We had an amazing experience with Cake Fanatics for our wedding last month! We were truly blown away by the flavors of our cake and the lilikoi bars (an absolute must!). We went with banana cake with one tier having guava filling and one having fresh strawberry cream filling- everything was so fresh and not overly sweet. I feel like not many people talk about how good a cake was at a wedding, but our guests seriously keep talking about it. It was so good, we took some home to freeze to eat on our anniversary next year!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Karen Taylor
I ordered a cake for a friends 50th Birthday and EmmaLee did an amazing job! The cake was Exactly what I wanted and it was moist and delicious. The birthday girl was surprised and everyone loved the cake. EmmaLee was easy to communicate with, was very responsive and delivered the cake to our hotel.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Grace Hengesbach
Emma Lee was so easy to work with and the cake was beautifully executed! (It was delicious, too!) I ordered a custom birthday cake a week in advance and she delivered it on a Sunday to help me keep it a surprise. She also made and delivered four allergy friendly cupcakes as an add-on.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kyla Moore (KYMOORE)
My sis was running in the Maui half marathon, and I couldn’t be there but wanted to do something special to celebrate the milestone. EmmaLee reached out to me immediately following me reaching out via her website, and helped me bring my surprise vision to life. Despite me being in Texas and the difference in time zones, she went above and beyond to make sure everything I needed and wanted was met. I couldn’t me more thankful to her for helping me celebrate and surprise me favorite person in the world! Thanks will never be enough ?.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Emily Henderson
Everything about this cake ordering to cake eating experience was stellar! Cake Fanatics took my very simple Blink-182 inspired idea for my husband’s 33rd birthday and brought it to life. Most importantly, having dietary restrictions can make ordering anything a pain but they were able to accommodate effortlessly by making the most delicious df/gf lilikoi cake I’ve ever had. I will definitely be a repeat customer and already looking forward to the next occasion where I can order a sweet treat! Thank you Cake Fanatics!!!
Dietary restrictions: dairy free/gluten free
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kyla Moore
My sis was running in the Maui half marathon, and I couldn’t be there but wanted to do something special to celebrate the milestone. EmmaLee reached out to me immediately following me reaching out via her website, and helped me bring my surprise vision to life. Despite me being in Texas and the difference in time zones, she went above and beyond to make sure everything I needed and wanted was met. I couldn’t me more thankful to her for helping me celebrate and surprise me favorite person in the world! Thanks will never be enough 😊.
Sarah F
Normally I don’t bother leaving reviews, but I can’t let it slide this time. I regret trusting Emmalee to create my wedding cake. They contributed to ruining my wedding day with an ugly cake in colors and flowers I did NOT ask for. Aqua blue is not green, and roses and Ranunculus flowers aren’t orchids, Lillies, or carnations which is what I received. I politely emailed them about their mistakes and how they upset us by not listening to what we asked for and instead of taking accountability, Emmalee tried to find loopholes to get out of giving me a full refund and gave me a petty attitude which was very emotionally immature of her. $75 refund is a slap in my face after we paid $350 for an ugly cake she didn’t make correctly. Please do not trust this person with your most precious day of your life, or you will likely regret it and end up having to have a vow renewal to make up for it. This persons character shows me they don’t actually care about making their clients happy, they’re greedy and all they cared about was keeping my money instead of being empathetic and taking responsibility for ruining my wedding cake. Get your cake somewhere else, I do not care how many positive reviews they have they screwed us over and that’s unacceptable.
Alicia Jenkins
I hired Cake Fanatics because their cakes were GORGEOUS and not being from Maui we didn't get to do a cake tasting so I just went off reviews. When my husband and I took our first bite it turned into us DEVOURING the entire slice of cake because it was THAT good. The best cake I've ever had. We ordered a larger cake and knew we would probably have extras because we had more cake than people and I am SO glad we had extras to take back to our hotel and enjoy for the rest of our trip.
The days after the wedding I had multiple friends and family ask if I had extra cake because they wanted more.
HIGHLY recommend!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Terry Gaylord
The cake was good, very tasty, but I’m taking off a star b/c we got married on 9.14.22! The devil is in the details. She wrote 9.22.21… come on 3/4 of this year of 2022 is over.
Cadence Feeley (Wedding Photographer)
I’m a professional photographer in Hawai’i and recommend Cake Fanatics to all my couples for their wedding day. We also hired Cake Fanatics for my son’s first birthday and had the most beautiful and delish cake made. mahalo!
The cake was good, very tasty, but I’m taking off a star b/c we got married on 9.14.22! The devil is in the details. She wrote 9.22.21… come on 3/4 of this year of 2022 is over.
Cadence Feeley
I’m a professional photographer in Hawai’i and recommend Cake Fanatics to all my couples for their wedding day. We also hired Cake Fanatics for my son’s first birthday and had the most beautiful and delish cake made. mahalo!
Carol McGrath
We were celebrating our 40th wedding anniversary and Cake Fanatics created a cake with decorations similar to our wedding cake. It was beautiful, very delicious, and they delivered it! Thank you so much!
Valerie Larsen
Cake Fanatics goes above and beyond! I had a very difficult request of a miniature figure of my boyfriend on top of his cake - he has very difficult hair to recreate - and they nailed it! The cake was amazing, and tasted SO GOOD! Great to work with, would 10/10 recommend :)
Ellen Irion
My wedding cake was everything I dreamed of thanks to Cake Fanatics! They put my vision into reality. Amazing to work with, prompt, communicative and so so skilled and creative! Couldn’t recommend them enough!
We had an amazing experience with Cake Fanatics for our wedding last month! We were truly blown away by the flavors of our cake and the lilikoi bars (an absolute must!). We went with banana cake with one tier having guava filling and one having fresh strawberry cream filling- everything was so fresh and not overly sweet. I feel like not many people talk about how good a cake was at a wedding, but our guests seriously keep talking about it. It was so good, we took some home to freeze to eat on our anniversary next year!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered a cake for a friends 50th Birthday and EmmaLee did an amazing job! The cake was Exactly what I wanted and it was moist and delicious. The birthday girl was surprised and everyone loved the cake.
EmmaLee was easy to communicate with, was very responsive and delivered the cake to our hotel.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Emma Lee was so easy to work with and the cake was beautifully executed! (It was delicious, too!) I ordered a custom birthday cake a week in advance and she delivered it on a Sunday to help me keep it a surprise. She also made and delivered four allergy friendly cupcakes as an add-on.
Food: 5
Service: 5
My sis was running in the Maui half marathon, and I couldn’t be there but wanted to do something special to celebrate the milestone. EmmaLee reached out to me immediately following me reaching out via her website, and helped me bring my surprise vision to life. Despite me being in Texas and the difference in time zones, she went above and beyond to make sure everything I needed and wanted was met. I couldn’t me more thankful to her for helping me celebrate and surprise me favorite person in the world! Thanks will never be enough ?.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Everything about this cake ordering to cake eating experience was stellar! Cake Fanatics took my very simple Blink-182 inspired idea for my husband’s 33rd birthday and brought it to life. Most importantly, having dietary restrictions can make ordering anything a pain but they were able to accommodate effortlessly by making the most delicious df/gf lilikoi cake I’ve ever had. I will definitely be a repeat customer and already looking forward to the next occasion where I can order a sweet treat! Thank you Cake Fanatics!!!
Dietary restrictions: dairy free/gluten free
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My sis was running in the Maui half marathon, and I couldn’t be there but wanted to do something special to celebrate the milestone. EmmaLee reached out to me immediately following me reaching out via her website, and helped me bring my surprise vision to life. Despite me being in Texas and the difference in time zones, she went above and beyond to make sure everything I needed and wanted was met. I couldn’t me more thankful to her for helping me celebrate and surprise me favorite person in the world! Thanks will never be enough 😊.
Normally I don’t bother leaving reviews, but I can’t let it slide this time. I regret trusting Emmalee to create my wedding cake. They contributed to ruining my wedding day with an ugly cake in colors and flowers I did NOT ask for. Aqua blue is not green, and roses and Ranunculus flowers aren’t orchids, Lillies, or carnations which is what I received. I politely emailed them about their mistakes and how they upset us by not listening to what we asked for and instead of taking accountability, Emmalee tried to find loopholes to get out of giving me a full refund and gave me a petty attitude which was very emotionally immature of her. $75 refund is a slap in my face after we paid $350 for an ugly cake she didn’t make correctly. Please do not trust this person with your most precious day of your life, or you will likely regret it and end up having to have a vow renewal to make up for it. This persons character shows me they don’t actually care about making their clients happy, they’re greedy and all they cared about was keeping my money instead of being empathetic and taking responsibility for ruining my wedding cake. Get your cake somewhere else, I do not care how many positive reviews they have they screwed us over and that’s unacceptable.
I hired Cake Fanatics because their cakes were GORGEOUS and not being from Maui we didn't get to do a cake tasting so I just went off reviews. When my husband and I took our first bite it turned into us DEVOURING the entire slice of cake because it was THAT good. The best cake I've ever had. We ordered a larger cake and knew we would probably have extras because we had more cake than people and I am SO glad we had extras to take back to our hotel and enjoy for the rest of our trip.
The days after the wedding I had multiple friends and family ask if I had extra cake because they wanted more.
HIGHLY recommend!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The cake was good, very tasty, but I’m taking off a star b/c we got married on 9.14.22! The devil is in the details. She wrote 9.22.21… come on 3/4 of this year of 2022 is over.
I’m a professional photographer in Hawai’i and recommend Cake Fanatics to all my couples for their wedding day. We also hired Cake Fanatics for my son’s first birthday and had the most beautiful and delish cake made. mahalo!
Restaurantji Recommends
The cake was good, very tasty, but I’m taking off a star b/c we got married on 9.14.22! The devil is in the details. She wrote 9.22.21… come on 3/4 of this year of 2022 is over.
I’m a professional photographer in Hawai’i and recommend Cake Fanatics to all my couples for their wedding day. We also hired Cake Fanatics for my son’s first birthday and had the most beautiful and delish cake made. mahalo!
We were celebrating our 40th wedding anniversary and Cake Fanatics created a cake with decorations similar to our wedding cake. It was beautiful, very delicious, and they delivered it! Thank you so much!
Cake Fanatics goes above and beyond! I had a very difficult request of a miniature figure of my boyfriend on top of his cake - he has very difficult hair to recreate - and they nailed it! The cake was amazing, and tasted SO GOOD! Great to work with, would 10/10 recommend :)
My wedding cake was everything I dreamed of thanks to Cake Fanatics! They put my vision into reality. Amazing to work with, prompt, communicative and so so skilled and creative! Couldn’t recommend them enough!
Loading...