Tiffany's Restaurant & Bar

Let me start out by saying I love the food that Sheldon and Company fix a TIN ROOF and have been going to TIFFANY’s for many years prior to his involvement. Used to love to go treat myself to a honey walnut shrimp and a cold beverage… But just recently was in there and Quality has seriously Dropped and The prices have doubled. Portions were smaller and Quality was not as good as previous visits and anyone who wants to spend nine dollars on a draft beer needs to reevaluate visiting TIFFANY’s these days. $40 for two items – I will not be Recommending TIFFANY’s any longer.

Everything we ordered was delicious! It is family style, a la carte, Hawaiian/Asian inspired food. Derek was our server, and he began with telling us a bit about the story of the restaurant. He suggested the local favorites to try, and they did not disappoint. I would highly recommend this restaurant and our wonderful server, Derek!

What a great experience. Our friends met us there who live only five minutes away. They were amazed with the food and the service,and said they will probably be regulars .Here some pictures that will say it all

Amazing food. Fresh and local and a child-friendly service. Definitely a recommendation

Never rob yourself of the opportunity to stuff your face with marinated steak bites, garlic noodles and house-made fried rice. Don't forget the Mandoo (not pictured)! Tiffany's is always a favorite and consistently good.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Ordered the Mac salad, Cheeseburger & Saimin, and Honey Walnut Shrimp. Overall, a lovely meal with wonderful service. Cheeseburger was small but very juicy and the honey walnut shrimp was pretty delicious too. The only thing I wouldn’t order again is the Saimin as the noodles tasted a little undercooked for my preference.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Go to spot for Saimin.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Mind blowing creative thoughtful menu with top tier results. The pickles and dip were a revelation to me. Garlic noodles and spicy eggplant were so good I nearly licked the plate. The happy hour cocktails were the best I’ve had on Maui.
My husband bought the cookbook for me as a birthday gift. I’m looking forward to working my way through it.

Vegetarian options: Most interesting vegetarian selection I’ve seen on Maui.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Hamachi Sashimi, Spicy Miso Eggplant

Another Maui favorite for me. Here it’s the Miso Butterfish that I enjoy, when I’m in the mood for seafood.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Awesome food and great service.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Honey Walnut Shrimp

The best restaurant on the island. Do not miss this delicious hidden restaurant. Every bite was amazing. And very reasonable prices.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Miso Butterfish, Hamachi Sashimi

Wow, totally worth it! Seven of us went for dinner and all ordered something different so we could set up our own buffet! We ended up with 10 entrees due to how amazing everything sounded. Every dish was absolutely delicious! Service was top notch, dining hall was clean and well decorated. Can’t wait to go back!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Kim Chee Fried Rice, Honey Walnut Shrimp, Chicken Katsu, Crispy Pork Belly, Sizzling Steak Bite, Garlic Mochiko Chicken, Hamachi Sashimi, Garlic Chicken, French Fries

Very friendly staff, but unfortunately that's all. Chicken was dry and meat itself wasn't the best quality. The deep fried food had an aftertaste of old oil. Do not recommended

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 5

I will never go back again. Since the Owner change the food got much worse and way more expensive. We ordered many of our previous favorites such as the sizzling steak bites, honey walnut shrimp, crispy pork, house fried rice, mandoo, and french fries. The only I might eat again was the mandoo. The waitress was like a pushy car salesperson. She made a mistake and put our order in wrong. We ordered crispy pork and yet she ordered crispy chicken and instead of apologizing she insisted we get it the chicken too, because we "didn't order enough". Culturally and personally we don't like to make waves so we ended up with something none of us wanted to eat, and those that tried it did not care for it. The waitress also wouldn't let us only order house fried rice, and pushed us to get the kimchee fried rice too. We ended gling home with half a plate of the fried rice and almost all the crispy chicken. On top of everything else, the fried rice we ordered with over easy egg, can sunny side up. The waitress was very agumentative if we tried to question anything and completely ruined my mood, and she just wouldn't go away.... I mean even to look at my phone while I'm on it and comment on everything.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Miso Butterfish, French Fries

Before I share how ONO da food was, I had fo rave about Shelby-our server. You guys lucky fo have her! She’s an unreal, supa sweet, awesome server (w a 50’s look). Came in las night and all we cud say was…SHE’S BOMB ? Guided us da right way, everyting we ordered was amazing! Before dat, our host was BOMB too. He was supa frenly, supa engaging, good style??

Now da food? BROKE DA MOUT!!! Was our firs time since Sheldon took ova. Heard a lot about it. Was told fo get da “Oxtail soup.” Wen add da (crazy ono) pork belly to our usual steak bites and honey walnut shrimp from old days. Added da HH $6 li hing mui margarita. And we wen close em wit da furikake caramel ice cream…hhho, EVERYTING was UNREAL! My order of faves? Pork belly, “oxtail soup,” steak bites, den walnut shrimp. Summm ONO!!! Keep dis up TIFFANY’S-das wat Maui need, one ONO restaurant wea da flavas, da menu and da aesthetics (da looks inside) got mo BETTA, if dat was even possible cuz da food was ono befo. And we need dis especially fo da locals??

TIFFANY’S-You guys BOMB ? ?? Mahalo fo producing unreal BROKE DA MOUT good tasting local food ?? ???? Sheldon, ur secret formulas…dey work. Not too sweet, not too rancid…but jus right ahhh???

Mahalo nui TIFFANY’S staff

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Just Like Ox Tail Soup, Crispy Pork Belly, Steak Bites