11 Best Pizza Restaurants in Rexburg

“great food. the pizza was on point“

“This place was wonderful!! We'd just come back from Yellowstone and were starving! I'd never tried a curry pizza but it was amazing!! We got a bunch of sides too that were fantastic! They were very accommodating for my toddler. They brought her a water cup with a lid. They also brought us each some rice pudding which was so sweet of them! I don't have any pictures because we were so hungry and the food was so good. Next time I am in town I want to come again! Thank you for the wonderful experience!!“

“Came to town to visit family and an ad for this place was with my hotel key. We decided to try it out not only was it deliver super fast but it was piping hot when we got it. Amazing pizza I will definitely be ordering again on this trip!“

“Huge shoutout to this Papa John’s team—they’re doing it right! Orders are always on point, the pizza is consistently fresh and delicious, and the service is top-tier. You can feel the teamwork and positive vibe as soon as you walk in. It’s not just good pizza, it’s a great experience every time.“

“Not only did I get three glorious pizzas that were ready on time, but as I walked into the store, a hand popped up from behind the counter waving and saying hi to me by name. I approached the counter to see if Papa Murphy's was employing Santa's elves during the summer months, but that didn't make much sense, because I'm on the naughty list, so they never greet me in such a friendly way.
Turns out, it was someone way cooler than any elf. It was Eliza!
Eliza and her awesome co-workers were super cheerful, and I was thrilled to know I was getting pizza made with the same joy and skill that Santa's elves have when making toys.
Come to think of it, if the manager came down my chimney every Christmas Eve and put a pizza in my oven, I'd probably try to get back on the nice list.
Thank you Santa Manager and your happy Pizza Elves!“

“My favorite place to eat!“

“food was great, service was lacking. server did not come check in our table one time after food was delivered to the table. ended up getting another server to get us a to go box and our server to get our check. won't be back to dine in as service was inadequate. pick up or delivery is best way here!!!!“

“That guy Jaren was a boss! I personally have always hated pizza and I went in to tell the Pizza Hut employees how awful their pizza is. Seeing that man in his Pizza Love hat made me see pizza in a whole new light. I spent over $300 because of his good vibes and sweet pies. I have now devoted my life as a Pizza Hut missionary, telling the world about this wonderful Italian flatbread. I hope to one day be as cool and inspirational as Jaren.“

“We stopped in Rexburg for the evening and tried this little hidden gem. Great food, staff, and atmosphere. Everything was made to perfection and I can’t wait to stop in again when I am in town.“

“They were wonderful. Someone instantly jumped to help, everyone was smiling, patient, helpful,“

“I just wanted to share my great experience. I had here at Little Caesars. Riley with the pizza bucket hat was able to help me. He greeted me with a smile and everybody in front of me he greeted them with smiles and a good energy and that’s something that we need in today’s society. He gave me a pizza. It was fresh. It tasted good. It’s quality pizza. Little Caesars always is gonna be the best bang for your buck when it comes to pizza and this location is no exception.“