Garcia's Mexican Restaurant

1599 Yellowstone Ave, Pocatello
(208) 813-9013

Recent Reviews

Fozzie T.

Pathetic. Small portions, high prices, and dry as a desert. Lousy experience. Not good.

Jennifer T.

Um! if this is Nick Garcia's Restaurant- 10 stars! In the old Perkins spot. If this is Garcia's by Costco - How are they even still open? They get -10 stars! Let's just say we only went there once when they 1st opened! 1 and done! The server dumped our drinks on me- 2 waters, 1 soda and an adult bev! yep the adult bev was mine. But I didn't want to wear them all! and I actually could and do cook better than they served!! Go see Nick at the old Perkins and the one that replaced Uncle Jim's! If this page is for the Garcia's by Costco in Pocatello- avoid at all cost

SnO Tetra

Looks nice, great service, good chips n salsa. That's it, though. The food was so bland and no flavor at all. Didn't finish it. I thought I had covid for a sec.

Rachelle O.

This was the blandest food I have ever eaten in my life, absolutely no flavor. Salsa tasted like it was from a jar, the rice was completely tasteless. The only thing nice about this place was the decor.

Stephanie Woodrow-Imlay

Really happy with the service and food here! We are from Las Vegas and visiting Pocatello, ID and it’s a snowy day. We decided to stop in for lunch on a whim. We’ll be back! The food was great, and service was even better.

Heath Mckinney

Good food/atmosphere, friendly staff. Loved the Charro beans!

Roger Sykes

Food was great and service too, Phoenix location on Thomas

Tyler Jensen

Great food and great serving sizes. Was a little pricy but you do get a lot of food. Service was really good and the restaurant has a great atmosphere.

Mark Nelson

I visited today with my friend and we’re not impressed to say the least. The guacamole ? was terrible with no flavor at all and it started to turn dark. That’s no bueno!~ The next thing is the “bean dip” that was served with the salsa, let’s just say it tasted like canned refried beans, nothing special and that’s another strike. I asked the waitress about the texture and said it was made with cream cheese. I didn’t taste any cream cheese, it tasted like the texture of canned refried beans. The cheese enchilada was flat in appearance and no flavor and it was nothing special. The refried beans that were on my plate were completely different from the ones served in the “bean dip”. They were good to the taste. I really enjoyed the rice, that was the best part of the whole meal. The salsa tasted like it was from a can or a bottle not made fresh on premise, too salty!! The chips were fried there which was a plus and my biggest pet peeve’s. Overall I gave them 3 stars ⭐️ and that was generous. The waitress was really polite and attentive.

Layne R.

They have moved to a new location on Pocatello Creek Rd. This could have been a good thing. The new location and interior are much better. But, alas, things are not so much better. Food is moderate. You can not get a beer. And, don't even think about a Margarita. Aínt happening.

Joshua Risley

Had a really amazing night with my girlfriend at Garcia’s with some amazing food and absolutely fantastic service from our waiter his name was Coltin he was so very nice and didn’t bother us too much or too little and always came over to help us out when we needed something. They made my steak perfect when I asked for medium rare it came with 2 shrimp skewers with 6-7 shrimp on each. The marinade and seasoning on the steak is absolutely to die for. It was my second time here and it has been impressive both times. My girlfriend got the Tampico stuffed chicken and it was pretty good although the cream cheese on it was really thick but still enjoyable. To all reading this go spend 30$-40$ and enjoy yourself with wonderful service at Garcias

Valerie Johnson

Delicious food and friendly staff. I got the spinach and cheese quesadillas with charro beans and delicious mixed vegetables. I forgot to take a pic though.?

Maxwell LeFevre

Excellent service with excellent food! This restaurant is pretty quick to get your food out and everything is absolutely amazing!! My personal favorite dish here is the Tampico Chicken! There is super nice table service and every time you come you get chips and salsa!

Mike Despot

Beautiful and clean restaurant. Looks expensive but with good prices and great food. A real value. Our server Mandy was so present and efficient. My wife loved the fajita and I totally enjoyed my taco combo. Chips two salsas and a bean dip came with the chips. The food came out quickly. Our drinks were refilled as needed. We will be back many times.

Ryan F.

I should have waited to post my review, about 2 hours after eating i got the worst diarrhea i have had in years. I ended up having to rinse my underwear out in a gas station sink.

Load More