11 Best Pizza Restaurants in Kihei

“The pizza is absolutely fantastic! We've eaten at other locations of theirs on other islands and have never been disappointed. We were happy to see a location close to our Airbnb. They have a super cute patio you can sit out on with tiki torches to add to the “Hawaiian feel”. The only downfall is they don’t currently have their liquor license so you can’t order alcohol of any kind (including beer) but, the BYOB feature is a great option and a way to save money as well!“

“Great food Great drink Sara is a true gem We found our Maui bar !!!“

“Pizza Madness is the best pizza on Maui! Excellent crust, fresh toppings and delicious sauces, both the red and white Alfredo, a good choice with garlic chicken. They also serve up some fine buffalo wings and have a buy ten get one large free pizza deal along with other items for points. We mostly do takeout and the food is always hot and ready to go promptly. We highly recommend Pizza Madness, been going there for years and love it every time. Phil, Cris and Kyle, Kihei Maui.“

“Upon arriving to the Fairmont Kea Lani after a long 9 hour flight, we were able to get a quick pizza that we brought up to our room to eat. Stopped in to get ice cream one night. I got the banana bread sundae and my fiancé got the chocolate Oreo shake. Both delicious. The store also had coffee, teas, and typical gift shop items. Everything of course is super expensive but what else would you expect. Overall recommend.“

“This was INCREDIBLE pizza. I consider myself to be a pizza fanatic and have had many a good pie, but this by far takes the cake. Awesome service as well and can’t beat the location and island vibes.“

“Excellent breakfast sandwich & pizza. highly recommend.“

“On Monday night I went and was helped by Lu and one of her coworkers. I had just arrived from a flight, and since everything else was already closed, I got there late. They were already closed too, and still they decided to make me a pizza and put so much love, lots of cheese, and such good vibes into it. I really want to highlight their attitude, the service, and the help they gave me. The pizza was excellent. Thank you so much, Lu!“

“nice staff. great pizza. masks worn and they were checking their temperatures.“

“Delicious food, excellent service, and the best beer around.“

“i love this place. the food is super good and it’s really affordable for what you get. they don’t gouge you like maui brew co or other restaurants nearby. everyone was really friendly and the outdoor patio/lanai is so nice. the desserts are great and not super pricey. i appreciate this place and the staff“

“Service is fast and friendly despite all us annoying tourists.
The food is what can take a long time coming out, which is pretty obvious when one sees a line out the door.
If one doesn’t want to wait for food, just grab one of the ready made sandwiches and/or salads.

As someone who doesn’t live in the USA anymore, it was great to see Erewhon products sold in Maui.“