Pete's Pizza is never a disappointment the food is amazing as well as a waitresses! I highly recommend it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Barbee E
Great pizza, friendly staff, family owned. Nuff said!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jared Scott
Out riding motorcycles with friends and several locals recommend Pete's. Good pizza and our server was very nice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Heidi Crouse
The best pizza with the best staff. Win, win!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rob Stout
I have ordered pizza multiple times now. The pizza is great! Pete's makes the pie consistently the same, golden crust and cheese. I make a drive to pick up this pizza and it's well worth it!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
jose molina
Worth the drive
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joshua Ort
Picked up 2 pizzas tonight. Will definitely come back! The Sparks pizza was a hit!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Dougie Noneya
Not really sure how to fairly rate this place, but here was my family and I's experience.
Service was great right off the bat. Got drinks and menus right away and waitress was friendly.
Unfortunately that's about where the good experience ended. Not the waitress fault.
When taking our order I asked for the wings with the sauce on the side. She explained that the wings are pre made and the sauce is already on them.. I am a diabetic and keto dietary so I asked if there was sugar in the sauce. She went back and asked, and was informed it's basically all sugar... So unfortunately the only other thing on the menu for me was a salad.. which was just lettuce and cheese only. Not bad but needed something else.. My wife ordered the wings and said they were some of the worst wings she has ever had... The sauce was absolutely TERRIBLE. They were overloaded in sugar and basically all you could taste. She ate 2 drowned in ranch and tossed the others... My wife and kid ordered a pizza as well to split. The pizza was ok they said but it was soaked in grease. Wasn't a fan of that, otherwise it was ok. Nothing special.
Overall, I cannot say I'd recommend this place. It's not keto or dietary friendly. The wings, pizza, and salads are not great in our opinions. $70 for 1 pizza, 8 wings, and a salad. Using a card is an up charge by the way.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
Kyle Bloom
Pete's Pizza has been a favorite in our family FOREVER so why not have them make the pizza's for our surprise wedding! Sami and the crew KILLED IT! We preordered and they had them ready on the Saturday. Everyone loved it! Thanks guys!
It's a small town bar/hangout. Pizza was above average, Nachos were ball park Nachos, a paper basket with a cup of melted cheese sauce. The beer on tap comes in a frosty mug, which was nice. Luckily we got there early about 4:45 on a Saturday by 5:30 it was standing room only! If I were in the Indinola area, I would eat there again.
Jason Krommenhoek
Found this place through reading reviews and was not let down. Cons - it is a small venue with about 10 tables and a few bar seats. Can get very noisy. Pros - Customer Service is top notch. Food is outstanding!
We started out with their large salad, which is enough for four. The lettuce is fresh and crisp the mozzarella fresh and it is appropriately doused with the dressing of your choice, I recommend the creamy Italian. My wife and I ordered small pizzas as we both like different things and the leftovers are great reheated in a air-fryer. The crust is a nice crispy crackers style crust and complements the ingredients delightfully. The sauce has great flavor and adds a great flavor to the Pizza. We have been there a couple of times and will continue to return as this is one of our favorites at this point. Worth the travel but would recommend going early or late as they have a steady crowd and are always busy.
Brent Stewart
First timers. Waitress was great with suggestions and service. A little hiccup on the sandwich, not a big deal but the owner came over and chatted. Nice touch. Loved the supreme pizza! Cheesy goodness. 😎
Matthew Donaldson
Amazing owner! Amazing food!
Tim Henward
If you come to Indianola and don't have Pete's Pizza you are a dingus and deserve whatever mediocre pizza you get elsewhere. Just go to Pete's damn it.
Pete's Pizza is never a disappointment the food is amazing as well as a waitresses! I highly recommend it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza, friendly staff, family owned. Nuff said!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Out riding motorcycles with friends and several locals recommend Pete's. Good pizza and our server was very nice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The best pizza with the best staff. Win, win!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I have ordered pizza multiple times now. The pizza is great! Pete's makes the pie consistently the same, golden crust and cheese. I make a drive to pick up this pizza and it's well worth it!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Worth the drive
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Picked up 2 pizzas tonight. Will definitely come back! The Sparks pizza was a hit!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not really sure how to fairly rate this place, but here was my family and I's experience.
Service was great right off the bat. Got drinks and menus right away and waitress was friendly.
Unfortunately that's about where the good experience ended. Not the waitress fault.
When taking our order I asked for the wings with the sauce on the side. She explained that the wings are pre made and the sauce is already on them.. I am a diabetic and keto dietary so I asked if there was sugar in the sauce. She went back and asked, and was informed it's basically all sugar... So unfortunately the only other thing on the menu for me was a salad.. which was just lettuce and cheese only. Not bad but needed something else.. My wife ordered the wings and said they were some of the worst wings she has ever had... The sauce was absolutely TERRIBLE. They were overloaded in sugar and basically all you could taste. She ate 2 drowned in ranch and tossed the others... My wife and kid ordered a pizza as well to split. The pizza was ok they said but it was soaked in grease. Wasn't a fan of that, otherwise it was ok. Nothing special.
Overall, I cannot say I'd recommend this place. It's not keto or dietary friendly. The wings, pizza, and salads are not great in our opinions. $70 for 1 pizza, 8 wings, and a salad. Using a card is an up charge by the way.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 5
Pete's Pizza has been a favorite in our family FOREVER so why not have them make the pizza's for our surprise wedding! Sami and the crew KILLED IT! We preordered and they had them ready on the Saturday. Everyone loved it! Thanks guys!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great place
Restaurantji Recommends
It's a small town bar/hangout. Pizza was above average, Nachos were ball park Nachos, a paper basket with a cup of melted cheese sauce. The beer on tap comes in a frosty mug, which was nice. Luckily we got there early about 4:45 on a Saturday by 5:30 it was standing room only! If I were in the Indinola area, I would eat there again.
Found this place through reading reviews and was not let down.
Cons - it is a small venue with about 10 tables and a few bar seats. Can get very noisy.
Pros - Customer Service is top notch. Food is outstanding!
We started out with their large salad, which is enough for four. The lettuce is fresh and crisp the mozzarella fresh and it is appropriately doused with the dressing of your choice, I recommend the creamy Italian.
My wife and I ordered small pizzas as we both like different things and the leftovers are great reheated in a air-fryer.
The crust is a nice crispy crackers style crust and complements the ingredients delightfully. The sauce has great flavor and adds a great flavor to the Pizza.
We have been there a couple of times and will continue to return as this is one of our favorites at this point. Worth the travel but would recommend going early or late as they have a steady crowd and are always busy.
First timers. Waitress was great with suggestions and service. A little hiccup on the sandwich, not a big deal but the owner came over and chatted. Nice touch. Loved the supreme pizza! Cheesy goodness. 😎
Amazing owner! Amazing food!
If you come to Indianola and don't have Pete's Pizza you are a dingus and deserve whatever mediocre pizza you get elsewhere. Just go to Pete's damn it.
Loading...