Black Sheep Cream Co
$ • Ice Cream, Coffee ShopsAbout Black Sheep Cream Co
Customers' Favorites
Matcha Green Tea Ice Cream Matcha Made in Heaven
Black Sheep Creamery Flight
Cookie Flavor
Coffee Cream
Mister Bean
Affogato
Black Sheep Cream Co Reviews
121 ratings
Share your opinion about Black Sheep Cream Co
Delicious ice cream and the best waffle cone I've ever had! Berry Baked and Kookie Cookie are bangers.
We stumbled upon this shop and it was amazing! Such unique flavors and you can tell it’s homemade. We were told how the icecream is made, the history of the store, etc we felt so welcomed. I got the “it’s gonna be a rocky road” and it was soooo cool how they toast little marshmallows for you to put on top!
If I want ice cream? Im here. My family and I have been visiting this location for many years now. And they have never disappointed. From the flavors to the service, no complaints. Check this place out if you want to try quality ice cream!
Hours
| Monday | 10AM - 9PM |
| Tuesday | 10AM - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 10AM - 9PM |
| Thursday | 10AM - 9PM |
| Friday | 10AM - 9PM |
| Saturday | 10AM - 9PM |
| Sunday | 10AM - 9PM |
Black Sheep Cream Co. is a highly acclaimed creamery on the island, known for its friendly service and rotating flavors. It's described as a hidden gem with a cozy atmosphere, where customers can sample the homemade ice cream, including unique offerings like the "Sugar Daddy" flavor. The creamery is kid-friendly, though not wheelchair accessible. Visitors often praise the inventive flavors, such as Rocky Road with toasted marshmallows and Cereal Killer, which is creamy with a fresh cone. Many say the ice cream tastes homemade and not overly sweet, with friendly staff making the experience enjoyable. The salted crackamel and wasted chocolate are highly recommended, and customers often say they will be back to enjoy these treats again. The parking situation can be a factor, but the rotating flavors and service keep customers coming back.