Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs

Name: Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs
Address: 1014 Main St, Buhl, Idaho, 83316, US
Telephone: (208) 543-5210
Price range: $
Rating: 4.1

$ • Pizza, Italian

Hours:
1014 Main St, Buhl
(208) 543-5210

Take-Out/Delivery Options

take-out

Customers' Favorites

Italian Combo Sandwich

Garlic Cheese Bread

Sub Sandwich

Pizza

Steak

Sub

Papa Kelsey's Pizza & Subs Reviews

4.1 (24)

Write a review

February 2024

Oh my! Size matters ??I ordered a whole tukey bacon sandwich. ?Got home, opened the bag, and -Hello come in Tokyo! It was huge and super yummmm ?I could only eat half ? - but now I have another meal ?Atmosphere - it's cute inside. I love the cow art. ?Service - I was looking over the menu on the wall, trying to find (The One) lol.The young lady that took our order rushed us to order. ??The young man brought our 'Togo' order out to us - that was very kind ?The food is worth a...read full review

February 2023

This is the best place for a sandwich in Buhl. It's easy to miss because it doesn't look like much from the outside! I was surprised to find out they have some breakfast options like a breakfast sandwich, breakfast pizza, breakfast burrito and biscuits and gravy. I tried the bacon, egg sand cheese breakfast sandwich and it was very good. The fresh made bread is a winner. Lots of tables inside to eat your sandwich or pizza. I will definitely go back when I'm town.

November 2022

I always get the Italian Combo Sandwich when I go to Papa Kelsey’s. I always get the 16” whole size. I normally split it when another person. It might not fill you both up completely, but it’s enough to get you both to your next meal. If you were to try to eat the whole sandwich yourself, you probably wouldn’t have to eat again for the rest of the day. The sandwich is delicious and full of meat and if you split it, it’s inexpensive. I’ve been getting these subs here...read full review

More Reviews(91)