50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Eagle

“Idaho pizza makes the best crust! We just ordered their 'two topping' special with mushrooms and chopped garlic - awesome combo and you could really enjoy the flavors of this pizza. Try them - this was the Eagle location!“

“This was my first experience with Flying Pie, and overall, the pizza was quite good. However, it wasn't as hot as we had hoped, which is something to consider with delivery. I'm looking forward to trying them again at the Eagle location.“

“Tate made my pizza perfectly!! She is so amazing!!“

“Would not take 100 even though it came from my bank... how do you use money? I get it, have it on your card. lol. the staff was apologetic because they are told if they accept 100 bills they get in trouble. There needs to be some trust. I can't believe PM is having and overrun of 100 bill users. actually I never use them but this time I happen to had forgotten my card. I live here, I will give you my address or whatever. made to feel like a criminal for spending hard earned money.“

“I left pics and comments regarding food. But wanted to update this. I called them and requested refund and they are sending me a gift card. They were very nice and were very apologetic. They get 5 star rating for service!!!.“

“It took me longer to find my phone to order the pizza than for it to be delivered. Under 15 minutes and pizza was fresh. Matthew delivered with a smile, but I would, too, if I had teleportation powers.“

“Love this place there my 2nd family and always kisses“

“Best pizza place in the valley! My husband and I have been coming here since we first started dating 5 years ago and the food is 10/10 every time. We always leave happy and full. They have a very large menu, we are very basic and stick to the pepperoni pizza and fries, but everything looks and smells delicious. Service is spectacular, they have great memories and make sure we always have everything we need. Short wait times and great pool tables to play at. Definitely give them a try!!!“

“I went with my friend for Happy Hour! The margarita I had was excellent! Well balanced flavor! I also had the meatballs as an appetizer. They were perfectly spicy, held together perfectly, size was perfect too! (Yes it does deserve to have 3 “perfect” descriptions). I can’t remember the name of the salad I had, but I told many people that it had a White Balsamic Dressing, it was light and bright, veggies were cool and crispy. I can’t wait to go back! 10/10 will have again!“

“The food was fantastic! We had the curry vegetable and the butter chicken pizzas. Definitely check this place out, you will not be disappointed.“

“we are visiting from Utah for a few days. we randomly chose to go to Romio's for dinner. what a great choice! we ordered Greek platter. there was enough food there for two of us. our food came out to us nice and hot and absolutely delicious! we were so full that we had to take our tiramisu to go. our waiter was very attentive, friendly and knowledgeable about the menu. we highly recommend Romio's. we' ll be back the next time we come to Boise. Mike and Chris Quick“

“We visited Margherita Pizza for the first time tonight. Seeing a wood fired oven in a pizza restaurant is a good first sign. A friendly, personable staff is the second. Tasting a fresh salad, refreshing Italian soda, and delicious pizza (in a style very similar to what we had in Italy) sealed the deal for us! They just gained two more loyal customers.“

“The barkeep was awesome and let us try several taps to find what we liked. Also received a free small pizza for being an educator. Love this place!! The Zambini has been my go to comfort pizza for 25 years!!

Vegetarian options: Love the sourdough crust!“

“We dined in with our two little kids. We dine out when eating because our kids can be a lot sometimes. We rolled into Flying Pie around 5:45 and the server Cody was on top of his game. We were very pleased with his service…something that is hard to find these days.

Thank you for the great food, cold beers and great service.

We will be back.“

“Good amazing!!! Order puf n stuff perfect starter pizza so good!!! Salads so big“

“My Family visited Proper Pizza for the 1st time tonight. The best thin crust pizza in the valley. The man who served us was so friendly and nice. We will be back!“

“Super friendly staff, the pizza was done on time, and on top of that the pizza is great. I don’t think you can find a better place in Boise!“

“I lived in New England for a long time and also parts of New York for a couple years, 42nd Street slices in downtown was great . I also had pizza from the oldest pizza joint in Connecticut. When I moved to Idaho I was worried about finding a NY style pizza that not only looked the part but tasted great as well......FUGET ABOUT IT, no need to look any further ! Jonny Bronx is like eating at home.“

“I have been here with my kiddos but we are from out of town, so I had to return with my entire family to make another great experience & to make great memories! Highly recommend best experience & best pizza I have ever ate.“

“while I love Uncle Bob's probably should have prepared for the Halloween rush better. I ordered at 2:30 for pick up at 5:15, got there and was told it would be an additional 20 to 30 minutes. I did feel bad for the staff because people were angry. Just a suggestion for next year!“

“Westside is awesome, we have tried all of the local pizza joints and landed on Westside. Their service and pizza is great and they never take 90-120 min to get it to my house like all of the other pizza joints. I made a small comment on my delivery order asking for them to make sure to pay attention to how I ordered my pizza, it was nothing major. To my suprise, the owner delivered the pizza himself and apologized as he felt I had left the comment out of frustration. I really wasn't upset at all but it showed me how serious they are about getting it right. Nowadays, that is hard to find. Thank you Westside!“

“LOVE THEIR PIZZA?? The Gent that helped my Son and I great personality and eyes.“

“I got food from this location for the first time, I like the pizza, it’s one of the rare places that offers sourdough crust! We love it!

They had accidentally made our breadsticks out of regular crust and one of the workers caught the mistake and remade it before I got there to pick it up.“

“First time at Idaho Pizza in Eagle and it won’t be our last! Mike was the cashier on the day we were there (Friday 10/18). He has a very warm, friendly demeanor and even brought us some extra cinnamon knots the kitchen had on hand. He and Rory were great at keeping the restaurant perfectly clean — always noticing what needed to be bussed or swept. Unlike employees at many other restaurants these days who just stand around oblivious, these guys were always looking for what needed to be done. And the cook who brought us our pizza was very attentive and kind (didn’t catch his name… he has tattoos on his arms). Pizza was 10/10!!! Donna, the assistant manager was warm, too! Thank you, staff at Idaho Pizza, for making our lunch experience a great one!“

“Words cannot express the elation I felt after taking my first bite of the pizza from Chicago Fire. After moving to Idaho over 8 years ago, we have been repeatedly disappointed by other “Chicago-style pizza” restaurants. Chicago Fire gets it right. I’ve been dying for a true thin-crust pizza for literal years, only fulfilling my craving during trips back to the Midwest. Thank you for coming to Meridian!“

“I tried this place for the first time via Uber Eats or DoorDash on 10/25/24. It was so good my roommate and I went in person the next day, and then I ordered it online AGAIN on Sunday. Today 11/1 I went in person again for lunch. I got the limited time menu chicken pesto pizza (It was incredible) the salad bar & a drink. I tell everyone I don’t like pizza, but I can’t say that anymore. this place has converted me. I’m obsessed with their salad bar, they have everything I love. I’m upset that I’ve lived less than a mile away from here for over 2 and a half years and I’m just now trying them out. 10/10 I will recommend them to literally everyone“

“This place could be better but they refused to make it easier on those of us that have pizza stones. The instructions for pizza stones say "preheat pizza stone in the oven". Spoke to a manager once that said just bring the pizza stone in and we will build the pizza on it. Not exactly a solution. I'm not taking a pizza stone that's over 300 degrees and driving it to their store. All they really have to do is flip the crust over and dust it with flour on one side so it slides off of their disposable Pizza Pan. Or dust the top and flip it onto a new pan before building the pizza on the top. They really do need to explain why I bought the pizza stone in the first place. I bought it because I like their pizza and I like using a pizza stone but now it's a useless piece of equipment in my cabinet.“

“We have been ordering Diggs Pizza for years! Why change when they are the best!?!? Amazing quality at great prices. Try to just eat 2 slices, but it's so good, we always end up eating more and getting stuffed!! ? Thank you for an amazing meal, every time!“

“We got a 20” Cheese pizza to go and it was phenomenal. Delicious, thin, NY Style pizza. We were absolutely thrilled and looking forward to trying the rest of the menu.“

“We got a thin crust, and it was literally perfect! Can’t believe I’d never tried it, and I pass it daily. 🍕“

“We were in town visiting family and our son brought us here and we were not disappointed. There was plenty of seating and the staff was very pleasant. Ordering was easy and our pizzas were brought to our table without much of a wait. The pizzas were really good and we'd definitely come back.“

“I went here for my Birthday. And I loved every bite of my pizza

Kid-friendliness: Area is big enough for small children. No playground.

Wheelchair accessibility: You can move chairs around to sit up to table.“

“Best white slice in Idaho!!!!!“

“My family decided to call in for pizza on valentines day and I was selected to go pick up our food. The service was quick and the atmosphere was nice. The staff was highly helpful and quick to get me my order. The lovely to check me was Grace, she was very nice and friendly she even gave me candy!“

“One of the best pizzas in Boise!“

“Bomb pizza, killer service and delicious Sriracha/ranch sauce!! 10/10 🙌🏻😍“

“I lived in New England for a long time and also parts of New York for a couple years, 42nd Street slices in downtown was great . I also had pizza from the oldest pizza joint in Connecticut. When I moved to Idaho I was worried about finding a NY style pizza that not only looked the part but tasted great as well......FUGET ABOUT IT, no need to look any further ! Jonny Bronx is like eating at home.“

“Papa Murphy’s is a fantastic choice for take-and-bake pizza, and it’s become a go-to spot for us. The convenience is unbeatable—you can walk in, pick up a freshly made pizza, and bring it home to bake when you’re ready. It’s perfect for busy nights or when you want something quick without sacrificing quality.

The pizza itself is consistently delicious. They have a great variety of options, from classic favorites to more creative combinations, so there’s something for everyone. The ingredients are fresh, and you can taste the difference in every bite. We especially love the fact that you can customize your pizza just how you like it. Plus, the cheesy bread and cookie dough are fun add-ons that make it feel like a real treat at home.

Baking it at home is easy, and it always comes out piping hot and perfectly done. It’s a lot fresher than traditional takeout, and the kitchen fills with that amazing pizza smell, which makes the whole experience even better.

We go to Papa Murphy’s a lot because it’s just so convenient, and the quality never disappoints. It’s also budget-friendly for the whole family, especially considering the portion sizes. For a takeout pizza place, Papa Murphy’s really does a great job. If you haven’t tried it, it’s definitely worth a visit!“

“Titus, Sye, Kenna, Nasaria, Mia, Dewey, Isabella, Ethan, Kevyn, and Sean-Luc are such a fantastic crew and amazing people. Nick is a fabulous GM and is always very kind to me and the AM John is such an amazing person.
The pizza is always good too. 😁 10/10 would recommend.“

“The BEST pizza we’ve had in so long . I can’t remember pizza tasting as good as Idaho Pizza Company tasted . We had delivery to our air b and b . They were prompt and brought things we didn’t think to ask for when we ordered but remembered to ask first when the pizza arrived . Honestly truly the best pizza we’ve had in years .“

“Dominic Is a good worker“

“I was craving an eat coast style Stromboli and man I love the way they make them here. 😎👍🏼great team there too.“

“Tried for the first time and wasn’t disappointed. We got the fried zucchini to start with and it was wonderful. Food came out and we realized their pasta portions could feed 2-3 people a plate ? was extreme yummy. Service was good, person in front seemed scared, “deer in the headlights” look the whole time we interacted. He came over to our table at the end and kinda got in our bubble so that was a little awkward. But our server herself was nice! It’s a cute place to check out.“

“Elijah is the MAN!
I just went to pick up my pie, he started to hand it to me and pulled away and said, "let me have them fix this." I said, "what, was it broken?!"
He said, "there wasn't enough pepperoni on it."
I had previously complained via the website, but those complaints go to corporate. Come to find out, my last visit I complimented him on the quality (actually picked up in the drive through, then pulled around front and went in to thank them). MONTHS AGO, was when I complained to corporate. After talking to Elijah, I sent another comment, this time a very positive compliment...right after my visit, corporate sent his boss the negative comments from months ago. Lame.
Fast forward, hey boss man, Elijah is STILL killing it! Give that man a raise! He is kind, friendly, and taking great care of your customers - he should be rewarded!
I write this so that the owners know for sure that he is an honest man, and puts his all into providing a great product for his customers!
If you are looking for a great pie, this is your place! SL NY can't be beat!“

“Great service. Great food, will definitely go again“

“The meatball and Italian subs were so delish… we will be back!“

“Their focaccia bread is to die for!! Soooo flavorful. I always get it with their oil & herb dip. I’m obsessed!! And then don’t even get me started on their chicken Alfredo…. It’s just the best. The chicken is so flavorful and it’s cooked perfectly. I wish I could just eat here every single day of my life. Best Italian restaurant we have in the state.“

“Everything was fine. The staff was really nice. The one wierd thing is something messed up and my order was paid by someone i didn't know. They fixed it though. The pizza and food was good.But expensive!!! $40 for food I have to take home and cook? I don't understand why it's so expensive, You'd think it would be less. Everything was nice except for the price,
Ridiculous“

“I went in to purchase a gift card to give a friend. I was greeted as soon as I walked in and it was quick and easy to get the card. I love going to Papa Murphy's. Their pizza is awesome (especially the garlic chicken thin crust). I like giving their gift cards as presents, I mean who doesn't like pizza!?! I definitely recommend Papa Murphy's if you want that home cooked goodness.“

“Chicago Connection has been what I consider a fun time staple growing up. I love their pizza. They're still going strong and I would highly recommend a family and friends or personally just enjoying how delicious they truly are. They have many other options other than pizza you can try as well. Just give it a try❣️“