I've tried only one thing from S&J Bakery. My workplace orders it annually come Thanksgiving time and most recently a co-worker picked one up for us to devour as an afternoon dessert.DESSERT:Pumpkin Custard PieFirst off, I'm a huge custard pie fan. Pumpkin, I'll eat but don't enjoy it as much as my eggy love. Mix the two together and you've got a damn tasty concoction. S&J's crust is the closest to my mom's homemade version, yet hers is still better ;). Flakey and moist with a surprising crunch to the exterior. The texture of the filling is my only quibble. The closest paradigm I can come up with is that it's similar to ricotta cheese; gritty and gelatinous. I'm guessing that's what happens when you combine the two fillings together. It's not repulsive but just a bit odd on the palate. That tidbit aside, the pies always have a fresh, quality ingredient-taste. Top it with some whipped cream and you'll moan with pleasure, lol. Highly recommended.OVERALL:Mmmmm... yessss... ooooh... ahhhh... yessss.... I'll have what she's having!
Jeff I.
Closed?Tried to visit on a Wednesday. Doors locked and no answer on the phone number...
Holly D.
Cute mom and pop business that has consecutively had great pies over the years. Definitely a staple in our house during the holiday season.
Vince N.
I've tried only one thing from S&J Bakery. My workplace orders it annually come Thanksgiving time and most recently a co-worker picked one up for us to devour as an afternoon dessert. DESSERT: Pumpkin Custard Pie First off, I'm a huge custard pie fan. Pumpkin, I'll eat but don't enjoy it as much as my eggy love. Mix the two together and you've got a damn tasty concoction. S&J's crust is the closest to my mom's homemade version, yet hers is still better ;). Flakey and moist with a surprising crunch to the exterior. The texture of the filling is my only quibble. The closest paradigm I can come up with is that it's similar to ricotta cheese; gritty and gelatinous. I'm guessing that's what happens when you combine the two fillings together. It's not repulsive but just a bit odd on the palate. That tidbit aside, the pies always have a fresh, quality ingredient-taste. Top it with some whipped cream and you'll moan with pleasure, lol. Highly recommended. OVERALL: Mmmmm... yessss... ooooh... ahhhh... yessss.... I'll have what she's having!
Paul Vargas
The Banana pie doesn’t taste like before there is hardly any banana in sorry to say it’s not the same I would never purchase it in the future.
Robert Elliott
Love love the pie, however you don't you don't deliver to the west side enough and it is very upsetting.
Chelsea R.
I had a chance to try S&J's chocolate haupia pie. The crust of their pie is flaky and crisp. Other pudding type pies I've had have fallen over after its been cut. I was pleasantly surprised to see that S&J's chocolate and haupia retain its shape. The combination of coconut flavor and chocolate is great.
Sherri C.
Banana cream pie was amazing. I picked some up at Pukalani Superette for our Christmas celebration. The pumpkin pie taste so authentic and creamy! Best pies I've had in a long time. I hope they continue to carry at my local store for a long time
T. M.
The best banana cream pies..hands down! How I miss going to Pukalani Superette to pick up some of their pies..delicious!
Kristen C.
On my dad's trips to maui, he brought us some pies from here. The first one he got for us was the strawberry cream pie. The cream feeling was good and came topped with some glazed strawberries, mmm mmm good. The second time he brought a pumpkin custard pie and that was also pretty good. Although it could have used a thicker layer of pumpkin, as there was more custard to pumpkin ratio. The crust is okay though, the one for the strawberry was a bit more flaky, however the one for the custard wasnt. So, for okay crust, i'll have to make it a 3.5 because crust is key =P. Overall cant wait to try more pies and whatever other baked goods they may have.
I've tried only one thing from S&J Bakery. My workplace orders it annually come Thanksgiving time and most recently a co-worker picked one up for us to devour as an afternoon dessert.DESSERT:Pumpkin Custard PieFirst off, I'm a huge custard pie fan. Pumpkin, I'll eat but don't enjoy it as much as my eggy love. Mix the two together and you've got a damn tasty concoction. S&J's crust is the closest to my mom's homemade version, yet hers is still better ;). Flakey and moist with a surprising crunch to the exterior. The texture of the filling is my only quibble. The closest paradigm I can come up with is that it's similar to ricotta cheese; gritty and gelatinous. I'm guessing that's what happens when you combine the two fillings together. It's not repulsive but just a bit odd on the palate. That tidbit aside, the pies always have a fresh, quality ingredient-taste. Top it with some whipped cream and you'll moan with pleasure, lol. Highly recommended.OVERALL:Mmmmm... yessss... ooooh... ahhhh... yessss.... I'll have what she's having!
Closed?Tried to visit on a Wednesday. Doors locked and no answer on the phone number...
Cute mom and pop business that has consecutively had great pies over the years. Definitely a staple in our house during the holiday season.
I've tried only one thing from S&J Bakery. My workplace orders it annually come Thanksgiving time and most recently a co-worker picked one up for us to devour as an afternoon dessert. DESSERT: Pumpkin Custard Pie First off, I'm a huge custard pie fan. Pumpkin, I'll eat but don't enjoy it as much as my eggy love. Mix the two together and you've got a damn tasty concoction. S&J's crust is the closest to my mom's homemade version, yet hers is still better ;). Flakey and moist with a surprising crunch to the exterior. The texture of the filling is my only quibble. The closest paradigm I can come up with is that it's similar to ricotta cheese; gritty and gelatinous. I'm guessing that's what happens when you combine the two fillings together. It's not repulsive but just a bit odd on the palate. That tidbit aside, the pies always have a fresh, quality ingredient-taste. Top it with some whipped cream and you'll moan with pleasure, lol. Highly recommended. OVERALL: Mmmmm... yessss... ooooh... ahhhh... yessss.... I'll have what she's having!
The Banana pie doesn’t taste like before there is hardly any banana in sorry to say it’s not the same I would never purchase it in the future.
Love love the pie, however you don't you don't deliver to the west side enough and it is very upsetting.
I had a chance to try S&J's chocolate haupia pie. The crust of their pie is flaky and crisp. Other pudding type pies I've had have fallen over after its been cut. I was pleasantly surprised to see that S&J's chocolate and haupia retain its shape. The combination of coconut flavor and chocolate is great.
Banana cream pie was amazing. I picked some up at Pukalani Superette for our Christmas celebration. The pumpkin pie taste so authentic and creamy! Best pies I've had in a long time. I hope they continue to carry at my local store for a long time
The best banana cream pies..hands down! How I miss going to Pukalani Superette to pick up some of their pies..delicious!
On my dad's trips to maui, he brought us some pies from here. The first one he got for us was the strawberry cream pie. The cream feeling was good and came topped with some glazed strawberries, mmm mmm good. The second time he brought a pumpkin custard pie and that was also pretty good. Although it could have used a thicker layer of pumpkin, as there was more custard to pumpkin ratio. The crust is okay though, the one for the strawberry was a bit more flaky, however the one for the custard wasnt. So, for okay crust, i'll have to make it a 3.5 because crust is key =P. Overall cant wait to try more pies and whatever other baked goods they may have.
Restaurantji Recommends