your staff should say something like, just to let you know, it's $1.00 more for extra dressing. Then the customer can decide or not if they want to pay this. I've seen this upcharge in the past at other places, but never $1.00 and we're always told about the charge beforehand. Not really happy with AMICI right now... ----------------------------------- I hope everyone agrees that any additional charges on the bill should be stated beforehand. Lots of great places in Madison GA to choose from, so not sure why I didn't get a response.
Glenn Rudolph
Great atmosphere, philly cheese steak was excellent, service was very good and the prices were very reasonable.
Sandy R.
Pleasantly surprised at the great taste of my slice of the "Athenian" pizza! Flavorful and generous portion ($6.50). I also had an order of 6 lemon-pepper wings ($10.50). They were ok, IMO, nothing special. Served with celery slices and choice of ranch or blue cheese dressing. Service was poor. Had to go up to the bar to get another drink as the waitress didn't come back to check on us after the food was delivered. Very busy establishment on a Saturday night. Overall, good experience.
Mike T.
Food was very good with a very good selection. Server was very friendly and helpful - experience was better than good. 5 stars.Recommend to all.It's in an old livery stable built in 1895. Great atmosphere. And they brew beer.
Wendy T.
I have eaten at several different Amici's and this one did not disappoint. The food and wait staff were great. I would recommend.
Garrett A.
Amazing wings! I am obsessed with the XXHot wings and pizza slice combo! I always opt for the Pineapple Express and it never disappoints! My friends and I love to sit on the patio and play cornhole whenever we're there!
Bomb ass food! Pizza deliciousness and you have to try honey hot wings!A must have if you are near a local store.
Morgan S.
I love everything about this place! The wings are great, the pizza and calzones are delicious, and the dough balls are addictive! On my most recent visit we had Trinity as our server and she was awesome! She had a great attitude and plenty of knowledge on the menu. She recommended the Dough Balls with the sauce on the side as a dessert and they were scrumptious! If you get the wings get them drizzled with honey, it amps up the flavor! We happened to be there during trivia and everyone seemed to be enjoying themselves. It wasn't too loud and everything was clean.
Mike B.
We are new to the Madison area, thought this restaurant looked inviting, so we went for dinner. The staff is friendly, but it was all downhill from there. Waited forever for our food, the food took forever to get and was cold. We ordered wings and pizza which was served on a pizza pan and wings in a basket, the pizza was okay at best and the wings were horrible. We weren't giving any, plates to eat from, we asked our server for small plates to eat our wings and pizza from and never received them, although, she had time to take selfies with other employees. VERY unprofessional!. A group of employees were hovered around the bar being very loud, again unprofessional! Needless to say we will not be going back. If you are looking for a nice place to enjoy pizza, wings and enjoy an evening out, this is definitely not the place.
Candace B.
I ate lunch here with a few coworkers today and the experience was alright. We had a long wait, that was the worst part. Our 1 hr lunch turned into a 1.5 hr lunch. I ordered the Parmesan sub and it was pretty good but drowning in marinara sauce. Overall the restaurant is decent but not the place to go if you need to get in and out.
Bob K.
First, the people that work at Amici are Awesome! All very friendly and helpful. The atmosphere was terrific.However, the (Philly) Cheese Steak was beyond terrible. The cook did not have a good handle on how to cook a traditional cheese cake in my opinion. If you think that a cheese steak should have tons of minced garlic in it, then you will love this cheese steak. If you love water from thick cuts of onion....soaking up your roll, you will love this cheese steak. I am not sure about this next statement....probably just me....but I tasted soy sauce (again, it may just be me), and it tasted awful. Obviously, I do not recommend the cheese steak.
Dropped into have lunch on a leisurely visit to Madison. We were very impressed with the taste and quality of the pizza here. I've seen the shirts around so I was curious and the food definitely is worth a visit
Slow service to start then it got better.
Service was adequate, food and ambiance was good. Drink special ran out immediately and they refused to substitute for same price; bait and switch in my opinion. They left the special drink sign up long after special was sold out. Not sure I would go back though wings were very good.
The food is good for the price. Service is very attentive... well trained! Service is quick for a place so large, which is good since the seating is not meant to invite a long stay.
Very Disappointed with the extra charges they applied to our bill. At least tell the customer first before charging extra for dressing. I wasn't going to post this because I sent the manager an email in hopes he would handle this, but after 2 emails, I had no reply, so I am posting this so ever one that comes here will know in advance. This is the exact email that I sent the manager (twice) ---------------------------- We come to Madison often and always enjoy coming to your place, but we were there yesterday and we were very upset about our bill. Our son lives in Athens GA and we met him at your place for lunch. I didn't notice it at first but later we looked at the bill and we were charged an extra $1.00 each for our salad dressings. At least when asking for extra dressings your staff should say something like, just to let you know, it's $1.00 more for extra dressing. Then the customer can decide or not if they want to pay this. I've seen this upcharge in the past at other places, but never $1.00 and we're always told about the charge beforehand. Not really happy with AMICI right now... ----------------------------------- I hope everyone agrees that any additional charges on the bill should be stated beforehand. Lots of great places in Madison GA to choose from, so not sure why I didn't get a response.
Great atmosphere, philly cheese steak was excellent, service was very good and the prices were very reasonable.
Pleasantly surprised at the great taste of my slice of the "Athenian" pizza! Flavorful and generous portion ($6.50). I also had an order of 6 lemon-pepper wings ($10.50). They were ok, IMO, nothing special. Served with celery slices and choice of ranch or blue cheese dressing. Service was poor. Had to go up to the bar to get another drink as the waitress didn't come back to check on us after the food was delivered. Very busy establishment on a Saturday night. Overall, good experience.
Food was very good with a very good selection. Server was very friendly and helpful - experience was better than good. 5 stars.Recommend to all.It's in an old livery stable built in 1895. Great atmosphere. And they brew beer.
I have eaten at several different Amici's and this one did not disappoint. The food and wait staff were great. I would recommend.
Amazing wings! I am obsessed with the XXHot wings and pizza slice combo! I always opt for the Pineapple Express and it never disappoints! My friends and I love to sit on the patio and play cornhole whenever we're there!
Restaurantji Recommends
Bomb ass food! Pizza deliciousness and you have to try honey hot wings!A must have if you are near a local store.
I love everything about this place! The wings are great, the pizza and calzones are delicious, and the dough balls are addictive! On my most recent visit we had Trinity as our server and she was awesome! She had a great attitude and plenty of knowledge on the menu. She recommended the Dough Balls with the sauce on the side as a dessert and they were scrumptious! If you get the wings get them drizzled with honey, it amps up the flavor! We happened to be there during trivia and everyone seemed to be enjoying themselves. It wasn't too loud and everything was clean.
We are new to the Madison area, thought this restaurant looked inviting, so we went for dinner. The staff is friendly, but it was all downhill from there. Waited forever for our food, the food took forever to get and was cold. We ordered wings and pizza which was served on a pizza pan and wings in a basket, the pizza was okay at best and the wings were horrible. We weren't giving any, plates to eat from, we asked our server for small plates to eat our wings and pizza from and never received them, although, she had time to take selfies with other employees. VERY unprofessional!. A group of employees were hovered around the bar being very loud, again unprofessional! Needless to say we will not be going back. If you are looking for a nice place to enjoy pizza, wings and enjoy an evening out, this is definitely not the place.
I ate lunch here with a few coworkers today and the experience was alright. We had a long wait, that was the worst part. Our 1 hr lunch turned into a 1.5 hr lunch. I ordered the Parmesan sub and it was pretty good but drowning in marinara sauce. Overall the restaurant is decent but not the place to go if you need to get in and out.
First, the people that work at Amici are Awesome! All very friendly and helpful. The atmosphere was terrific.However, the (Philly) Cheese Steak was beyond terrible. The cook did not have a good handle on how to cook a traditional cheese cake in my opinion. If you think that a cheese steak should have tons of minced garlic in it, then you will love this cheese steak. If you love water from thick cuts of onion....soaking up your roll, you will love this cheese steak. I am not sure about this next statement....probably just me....but I tasted soy sauce (again, it may just be me), and it tasted awful. Obviously, I do not recommend the cheese steak.